British Mince Pies
intro
Buttery, flaky shortcrust pastry filled with spiced fruit mincemeat, dusted with snowy icing sugar—these iconic bite-sized treats are the beloved centerpiece of a British Christmas spread.
Ingredients
Steps
Grate butter into flour
Place 225g plain all-purpose flour and 1 pinch of fine table salt into the large stainless steel mixing bowl. Hold the 110g block of very cold unsalted butter with the corner of the linen tea towel to avoid warming it with your hands, then grate it into the flour using the coarse side of the box grater. Pause every 3-4 grates to toss the butter shreds in flour to fully coat them. When finished, the mixture should resemble coarse fresh breadcrumbs with a few pea-sized butter bits remaining — do not overmix, as these intact butter bits create the signature flaky pastry layers.
Bring dough together
Drizzle 3 tablespoons of ice-cold water into the flour and butter mixture, adding 1 tablespoon at a time. Use your fingertips to gently toss the mixture (do not knead) until it clumps into a rough, cohesive ball. Add the 4th tablespoon of water only if the mixture remains dry and crumbly, and will not hold together when squeezed firmly in your palm. Flatten the dough ball into a 2cm thick disc, then chill in the refrigerator for 30 minutes to rest — this prevents pastry shrinkage during baking.
Roll pastry evenly
After chilling, place the dough disc on the lightly floured beech pastry board. Use the polished stainless steel rolling pin to roll the pastry out to a consistent 3mm thickness, turning the pastry a quarter turn every 2-3 rolls to prevent sticking, and dusting the board and pin with a tiny amount of extra flour only as needed. Avoid rolling the pastry thinner than 3mm, as it will tear when lining the tin.
Cut and line tin
Use the 9cm fluted stainless steel pastry cutter to cut 12 even circles from the rolled pastry sheet. Gently press each circle into the cups of the dark grey non-stick muffin tin, making sure the pastry sits snugly against the bottom and fluted sides of each cup, with a 2mm overhang of pastry at the top edge. Gather all pastry offcuts into a small ball, re-roll to 3mm thickness, and set aside on the board for the pie lids.
Add mincemeat filling
Use the small beech wood teaspoon to scoop 25g (roughly 1 heaped teaspoon) of spiced fruit mincemeat into each pastry-lined cup, filling each to just 2mm below the pastry edge. Do not overfill the cups, as the high-sugar mincemeat will bubble, leak, and burn during baking if packed too full.
Seal pie lids
Use the 7cm fluted stainless steel pastry cutter to cut 12 smaller circles from the re-rolled pastry scraps. Beat 1 large egg with 1 tablespoon of whole milk in the small glass ramekin to make egg wash, then use the silicone pastry brush to dab a thin layer of egg wash around the rim of each filled pastry base. Place a smaller pastry circle on top of each pie, pressing the edges firmly with your fingertip to seal, then crimp the sealed edge with the tines of the small stainless steel fork to create a tight, decorative seal. Cut a tiny 5mm slit in the center of each lid to allow steam to escape during baking.
Bake until golden
Brush the top of each pie lid with a thin final layer of egg wash, then place the muffin tin in a preheated oven set to 200C (180C fan / 400F / Gas Mark 6). Bake for 18-20 minutes, until the pastry is a deep, even golden brown and crisp, and small bubbles of mincemeat gently seep through the top slits. Watch closely during the final 3 minutes of baking to prevent the pastry edges from burning.
Cool and dust pies
Let the mince pies cool in the tin for 5 minutes, then carefully lift each pie out and transfer them to the chrome wire cooling rack to cool for a further 10 minutes until just warm (not piping hot). Arrange the pies on the round cream ceramic serving platter, then hold the fine-mesh sieve 15cm above the platter and tap it gently to dust a light, even layer of icing sugar over all the pie tops.
Tips
2.Avoid over-kneading the pastry: Overworking the dough develops gluten in the flour, which results in a hard, tough crust instead of a tender, crumbly one. Toss the dough gently rather than squeezing or kneading it when bringing it together.
3.Don’t skip the steam slits in the pie lids: Trapped hot steam from the bubbling mincemeat will build up under the lid and cause it to pop off or leak, leaving you with messy, uneven pies. The small slit also lets the rich spiced aroma escape as the pies bake.

OMG these mince pies were such a hit at my office holiday potluck! I was worried they’d be too sweet since I’d never had British mince pies before, but the spice balance is totally perfect. My coworkers kept coming back for seconds, a couple people even asked for the recipe link. 10/10 will be making these every Christmas from now on!
These were SO good, though I will say the pastry was a little trickier to work with than I expected, even for a medium-difficulty recipe with a 20-minute cook time! My kids loved them, they devoured half the batch as soon as they came out of the oven, I had to hide the rest for our holiday party tomorrow. Next time I’ll chill the pastry a little longer before cutting it, that was my bad for rushing.
Game changer! I’ve been buying sad grocery store mince pies for years because I thought making them from scratch would be way too hard, but these came together way faster than I expected. The buttery shortcrust pastry is chef’s kiss, way better than any store-bought version I’ve tried. Already added these to my annual Christmas meal prep rotation!
These were tasty, but I had a little mishap! I didn’t have a mini muffin tin small enough so I used a regular cupcake pan, and the pies spread out way more than I thought they would. Flavor was still spot on though, so I’ll definitely grab a mini muffin tin before I make them again.