tartar sauce
intro
Creamy, briny, bright homemade tartar sauce, packed with crisp pickles and fresh dill, the perfect tangy pairing for fried fish, crab cakes, and fish sandwiches.
Ingredients
Steps
Finely chop dill pickles
Set drained dill pickles on the acacia wood cutting board. Use the 5-inch paring knife to dice pickles into uniform 1/8-inch pieces, avoiding mashing the pickle flesh. Transfer diced pickles to a clean paper towel, gather the edges, and squeeze firmly to press out all excess brine; leftover brine will thin the sauce and dilute flavor. Set drained pickles aside in one small prep bowl.
Chop capers and dill
Place rinsed capers on the same acacia cutting board, and finely chop them into tiny pieces to release their briny flavor. Pick fresh fronds from the potted dill plant, discard thick stems, and chop the fronds finely to yield 1 tablespoon of chopped dill. Transfer both chopped capers and dill to separate small prep bowls.
Add mayo base to bowl
Scoop the full 1 cup of full-fat mayonnaise into the clear glass mixing bowl at the center of the counter. Use the stainless steel mixing spoon to spread the mayo slightly across the bottom of the bowl to create an even base for mixing, which prevents pockets of unblended seasoning.
Mix in aromatic seasonings
Add the 1 teaspoon Dijon mustard, 1 tablespoon fresh lemon juice, and 1/2 teaspoon Worcestershire sauce to the mayonnaise in the mixing bowl. Stir gently with the mixing spoon to combine the wet seasonings fully into the mayo, until the base is smooth and evenly pale yellow with no streaks of mustard visible.
Fold in solid ingredients
Add the drained, chopped pickles, chopped capers, and chopped fresh dill to the seasoned mayo base. Fold gently with the mixing spoon instead of stirring vigorously to keep the sauce thick and retain the pleasant texture of the finely chopped bits, rather than mashing them into the base. Stop folding once the pickles, capers, and dill are evenly distributed throughout the sauce, about 10 gentle turns of the spoon.
Season to taste
Add 1/4 teaspoon kosher salt and 1/8 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper from the maple pepper mill to the sauce. Stir gently to incorporate, then taste a small amount on the tip of the spoon. Adjust seasoning if needed: add extra lemon juice for brightness, extra salt for savoriness, or a tiny pinch of sugar if your pickles are overly tart.
Chill before serving
Transfer the fully mixed tartar sauce from the mixing bowl into the matte white ceramic serving ramekin on its rattan coaster. Smooth the top gently with the back of the spoon, then cover loosely and chill in the refrigerator for at least 30 minutes to allow the flavors to meld together before serving. Garnish with a small fresh dill frond right before serving.
Tips
2.Use full-fat mayonnaise for the richest, creamiest texture: low-fat or light mayo often contains added stabilizers and water that give the sauce a gummy, artificial aftertaste and thin, watery consistency.
3.Let the sauce chill for a minimum of 30 minutes before serving: this resting time allows the briny pickle, caper, and dill flavors to infuse evenly into the mayo, resulting in a more complex, well-rounded taste instead of flat, separate flavors.

OMG this is SO good! I made this for our weekly fish fry last weekend and everyone was begging for the recipe. Ditched the store-bought stuff forever, no cap. The dill pickle ratio is absolutely perfect, not too tangy not too bland.
Game changer for quick weeknight dinners! My kids are obsessed with fish sticks and they used to dip them in ketchup only (gross, I know) but they went crazy for this tartar sauce. Took 5 minutes to stir together, zero cook time which is perfect for my chaotic after work schedule.
Really solid base recipe! I added a tiny spoonful of capers and a pinch of old bay because I like my tartar sauce a little extra zesty, and it turned out chef’s kiss. Will be making this again for our upcoming crab feed.
Brought this to our neighborhood potluck last weekend alongside a big platter of fried shrimp, and the bowl was literally scraped clean before I even got a second serving. So many people asked for the recipe I just sent them all this link!
Perfect for meal prep! I made a big batch on Sunday and it lasted all week in the fridge, tasted just as fresh on Friday as it did day one. Pairs so good with salmon cakes, fried cod, even as a dip for roasted veggies honestly.
Bro I can’t believe how easy this was. I only had mayo, pickles, and lemon juice in my dorm fridge and it still came out better than the tartar sauce they serve at the campus seafood spot. 10/10 no notes.
My grandma’s tartar sauce recipe is almost identical to this, so I was skeptical when I tried it — but wow, it tastes just like hers! I added a little splash of hot sauce like she always did, and it transported me right back to Sunday suppers at her house.
It’s fine? I don’t know, I feel like it was missing something for me. Maybe a little more dill? Or some onion? I might tweak it next time but the base is decent.
Made this to go with our Dungeness crab feast last night and *chef’s kiss*. So much brighter and fresher than any jarred tartar sauce I’ve ever bought. I love that there’s no weird preservatives or unpronounceable ingredients in it.
Pro tip: this is insane as a dip for tater tots. Don’t @ me. I know it’s made for fish but the creamy tang with crispy salty tots? Life changing. My roommate thought I was weird until he tried it and ate half the bowl.
I’ve been making tartar sauce for 60 years and this recipe is exactly how I learned to make it from my own mother. It’s so nice to see simple, no-fuss recipes that don’t add a million fancy unnecessary ingredients. Good work!
I swapped the regular mayo for vegan mayo to make this for my sister who’s dairy free, and it turned out amazing! Even my non-vegan brother said he couldn’t tell the difference. Only reason it’s 4 stars is I wish there was a note about vegan swaps in the actual recipe!
Packed this in our cooler for a weekend camping trip to go with the fried trout we caught in the lake. It held up perfectly even in the cooler, no weird separation, and tasted so good after a long day of hiking. Will be a staple on all our future trips.
Wait this has zero cook time? I thought homemade tartar sauce required cooking or something? I feel silly for buying jarred stuff for years when this literally takes 2 minutes to stir together. So easy even I can’t mess it up.
I used to work at a seafood restaurant and we made our tartar sauce in house every day, and this recipe is dead on for what we served. People don’t realize how much better it tastes when you make it fresh instead of buying it off the shelf. 10/10.
Hosted our annual Lenten fish fry last week and made a quadruple batch of this. Let me tell you, the old guys at my parish were raving about it, said it was better than the tartar sauce they serve at the legendary supper club up north. High praise!
This is perfect for my son who has a soy allergy! Most jarred tartar sauces have soy in them from the cheap mayo they use, but I made this with soy-free mayo at home and he could finally have tartar sauce with his fish sticks. He was so happy he asked for seconds.
Random but I put this on my fish sandwich last night and it was insane. I usually just put mayo on my fish sandwiches but this took it to a whole new level. Only knock is I wish I made more, I ran out halfway through dinner.
This is the first thing I’ve ever made entirely from scratch without following a TikTok tutorial, and it turned out perfect!!! I was so nervous I’d mess it up but it’s literally just measuring and stirring, so easy. I’m so proud of myself lol.
Used leftover pickles from the jar I had in the fridge to make this, zero extra grocery run needed. Tossed it with leftover baked salmon to make a quick salmon salad for lunch the next day, and it was chef’s kiss. Zero food waste, maximum flavor, perfect recipe.