Eggnog Crème Brûlée
intro
Silky, spiced eggnog custard topped with a shatteringly crisp caramelized sugar crust—this festive twist on classic crème brûlée is the perfect make-ahead holiday dessert.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep Oven and Ramekins
Adjust oven rack to the middle position, preheat oven to 325°F (160°C). Arrange all 6 white porcelain ramekins evenly spaced in the bottom of the large high-sided ceramic baking dish. Set the dish on the counter near the stovetop, and bring a kettle of water to a gentle simmer for the water bath.
Warm Cream and Eggnog
Pour the heavy cream and eggnog into the medium heavy-bottomed stainless steel saucepan. Add ½ cup of the granulated sugar, grated nutmeg, ground cinnamon, and pinch of fine sea salt. Warm over medium-low heat, stirring occasionally with the silicone spatula, until the mixture reaches 170°F (77°C) on the instant-read thermometer – it will be steaming gently, with tiny bubbles forming around the edge of the pan, but not boiling. Remove from heat immediately.
Whisk Egg Yolks
While the cream mixture warms, place the 6 egg yolks into the large stainless steel mixing bowl. Whisk constantly with the beech-handled wire whisk for 1 minute until the yolks are smooth, pale golden, and slightly thickened, with no streaks of unbroken yolk remaining.
Temper Yolks with Cream
While whisking the egg yolks constantly and slowly, pour ½ cup of the warm cream mixture into the yolks in a thin, steady stream to gently raise their temperature and prevent curdling. Once fully incorporated, continue adding the remaining warm cream mixture in 3 small additions, whisking nonstop, until all the liquid is combined with the yolks. Stir in the dark rum and vanilla extract.
Strain Custard Mixture
Place the fine-mesh stainless steel sieve over the clear glass 500ml measuring cup. Slowly pour the entire custard base through the sieve to catch any tiny curdled egg bits or spice clumps, resulting in a perfectly smooth, silky custard. Discard any solids left in the sieve.
Bake in Water Bath
Divide the strained custard evenly between the 6 ramekins in the baking dish, filling each to ½cm below the rim. Carefully pour the hot simmering water into the baking dish until it reaches halfway up the sides of the ramekins, taking care not to splash water into the custard. Bake for 40-45 minutes, until the edges of the custard are fully set but the center 2cm of each ramekin jiggles slightly like Jell-O when gently nudged – the custard will set fully as it chills.
Chill Custards Completely
Carefully remove the ramekins from the water bath, pat the outsides dry with the linen towel, and place them on a small tray. Cover loosely with plastic wrap and chill in the refrigerator for a minimum of 4 hours (or up to 3 days) until the custard is completely cold and firm to the touch.
Brûlée Sugar Crust
When ready to serve, remove the chilled custards from the refrigerator. Blot any condensation off the top of each custard with a paper towel, then sprinkle 1 tablespoon of the remaining granulated sugar evenly over the surface of each custard, tilting the ramekin to spread the sugar in a thin, even layer. Use the butane kitchen torch held 10cm from the surface to melt the sugar, moving the flame constantly in small circles, until the sugar melts, bubbles, and turns a deep amber golden color. Let the sugar rest for 1 minute to harden into a crisp crust, then grate a light dusting of fresh nutmeg over the top before serving.
Tips
2.Do not overbake the custards: the 2cm center of each ramekin should still jiggle gently when pulled from the oven, as residual heat will continue to set the custard as it cools. Overbaking results in a rubbery, grainy texture instead of the signature silky, melt-in-your-mouth mouthfeel.
3.For the shatteringly crisp sugar crust, brûlée the tops immediately before serving: if you caramelize the sugar more than 10 minutes in advance, moisture from the cold custard will dissolve the caramel, leaving a soft, sticky top instead of the classic crisp shell.

OMG, this was the star of our Christmas dinner party last weekend! I was nervous to make crème brûlée for the first time, but the steps were so straightforward even for a medium-difficulty recipe. The eggnog flavor is perfectly spiced, not too overpowering, and that crackly sugar top? *Chef’s kiss* My cousin asked for the recipe before she even finished her first bite.
