Anchovy Pizza
intro
Bold, briny anchovies star in this classic Italian-American pizza, paired with melted mozzarella, bright tomato, and crispy, bubbled crust for an umami-packed, satisfying dinner.
Ingredients
Steps
Preheat Pizza Stone
Place the cordierite pizza stone on the middle rack of your oven, then preheat oven to 500°F (260°C) for a full 30 minutes before baking—this high, sustained heat creates the crispy, blistered crust characteristic of great pizzeria pizza, rather than a soft, soggy base. While the oven preheats, lightly dust the 14-inch perforated aluminum pizza peel with 1.5 tablespoons of fine semolina flour to prevent sticking, and set the peel on the counter within easy reach.
Stretch Dough to Size
Set the room-temperature 1lb pizza dough ball on the center of the semolina-dusted pizza peel. Gently press the dough outward from the center with your fingertips, leaving a 1-inch thicker border to form the puffed crust edge. Stretch the dough slowly into an even 14-inch round, lifting and rotating it as you go to avoid tearing; use the stainless steel rolling pin lightly only if needed to achieve a consistent 1/4-inch thickness across the center. Give the peel a gentle, quick shake back and forth to confirm the dough slides freely without sticking—add a pinch more semolina under any spots that catch.
Mix Quick Tomato Sauce
Add the 1 cup of drained crushed San Marzano tomatoes to the medium brushed stainless steel mixing bowl. Stir in 1 tablespoon of extra virgin olive oil, 1/4 teaspoon freshly cracked black pepper, and half of the chopped fresh oregano. Hold off on adding salt at this stage: the anchovy fillets will release rich, briny salt as they bake, and over-salting the sauce will make the final pizza too salty. Mix gently with the small stainless steel sauce spoon until just combined, leaving the sauce slightly chunky rather than fully smooth for better texture.
Spread Sauce and Cheese
Using the small sauce spoon, dollop the tomato sauce in small spoonfuls across the center of the stretched dough, spreading it in a thin, even layer out to the 1-inch crust border. Resist the urge to add extra sauce—too much sauce will create a soggy middle that won’t crisp up, even on a hot stone. Sprinkle the patted-dry shredded mozzarella evenly over the sauce, leaving small gaps so the bright red tomato peeks through, then scatter the thinly sliced garlic cloves across the cheese.
Add Anchovy Fillets
Lightly blot the drained anchovy fillets with a paper towel to remove excess surface oil, which prevents greasy, pooled spots on the finished pizza. Arrange the fillets evenly across the pizza in a loose spoke pattern, spacing them roughly 2 inches apart so every slice gets a portion of anchovy. Avoid piling fillets in a single spot—their bold, umami flavor is concentrated, so even distribution ensures balanced flavor in every bite.
Bake to Golden Perfection
Give the pizza peel one final gentle shake to confirm the pizza slides freely, then carefully slide the pizza directly onto the preheated pizza stone in the oven. Bake for 10 to 12 minutes at 500°F (260°C), rotating the pizza halfway through with the peel for even browning. The pizza is done when the crust edge is deep golden brown, bubbled, and dotted with small dark char spots, the cheese is fully melted and bubbling across the surface, and the anchovy fillets are slightly curled at their edges. Slip on the quilted oven mitts, pull the oven rack out slightly, and slide the peel under the pizza to lift it out of the oven.
Garnish and Slice
Immediately after removing the pizza from the oven, drizzle the surface with the remaining 1 tablespoon of extra virgin olive oil, sprinkle with the remaining chopped oregano, finely grated parmesan, and a tiny pinch of flaky sea salt (taste a small edge of crust first to check salt level, as anchovies vary in saltiness). Let the pizza rest for 3 full minutes to let the cheese set, then slide it onto the matte cream ceramic pizza platter and slice into 8 even wedges. Serve hot, with red pepper flakes and extra parmesan in the small black ramekins on the side.
