home made rice pudding
intro
Silky, warmly spiced old-fashioned rice pudding, slow-simmered to creamy perfection with plump short-grain rice, vanilla, and cinnamon, finished with fresh nutmeg for pure nostalgic winter comfort.
Ingredients
Steps
Rinse the Short-Grain Rice
Place ¾ cup arborio rice in the fine-mesh stainless steel strainer. Hold the strainer under cold running tap water for 1 to 2 minutes, swishing rice gently with your fingers, until water running through the mesh runs nearly clear rather than cloudy with loose surface starch. Shake the strainer firmly to drain all excess water from the rice; do not soak the rice, as this will make the final texture mushy.
Combine Pudding Base Ingredients
Pour the drained rice, 4 cups whole milk, ¼ cup granulated sugar, and 1/8 teaspoon fine sea salt into the 3-quart stainless steel saucepan on the cooktop. Stir briefly with the long-handled beech wood spoon to combine, making sure no rice is stuck to the bottom of the pan. Turn the burner to medium heat to begin warming the mixture.
Bring to Gentle Simmer
Heat the milk and rice mixture over medium heat, stirring every 2 to 3 minutes with the beech wood spoon, scraping the full bottom of the pan to prevent rice from sticking or burning. After 8 to 10 minutes, the mixture will reach a gentle simmer: small, steady bubbles will break across the surface, rather than large, violent boiling bubbles. Immediately turn the heat down to the lowest setting once this simmer is reached to prevent boil-overs and scalded milk.
Slow Simmer Until Creamy
Tilt the saucepan lid to cover 90% of the pan, leaving a 2cm gap to let steam escape and prevent boil-overs. Let the rice cook over the lowest heat for 22 to 25 minutes, stirring thoroughly with the beech wood spoon every 5 minutes to scrape the pan bottom and sides. The pudding is done when rice is completely tender (no hard white core at the center of a bitten grain), and the mixture is thick enough to evenly coat the back of the beech wood spoon. Remember the pudding will thicken further as it cools.
Stir in Butter and Spices
Once the rice is tender and the pudding reaches the correct thick consistency, turn off the heat and slide the pan slightly off the burner. Add 1 tablespoon unsalted butter, 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract, and ½ teaspoon ground cinnamon to the pudding. Stir gently with the beech wood spoon for 1 full minute until the butter is fully melted and all ingredients are evenly incorporated, creating a smooth, silky texture with no streaks of spice or unmelted butter.
Let Pudding Rest Briefly
Leave the pudding uncovered, off the heat, to rest for 5 minutes. This allows the starch to set and the flavors to meld fully. Stir once more after resting; if the pudding is thicker than your preferred consistency, stir in 1 to 2 tablespoons of extra warm milk to loosen it. Avoid over-stirring, as this will break down rice grains and create a mushy texture.
Plate and Garnish Servings
Scoop equal portions of the warm rice pudding into the cream white hand-thrown ceramic dessert bowls. Grate fresh nutmeg over the top of each serving (using ¼ teaspoon total nutmeg across all four bowls) for a warm, aromatic finish. Serve immediately while warm for the best texture and flavor.
Tips
2.Keep heat at the lowest setting once the mixture reaches a simmer: boiling milk too rapidly scalds the dairy, creating a bitter burnt off-flavor, and causes rice to stick and burn to the pan bottom. Low, slow gentle heat ensures evenly tender rice and no burnt bits.
3.Avoid over-thickening the pudding on the stovetop: rice continues to absorb liquid and starch sets as the pudding cools, so a slightly loose consistency when you remove the pan from heat will set to the perfect spoonable, silky texture after 5 minutes of resting. Overcooking to thicken it while hot will result in a stiff, gluey pudding as it cools.

OMG this rice pudding is SO good! I made it last night for my kid’s after-school snack and they begged for seconds before they even finished their first bowl. I added a handful of golden raisins and a dash of cinnamon on top, total game changer. Only thing is, mine was a little thinner than I expected when I first took it off the stove—did I do something wrong?