Help! I made this last night and my custard got little lumpy bits in it, like it curdled? Tasted fine but the texture was off. Did I cook it too hot? I followed the bake time exactly but maybe my oven runs hot? Flavor was amazing otherwise, I just want to get it right for my in-laws coming next week!
Game changer! I swapped regular eggnog for the spiked bourbon eggnog my wife picks up every holiday season, and oh my gosh, it added such a nice warm kick. My kids even ate the non-spiked version I made for them and asked for seconds. 10/10 will be making this every December from now on.
Brought this to my office holiday potluck yesterday and people were scraping the ramekins clean! I was worried it would be too fussy to transport, but I baked them the night before, kept them in the fridge, and just torched the sugar top right before serving. Zero leftovers, zero complaints. SO good.
Wait, is this recipe naturally gluten free? I checked the ingredient list and didn’t see any wheat products, but I wanted to double check before I make it for my celiac best friend’s holiday gathering. Don’t want to accidentally make her sick!
Quick question for folks who’ve made this — do I *need* a kitchen torch to get that crunchy sugar top? I don’t own one and really don’t want to buy a single-use gadget if I can do it under the broiler instead. Has anyone tried that method here?
This recipe is so good, but I felt like the eggnog flavor was a little mild for my taste. I added an extra 1/4 tsp of nutmeg and a dash of cinnamon, but next time I might reduce the heavy cream a little to let the eggnog shine more? Any tips?
My kids loved it! My 7 year old is notoriously picky about creamy desserts and she ate two whole ramekins after dinner last night. I thought the 45 minute cook time was totally reasonable for a fancy dessert, no crazy long prep or weird hard to find ingredients. Will absolutely be adding this to our annual Christmas menu rotation.
First time making any kind of crème brûlée ever, and I was so intimidated by the medium difficulty rating, but this came out perfect on the first try! I did mess up the first sugar top I torched (burned it to a crisp, oops) but the second try was perfect. Even my roommate who hates eggnog said it was the best dessert I’ve ever made.
Has anyone made these ahead of time? I want to make them on Wednesday for a dinner party on Saturday, but I’m worried the texture will get weird if they sit in the fridge that long. Don’t want to be stressed cooking the day of the party!
SO good. I’ve made a lot of crème brûlée recipes over the years and this is hands down my new holiday favorite. The eggnog flavor feels so festive without being cheesy, and the custard is so silky smooth. 10/10, no notes.
Wait, what size ramekins did you use for this? I only have 4 oz ones and I wasn’t sure if I need to adjust the bake time if I use those instead of the standard 6 oz? I don’t want them to be overdone!
Wait, what do I do with the leftover eggnog I have after making this? I bought a whole half gallon and I’ll only use the amount the recipe calls for. Don’t want it to go to waste! Also, this recipe is chef’s kiss, made it last night for date night and my partner said it was better than any restaurant dessert we’ve ever had.
Is the nutmeg really strong in this? I’m not a huge fan of super spiced desserts, I was thinking of cutting the nutmeg in half so it’s just a hint of flavor instead of a big punch. Think that would work?
I know this is billed as a Christmas dessert but I’m making it for my New Year’s Eve dinner party and I know it’s gonna be a hit. Who says eggnog is only for Christmas? The creamy custard and crunchy top is perfect for any cold weather celebration, tbh. Already did a test run last weekend and my roommates devoured all of them.
Y’all, I forgot to cover my ramekins with foil when I did the water bath and a little bit of water sloshed into one of them. Is that one totally ruined? I’m so mad, I was so careful up until that point!
Is it weird to serve this with a little dollop of whipped cream on top? I know traditional crème brûlée is just the custard and sugar top, but I feel like a tiny bit of freshly whipped cream and a sprinkle of nutmeg would make it even more festive.
Made this for my book club holiday meeting last night and everyone was raving. Several people asked for the link to the recipe before they left, which is always the sign of a winner. Will be making this for years to come!