best cheese for french onion soup
intro
Deeply caramelized sweet onion broth topped with crusty bread and a perfectly melted, nutty Gruyère-Comté cheese cap: the iconic, cozy French bistro classic.
Ingredients
Steps
Slice Yellow Onions
Halve, peel, and thinly slice 1kg of yellow onions into uniform 3mm half-moons using the chef knife on the light oak cutting board. Discard tough root ends and outer papery skins, leaving a few scattered skins on the counter edge as a natural minor mess. Set sliced onions aside in a loose pile on the cutting board.
Caramelize Onions Slowly
Place the 4L matte cream enameled cast iron Dutch oven on the stovetop over medium-low heat. Add 30g unsalted butter and 1 tbsp olive oil, then add all sliced onions and 1 tsp kosher salt. Stir with the olive wood cooking spoon to coat onions evenly in fat, then cook for 40 minutes, stirring every 3-4 minutes, until onions are deep golden amber, completely soft, and reduced to 1/4 their original volume. Do not cook on high heat, as burnt onions will create a bitter, unbalanced soup.
Deglaze and Simmer Broth
Pour 60ml dry sherry into the Dutch oven with the caramelized onions, scraping the bottom of the pot firmly with the olive wood spoon to lift all browned, flavorful fond bits. Add 1L low-sodium beef broth, 4 fresh thyme sprigs, and 1 bay leaf. Bring to a gentle simmer, then reduce heat to low, cover, and cook for 20 minutes to let flavors meld. Remove and discard thyme sprigs and bay leaf, then season broth to taste with 1/2 tsp freshly ground black pepper.
Grate Cheese Blend
While the broth simmers, use the large holes of the stainless steel box grater to grate 180g aged Gruyère and 60g 12-month Comté on the dry section of the light oak cutting board. Toss the two grated cheeses together gently to combine into an even blend. Do not use pre-shredded cheese, as it contains anti-caking agents that prevent smooth, even melting.
Toast Baguette Slices
Turn the oven broiler to high. Arrange 4 thick (2cm) day-old baguette slices on the parchment-lined matte silver aluminum baking sheet. Toast 30 seconds per side under the broiler until lightly golden and crisp, watching closely to avoid burning. Remove the baking sheet from the oven and set toasted slices aside temporarily.
Assemble Soup Crocks
Set the four creamy white stoneware soup crocks on the same parchment-lined aluminum baking sheet. Use the stainless steel ladle to pour the hot onion broth into each crock, filling to 1cm below the flared rim. Top each crock with one toasted baguette slice, pressing gently so the bread sits just above the broth surface without sinking.
Top with Cheese Blend
Pile 60g of the combined grated Gruyère and Comté blend evenly over each baguette slice, making sure the cheese covers the entire bread surface and drapes slightly over the crock rim. This overhang creates the iconic crispy, lacy cheese edge as it melts.
Broil Cheese Topping
Place the baking sheet with assembled crocks 10cm under the hot broiler. Cook for 3-4 minutes, watching constantly, until the cheese is fully melted, bubbly, and dotted with deep golden brown blisters across the surface. Do not walk away during broiling, as cheese can burn in as little as 30 seconds once it reaches melting temperature. Remove from broiler, let rest 1 minute before serving.
Tips
2.Let grated cheese rest at room temperature for 10 minutes before broiling. Cold cheese melts unevenly, leading to burnt brown spots on the top surface before the cheese closest to the bread fully melts, resulting in a patchy, less cohesive cap.
3.Let cheese shreds drape slightly over the crock’s flared rim when assembling. As the cheese melts, this overhang creates a crispy, lacy cheese seal that holds the baguette in place, preventing it from floating up and letting broth seep over the top to make the bread soggy as it broils.

OMG this French onion soup is SO good!!! I made it for our Sunday family dinner last night and everyone went back for seconds. The cheese topping got perfectly crispy and bubbly in the broiler, total game changer. I was worried the caramelized onions would take forever but the timing was spot on for how long to cook them down.
