Butter-Basted Steak
intro
Crisp, golden-seared steak basted in nutty brown butter, garlic, and woody herbs, with a juicy, evenly pink center. Restaurant-worthy results in under 30 minutes for a cozy, special meal.
Ingredients
Steps
Pat Dry and Season
After letting steaks temper at room temperature for 30 minutes to ensure even cooking, place them on the maple end-grain cutting board. Tear sheets from the unbleached paper towel roll to pat every surface (top, bottom, and thick side edges) completely dry, pressing firmly to wick away all surface moisture. Season all sides evenly with 1 tsp kosher salt and ½ tsp coarsely ground black pepper, pressing the seasoning gently into the meat to ensure it adheres.
Heat Cast Iron Skillet
Place the 12-inch seasoned cast iron skillet on the centered gas burner, turn heat to medium-high. Add 1 tbsp neutral high-smoke-point avocado oil to the pan, and heat for 3-4 minutes until the oil is shimmering and just beginning to send up thin wispy trails of smoke. Do not let the oil darken or burn, as this will create bitter off-flavors.
Sear First Steak Side
Use the stainless steel tongs to carefully lay both steaks in the hot skillet, laying them away from your body to avoid hot oil splatter. Leave 2cm of space between the steaks to allow air circulation for even searing. Do not move, press, or prod the steaks once placed. Sear for 3 minutes exactly, until the bottom surface forms a deep, crisp, golden-brown crust with no soft, gray patches.
Flip and Add Aromatics
Use the tongs to flip both steaks to their uncooked second side. Immediately add 3 tbsp unsalted butter, 3 crushed garlic cloves, 1 rosemary sprig, and 3 thyme sprigs to the skillet, tucking the herbs and garlic into the melting butter around the steaks. Let the second side sear for 1 minute before starting to baste, to allow an initial crust to form.
Baste with Brown Butter
Tilt the skillet slightly toward you so the melted butter pools at the front lower edge of the pan. Use the stainless steel basting spoon to continuously scoop the foaming, nutty-smelling golden brown butter, garlic, and herbs over the top of the steaks. Baste steadily for 4-5 minutes, pausing to check internal temperature with the instant-read thermometer: remove steaks when the thickest part registers 125°F (52°C) for medium-rare, or 135°F (57°C) for medium. Spoon butter directly over the garlic and herbs as you baste to release their aromatic oils into the fat.
Rest Cooked Steaks
Use the tongs to transfer the cooked steaks to the matte cream speckled stoneware dinner plate. Spoon 1 tbsp of the browned butter and herb mixture over the top of the steaks, then tent loosely with a small sheet of aluminum foil. Let rest for 5 full minutes to allow muscle fibers to relax and redistribute juices; skipping this step will cause juices to run out onto the plate when slicing, leading to dry steak.
Slice and Finish
After 5 minutes of resting, transfer the steaks back to the maple end-grain cutting board. Hold the 8-inch chef knife at a 45-degree angle to slice the steaks against the grain into 1.5cm thick slices, preserving the crisp seared crust on each piece. Arrange the sliced steak fanned across the center of the same matte cream stoneware dinner plate, drizzle any collected resting juices from the plate over the top, and finish with a light, even sprinkle of ¼ tsp flaky sea salt.
Tips
2.Do not move, press, or prod steaks during the initial 3-minute sear: leaving them undisturbed allows the crust to form fully and evenly; moving them early will tear the developing crust and prevent consistent browning.
3.Remove steaks from the pan 5°F below your target finished temperature: residual carryover cooking will raise the internal temperature by 5°F as the steaks rest, ensuring you hit your ideal doneness without overcooking the meat into dry, tough texture.

OMG, this butter-basted steak method is a total game changer! I made this for my family dinner last night, used a ribeye like the recipe suggested, threw in some garlic and thyme with the butter, and my kids literally asked for seconds before they even finished their first bite. 12 minute cook time was spot on for my 1.5 inch thick steak, came out perfect medium rare. SO good, I’ll never make steak another way again!
Super solid recipe, perfect for meal prep! I made two of these on Sunday, sliced them up, and they’ve been amazing tossed in salads and with roasted veggies all week. The only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is I wish the recipe mentioned venting your range hood a little more – my smoke alarm went off twice when searing on high heat lol. Still delicious though!
Made this last weekend for a post-hike date night in, and wow. The butter baste gives the steak that rich, nutty flavor you only get at fancy steakhouses for like $50 a plate. I added a little rosemary from my windowsill plant and it was chef’s kiss. 10/10, will make again.
Uh, full transparency, I’ve never cooked a steak that didn’t come out tough or totally overcooked before this. Medium difficulty felt intimidating but the 12 minute cook time was broken down so easy to follow, I didn’t mess it up! My roommate thought I ordered takeout, no cap.
Wait y’all, I brought this butter-basted steak to my neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were hovering around the platter before I even set it down. I did add a little paprika and garlic powder to the seasoning rub, and the butter baste had a dash of Worcestershire, and it was unreal. My neighbor begged me for the recipe, I just sent her the link!
Made this in my tiny dorm kitchen on my cast iron, honestly thought I’d set off the whole building fire alarm but it was worth every second. The steak came out so juicy, I ate the whole thing standing up over my stove because I couldn’t wait to sit down. 10/10, no notes.
This is my new go-to weeknight dinner! It’s keto friendly, comes together so fast, and tastes way more fancy than the effort it takes. I paired mine with roasted asparagus and a little side of cauliflower mash, and my husband said it’s better than the steak we got on our anniversary dinner last month.
Quick question, I only have a thin cut steak (like an inch thick max) – will this method still work? I don’t want to overcook it, I’ve been craving a good butter basted steak for weeks!
Made this for my dad’s 70th birthday dinner, he’s a total steak snob who swears by his old charcoal grill method, and even he said it was one of the best steaks he’s ever had. The butter baste with garlic and thyme made the whole house smell incredible for hours after we cooked. Win in my book!
Bro, I make steak all the time for my food truck pop ups and I’m stealing this basting method. The nutty brown butter mixed with the garlic and thyme adds such a deep flavor, my customers are gonna lose their minds. Already tested it on my roommates, they gave it 10/10.
Okay so I forgot to let my steak come to room temp first like the recipe said, so it took a couple extra minutes to cook, but even with my mistake it came out SO juicy and flavorful. My kids kept dipping their bites in the leftover pan butter, it was chaotic but so good. Definitely letting the meat rest on the counter next time though, lesson learned!
Pro tip from someone who’s made this recipe 6 times now: save all that garlicky herb butter left in the pan after you take the steak out to rest, toss some parboiled baby potatoes in it and fry them up for 5 minutes. Best side dish ever, no extra work needed. You’re welcome.
Came out perfect! Used a New York strip, followed the directions exactly, got that perfect crispy crust and juicy pink center. Tossed a little blue cheese crumble on top at the end, chef’s kiss. Will be in my regular dinner rotation for sure.