Made this for our neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were coming up to me asking for the recipe all night! It’s so easy to throw together, I didn’t even have to run to the store for special ingredients. 10/10, will be making this on repeat all fall.
I meal prepped this on Sunday for my work lunches this week and it’s the perfect sweet little treat to look forward to midday. I swapped whole milk for oat milk because that’s what I had on hand and it still came out ultra creamy, no weird texture at all. Will definitely be adding this to my regular rotation.
Wait, can I use leftover white takeout rice for this? I have a ton in the fridge from last night’s Chinese order and I hate wasting food, would love to repurpose it for this pudding.
My grandma used to make stovetop rice pudding when I was little and I’ve been chasing that flavor for years—this recipe is EXACTLY it. Not too sweet, perfectly creamy, no weird condensed milk aftertaste like so many other recipes I’ve tried. I cried a little when I took my first bite ngl.
Super easy, minimal cleanup, tastes way better than the store-bought rice pudding cups I used to buy for my hiking trips. I portioned mine into small mason jars to toss in my pack for day hikes, it holds up great and gives me that little sugar boost I need halfway up the trail.
Help! I’ve never made rice pudding before and I burned the rice a little bit on the bottom of the pan on my first try. Is there a trick to keeping it from sticking? I really want to get this right because my boyfriend loves rice pudding and his birthday is next week.
Brought this to my book club meeting last night and everyone went back for seconds. I topped half with cinnamon sugar and half with a little dollop of whipped cream and fresh berries, both versions were a massive hit. Only took me 35 minutes total just like the recipe said, zero stress.
I made this vegan by using full fat coconut milk instead of dairy and adding a splash of maple syrup instead of white sugar, and it came out insane. Even my non-vegan roommate stole half the batch and said it was the best rice pudding he’s ever had. Total win.
My three picky sons gobbled this up so fast I barely got a bite! I didn’t add raisins because my boys think they’re “gross” (eyeroll) but even plain it was so rich and creamy. This is going to be a new weeknight staple in our house for sure.
Wait, is there a way to make this in the Instant Pot? I don’t love standing over the stove stirring if I don’t have to, but this looks so good I’m tempted to do the stovetop version if that’s the only way.
This recipe is so straightforward even I could make it without messing it up, and I’m notorious for burning even simple desserts. I added a little lemon zest like my mom used to and it gave it such a bright, lovely little kick. Highly recommend.
Great high carb treat for my post-workout meal prep! I added a scoop of vanilla protein powder to the batch when I stirred in the cream and it added a nice little protein boost without messing up the texture at all. Macros came out perfect for my meal plan.
I thought this was good but a little less sweet than I prefer—how much extra sugar would you recommend adding if I like my rice pudding a little more dessert-forward? I don’t want to add so much it becomes cloying, just a little extra sweetness.
I made this for our local fire department’s annual pancake breakfast fundraiser and it was the first dish to empty out! People kept saying it tasted like the old-fashioned diner rice pudding they grew up eating. Can’t brag enough about how easy and delicious this recipe is.
Perfect cheap dorm recipe! I only had a tiny hot plate and a cheap saucepan in my dorm and this still came out amazing. Cost me like $3 total to make a whole batch that lasted me 4 days of late-night study snacks. No fancy equipment needed, 10/10 for broke college kids.
This is a lifesaver for my kid who has a nut and egg allergy! So many creamy dessert recipes have egg or hidden nut ingredients, but this one is totally free of both and he can eat it without any issues. He asked for it in his school lunch every day this week.
Served this at my Sunday brunch last weekend alongside French toast and bacon and it was such a nice change from the usual brunch spread. I set out a little topping bar with cinnamon, nutmeg, raisins, chocolate chips, and caramel drizzle so people could customize their bowls, everyone had so much fun with it.
Made this on a rainy cold day last week when I was feeling under the weather and it was like a warm hug in a bowl. I didn’t even have any fancy toppings, just ate it plain warm off the stove and it was exactly what I needed to feel better.