pil pil sauce
intro
Silky, garlicky, gently spicy Basque pil pil is a luxuriously emulsified olive oil sauce paired with tender poached salt cod, boasting a velvety texture and warm, bright flavor.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep Aromatic Ingredients
Set the olive wood cutting board in its fixed left-of-center position. Use the paring knife to thinly slice 6 peeled garlic cloves into uniform 2mm thick slices. Slit the 2 dried guindilla peppers lengthwise, shake out and discard loose inner seeds, then tear into 3cm pieces. Finely chop 2 tablespoons of fresh flat-leaf parsley and transfer it to the small terracotta ramekin.
Warm Olive Oil Gently
Place the terracotta cazuela in its center counter position. Pour all 200ml of extra-virgin olive oil into the cazuela, and heat over the lowest possible stovetop setting until the oil reaches 60C (140F). The oil should feel warm to the touch, with no shimmer, bubbles, or smoke — high heat at this stage will ruin the final emulsion.
Fry Garlic and Peppers
Add the sliced garlic and seeded guindilla pieces to the warm oil. Cook over the lowest heat for 3-4 minutes, stirring occasionally with the olive wood whisk, until the garlic turns pale translucent gold. Do not let the garlic darken to deep brown, as this will add a bitter flavor to the sauce. Use the fine-mesh skimmer to lift the fried garlic and peppers out of the oil, and set them aside on a small square of parchment paper on the corner of the cutting board to use as garnish.
Poach Cod Slowly
Pat the desalted salt cod completely dry with a corner of the striped linen towel. Place the cod pieces skin-side down into the warm, garlic-infused oil. Maintain the lowest possible heat, keeping the oil at a steady 65C (149F) — no bubbles should break the oil surface. Poach for 6-8 minutes, until the flesh is just opaque and flaky, and milky, sticky cod gelatin has leached out of the skin into the surrounding oil. Boiling the cod will make the flesh tough and prevent a stable emulsion.
Rest Cod Temporarily
Use the fine-mesh skimmer to carefully lift the poached cod pieces out of the oil, transferring them to the terracotta serving plate at the back right of the counter. Leave all the gelatin-infused oil in the cazuela. Turn off the heat under the pan, and let the oil cool for 2 minutes until it reaches 50C (122F), the ideal temperature for a stable emulsion.
Whisk to Emulsify
Return the cazuela to the lowest heat setting. Use the olive wood whisk to stir the oil in slow, steady circular motions, pressing gently against the bottom and sides of the terracotta pan to collect the settled cod gelatin. Continue whisking consistently for 4-5 minutes, as the oil gradually thickens into a silky, opaque, pale golden sauce that coats the back of a spoon. If the sauce shows signs of separating (greasy, shiny pools on the surface), remove the pan from heat for 30 seconds and keep whisking until it binds again.
Combine Cod and Sauce
Nestle the reserved poached cod pieces back into the thickened pil pil sauce in the cazuela. Tilt the pan gently and swirl to coat every piece of fish completely in sauce. Warm together over the lowest heat for 1 minute, just to bring the cod back to serving temperature. Taste the sauce, and add a tiny pinch of flaky sea salt only if needed — desalted cod retains enough salt that extra seasoning is rarely required.
Plate and Garnish
Transfer the sauced cod to the terracotta serving plate, arranging the fish in a loose cluster in the plate’s center with sauce pooling gently around it. Top with the reserved fried garlic slices, guindilla pieces, and a generous sprinkle of chopped parsley from the ramekin. Serve immediately with slices of crusty sourdough to soak up extra sauce.
Tips
2.Always use a wooden whisk and terracotta pan for emulsification: the slight friction between the porous wood and earthenware helps draw cod gelatin into the oil, creating a more stable, velvety sauce than metal whisks or non-stick pans can produce.
3.If your sauce refuses to thicken after 5 minutes of steady whisking, stir in 1 teaspoon of ice-cold water and whisk vigorously off heat for 60 seconds: the cold temperature shock helps the gelatin bind the oil into a smooth emulsion without making the sauce runny.

OMG this pil pil sauce is a total game changer! I was so nervous to make it because I heard emulsifying olive oil can be a total messy disaster, but following the 20 minute timeline worked perfectly. My whole family devoured the salt cod at our Sunday dinner, even my super picky 8 year old asked for seconds! SO good, I’m already planning to make a big batch for our next neighborhood tapas potluck.
Tried this last night after a weekend cod fishing trip up in the Sound (full transparency: I skipped the salt curing step and used super fresh catch, don’t come for me purists). The sauce still came out silky, garlicky, perfectly rich without being heavy. Paired it with roasted asparagus and crusty sourdough to soak up every last drop off the plate. 10/10, no notes, will make again as soon as I catch more fish.
Quick question for the group and the chef! Has anyone tried making this with a plant-based fish substitute? I’m cooking for my sister who’s vegan next week and I’m obsessed with this sauce’s garlicky, rich flavor, wondering if it would pair well with hearts of palm “cod” or if the texture would be off? Also, can I make the sauce a day ahead for meal prep to cut down on day-of cooking?
Took me two whole tries to get the emulsion right the first time I attempted pil pil a few years back, but this recipe’s clear step-by-step made it totally foolproof! Cook time was spot on 20 minutes, no extra fuss or fancy tools needed. My partner said it tasted exactly like the version we had at a tiny pintxo bar in Bilbao when we visited a couple summers ago. Wild how just a few simple ingredients come together to make something that flavorful.
Brought this to my neighborhood block party potluck last weekend and people were literally hovering over the platter asking for the recipe! I added a tiny pinch of smoked red pepper flakes for a subtle little heat kick, which went over so well. The salt cod was perfectly tender, and the sauce had that gorgeous glossy sheen that makes everyone go “ooooh” when you set the dish down. Will absolutely be a permanent entry in my go-to potluck recipe rotation.
Uh oh, my sauce broke the first time I tried this! I think I had the heat too high because I was rushing to get dinner on the table before my book club showed up. Is there a quick fix for separated pil pil, or did I totally ruin the batch?
This is such a perfect weeknight win! 20 minutes is exactly the window I have after getting home from spin class before I need to wrangle the kids through homework and bedtime. I portioned the leftover cod and sauce over roasted baby potatoes for my lunches this week, and it reheated like an absolute dream. My kids loved it so much they asked if we can have “that garlicky silky fish” every Friday for our family dinner night.
Made this for my anniversary dinner with my wife last night, and she said it’s the best thing I’ve ever cooked for her! I served it with crispy pan con tomate and a glass of dry albariño, total restaurant-level vibe. Quick question though—can I use regular unsalted cod if I don’t have time to source salt cod and do the multi-day soak? I had to run to three stores to find salt cod for this batch, and I want to add this to my regular weeknight rotation!