Tips
2.Let the pizza rest for a full 3 minutes after removing it from the oven before slicing: this short wait lets the melted cheese set firmly, so toppings don’t slide off when you cut into it, and allows the briny anchovy flavor to meld evenly with the cheese and tomato sauce.
3.Keep sauce and cheese layers light: anchovy pizza shines when toppings are sparse enough to let the bold, umami anchovy flavor take center stage, rather than being buried under heavy layers of sauce and cheese. Taste a small bite of crust before adding extra salt, as anchovy fillets can vary widely in salt content between brands.

OMG I was so skeptical about anchovy pizza because I thought it’d be too fishy, but this recipe is a GAME CHANGER. The saltiness of the anchovies pairs so perfectly with the melty mozzarella and that crispy thin crust! Made it for family dinner last night and even my teen who swears he hates fish went back for a third slice. 10/10, will be making this every other pizza night from now on.
This was SO good! I was worried the 12 minute cook time was too short to get the crust crispy, but my oven runs hot so it came out perfect. I added a little sprinkle of red pepper flakes on top for a tiny kick and it was chef’s kiss. Packed the leftover slices for my husband’s lunch today and he texted me saying it’s the best homemade pizza I’ve ever made.
Brought this to our neighborhood block party potluck last weekend and I swear people were hovering around the platter waiting for the last slice! I will say the medium difficulty rating is pretty fair — I messed up stretching the dough the first try, but the second go-round came out great. Pro tip: let your dough come to room temp for 30 minutes before stretching, it makes it way easier to work with!
Okay full transparency, I’ve never made homemade pizza before and I was terrified to try this because anchovies feel fancy? But the instructions were super straightforward, the 12 minute cook time was totally accurate, and it turned out way better than the anchovy pizza I get at our local Italian spot. Only change I made was adding a handful of sliced black olives because I had them in the fridge.
I was craving anchovy pizza but trying to cut back on regular refined flour crust, so I swapped the regular pizza dough for a cauliflower crust and adjusted the cook time a tiny bit (added 3 extra minutes) and it worked perfectly! The salty anchovy flavor is so satisfying it doesn’t even feel like a ‘diet’ meal. My kids loved it too, which is saying something because they turn their noses up at most veggie swaps.
Made this in my tiny dorm oven last night and it slapped. Used pre-made store bought dough because I don’t have time to make dough from scratch between midterms, added some extra anchovies because I love that salty briny flavor, and it was done in exactly 12 minutes like the recipe said. Way cheaper than ordering takeout pizza, will be adding this to my regular meal prep rotation.
Made this for my anniversary dinner with my partner last night because they are obsessed with anchovy pizza, and they said it was better than the pizza we had on our trip to Naples! I will say the medium difficulty feels a little overstated if you use store-bought dough — it came together so fast, we even had time to make a little side salad to go with it. 10/10, major partner points earned.
Wait, hold on — has anyone tried adding a little drizzle of hot honey to this? I did that on a whim last night when I made it and the combo of salty anchovy, melty cheese, and sweet spicy honey is absolutely insane. I don’t think I can eat anchovy pizza without it now. Only downside is I ate three slices in one sitting and had a major food coma after, zero regrets though.
I’ve been making pizza at home for 40+ years and I have to say, this anchovy pizza recipe is spot on. The ratio of cheese to anchovy to sauce is perfect, the 12 minute cook time at high heat is exactly what you need to get that crispy, blistered crust without overcooking the toppings. My only note is to make sure you’re using good quality oil-packed anchovies, not the cheap salt-packed ones that taste like straight salt.
Made a double batch of these on Sunday for meal prep for the week, and the slices hold up so well in the fridge! I just reheat a slice in the toaster oven for 3 minutes at lunch and it tastes just as fresh as when it came out of the oven. The whole family is obsessed, even my picky 7 year old asked for it in his school lunch this week. Total win for busy school nights!