In-N-Out Animal Style
intro
Juicy, mustard-seared beef patties, tangy secret spread, melted cheese, and jammy grilled onions on a toasted bun: the iconic West Coast fast food favorite made perfectly at home.
Ingredients
Steps
Mix Secret Spread
In the small stainless steel mixing bowl, combine 1/2 cup mayonnaise, 2 tbsp ketchup, 2 tbsp sweet pickle relish, 1 tbsp yellow mustard, 1 tsp white vinegar, 1/2 tsp granulated sugar, and 1/4 tsp kosher salt. Stir thoroughly with the matte red silicone spatula until completely smooth, with a uniform pale orange-pink color. Set aside at room temperature to let flavors meld while you prep remaining components.
Caramelize Diced Onions
Melt 1 tbsp of unsalted butter in the 12-inch matte black carbon steel skillet over medium-low heat. Add the finely diced yellow onion and 1/4 tsp kosher salt, stirring occasionally with the stainless steel metal spatula for 8-10 minutes. Cook until onions are soft, deep golden brown, and jammy in texture, with no crisp raw bits remaining. Avoid turning heat to high, as this will burn the onion edges and create a bitter flavor. Transfer finished onions to a small clear glass condiment bowl and set aside.
Shape Thin Beef Patties
Divide the 454g of 80/20 ground beef into 8 equal 2oz portions. Roll each portion into a loose ball, then press flat on the maple cutting board into very thin 4-inch wide patties (about 1/4 inch thick, as they will shrink significantly during cooking). Season the top surface of each patty lightly with the remaining 1/2 tsp kosher salt and 1/2 tsp freshly ground black pepper. Do not overwork the beef when shaping, as this will create tough, dense patties.
Toast Sesame Buns
Wipe the carbon steel skillet clean with a paper towel, then return to medium heat. Use the boar bristle pastry brush to coat the cut sides of all 4 split sesame seed buns with the remaining 1 tbsp melted unsalted butter. Place buns cut-side down in the hot skillet for 1-2 minutes, until the cut surface is golden brown and slightly crisp at the edges. Transfer toasted buns to a clean surface and set aside.
Sear Mustard Patties
Increase skillet heat to medium-high. Working in 2 batches to avoid crowding the pan, place 2-3 patties seasoned-side down in the hot skillet. Immediately spread 1 tsp of yellow mustard evenly across the raw top surface of each patty. Cook for 1.5 minutes, until patty edges are deep brown and lacy-crisp, then flip with the metal spatula. Top each flipped patty with one slice of American cheese, then cook for an additional 1 minute, until cheese is fully melted and slightly drippy down the patty sides. Repeat with remaining patties.
Layer Burger Components
Spread 1 tbsp of the prepared secret spread evenly across the cut side of every top and bottom toasted bun. Layer 4 dill pickle slices on each bottom bun, followed by two cheese-topped beef patties, and a heaping 1/4 cup of caramelized grilled onions. Place the top bun on each stack, then press down lightly to help the ingredients settle and adhere, so the burger does not fall apart when picked up.
Plate and Serve
Transfer two fully assembled burgers to each cream white ceramic dinner plate. Serve immediately, while patties are hot, cheese is fully melted, and buns retain their crisp toasted edge. Extra secret spread can be served on the side for dipping fries, if desired.
Tips
2.Always spread mustard directly on the raw patty before searing: this lets the mustard caramelize against the hot skillet, creating a tangy, slightly sharp crust that defines Animal Style burgers. Adding mustard only to the spread will not replicate this iconic flavor.
3.Caramelize onions over low heat, no shortcuts: cooking the diced onions for 8-10 minutes over medium-low heat slowly breaks down their natural sugars for a sweet, jammy texture. High heat will char the onion exterior before the interior softens, leading to bitter, crunchy onions that don’t match the original.

OMG, I grew up 10 minutes from an In-N-Out and have been craving animal style burgers since I moved to Washington for work. This recipe is SPOT ON. The spread tastes exactly like the real thing, and the caramelized onions with the mustard grilled patty? *Chef's kiss* Cook time was actually even faster than 18 minutes for me, super easy even on a busy weeknight. My kids devoured two each and asked when we're making these again. Total game changer for our weekly family dinner rotation!
Made these in my tiny dorm kitchen last night with my roommates, and holy cow they were SO good. I was worried it'd be too complicated since I can barely make mac and cheese without burning it, but it was genuinely easy. We didn't have a grill so we just cooked the patties on a cast iron skillet on our hot plate and it still slapped. 10/10 will be making these for our pre-game potluck this weekend.
Tried these out for my Sunday cookout and everyone was begging for the recipe. I added a little extra pickled jalapeno to my spread for a tiny kick, but kept everything else exactly as written. Even my sister who swears nothing beats actual In-N-Out said this was better because the patties were thicker. Worth every minute of prep, and the 18 minute cook time is no joke — super quick for how fancy it tastes.
Wait, is there a trick to getting the onions to caramelize that fast? I followed the cook time to a T but my onions were still pretty crisp when the rest of the burgers were done. Flavor was still great, my husband loved them, but I want that soft, sweet onion texture next time!
As someone who only had In-N-Out for the first time on a work trip to LA last year, I've been chasing that animal style high ever since. This recipe did NOT disappoint. I meal prepped the spread and caramelized onions on Sunday so I could throw these together for quick dinners all week, and it made weeknight cooking so easy. Even my roommate who hates "fast food copycats" went back for seconds.
Made these for our beach picnic last weekend and they held up so much better than I thought they would! I wrapped them in parchment paper just like In-N-Out does and they stayed juicy without getting soggy, even after sitting in the cooler for an hour. The secret spread is so good I've been dipping my fries in it too, no regrets. 10/10, will be a summer staple for us.
Wait, has anyone tried this with a plant-based patty? I'm vegetarian but my partner is obsessed with In-N-Out, so I want to make these for our date night in. The recipe looks super easy, the pictures look amazing, just curious if the mustard grilling method works as well on veggie burgers!
OMG, I can't believe how simple this was! I've paid for fancy In-N-Out pop up events here in Atlanta that charge $20 a burger and they don't even taste this close to the real thing. The mustard cooked into the patty is the secret I was missing all these years. Made these for my kid's birthday cookout and all the parents were asking for the link. SO good.