Really solid French onion soup recipe. I used gruyere like the recipe said for the topping and it was chef’s kiss, though I did add an extra splash of sherry because I love that deeper flavor. Only knock is it took me closer to an hour and a half total instead of the 1 hour 10 listed, probably because I was chopping onions slow and crying the whole time lmao.
My kids loved it!!! I’ve tried so many French onion soup recipes that end up too bland or the cheese gets rubbery, but this one was perfect. I prepped the onion base the night before for meal prep and just heated it up and broiled the cheese when we got home from soccer practice, total weeknight win.
Taste was great, but I struggled with the cheese topping sliding off the bread into the soup when I broiled it. Did I do something wrong? I used the sourdough slices like recommended but they kept sinking a little. Flavor of the broth was 10/10 though, the caramelized onions were perfect.
Made this for a potluck at my apartment building and people were begging me for the recipe! The cheese topping is absolutely the best part, I mixed a little bit of parmesan in with the gruyere like the pro tip suggested and it was so nutty and delicious. Will be making this all fall and winter long for sure.
I was intimidated because French onion soup always seemed like fancy restaurant food, but the medium difficulty rating was totally fair. The steps were easy to follow, no fancy equipment needed! I treated myself to a bowl after grading midterms all weekend and it was the coziest meal ever.
Smoked the onions on my pellet grill for 20 minutes before caramelizing them in the pot and HOLY COW that added such a good depth. The cheese topping was crispy exactly like it looks in the photos, though I wish the recipe noted how much ventilation you need when cooking down that many onions — my smoke alarm went off twice lmao.
As someone who orders French onion soup every single time I go to a French bistro, I can confirm this recipe is just as good if not better than restaurant versions! The cheese pull is insane, I got a 2-foot pull on my first bite and my roommate thought I was crazy for cheering out loud.
Made this after a long cold hike in Flagstaff last weekend and it hit so different. Warm, savory, that gooey cheese on top was exactly what I needed to warm up. Even my partner who swears he ‘hates onion anything’ ate two whole bowls. 10/10, adding this to our regular camping meal rotation too.
I’ve been making French onion soup for over 40 years and I have to say, this cheese topping ratio is perfect. I used to just throw a slice of cheese on top but the mix of cheeses and letting it broil until the edges are crispy and browned makes all the difference. My grandkids ate every last drop.
Brought this to my neighborhood fall potluck and it was the first dish gone! Only thing I’d change is I’d double the recipe next time, because a single batch only ended up being 6 servings and we had 12 people there. Everyone was raving about the crispy cheese edges.
Made this in my tiny dorm kitchen with a toaster oven to broil the cheese and it actually turned out! I had to substitute Swiss cheese because the grocery store by campus didn’t have gruyere, but it still tasted really good. Way better than the dining hall soup for sure.
Flavor was on point, but I burned the cheese topping on my first go-round because I walked away for 30 seconds to grab a drink. Don’t be like me, stand right by the oven when you’re broiling! It goes from perfectly golden to charred so fast.
Rainy Seattle day + this French onion soup = absolute perfection. I paired it with a side salad and a glass of red wine and it felt like a fancy date night in for me and my partner. The slow caramelized onions have such a deep, sweet flavor that pairs so well with the salty, melty cheese.
This was so cozy! I made it on a night when the wind was howling off the lake and it warmed me right up. My golden retriever kept sitting by the oven the whole time it cooked begging for a bite, I had to give him a tiny piece of plain bread (no cheese/onions, don’t worry!) so he’d stop staring at me.
I was worried this would be too light and not filling enough for my meat-and-potatoes family, but y’all, they loved it! I served it with some crusty garlic bread on the side and none of them even complained about there being no meat. That cheese topping is so rich and flavorful it makes the whole bowl feel hearty.
I made this with vegan gruyere and vegetable broth for my sister who’s vegan and it was actually really good! The caramelized onion base is so flavorful on its own that you don’t even miss the beef broth. The vegan cheese broiled up surprisingly crispy too, just like the regular version.
I’ve made this recipe three times in the last two weeks, it’s that good. The directions for caramelizing the onions are foolproof, I used to rush that step and end up with burnt, bitter onions but the low and slow method here works every single time. Best French onion soup I’ve ever made, hands down.