Instant Pot BBQ Chicken (Frugal)
intro
Juicy, tangy, budget-friendly shredded BBQ chicken made in the Instant Pot in under 45 minutes, perfect for sandwiches, rice bowls, or quick weeknight tacos with no fancy ingredients.
Ingredients
Steps
Dice the Yellow Onion
Place the bamboo cutting board on the center-left of the counter. Set the yellow onion on the board, use the walnut-handled chef knife to trim the root and stem ends, peel off the papery outer skin, then dice the onion into rough 1/2-inch (1cm) pieces. No precise dicing is needed, as the onion will soften completely during pressure cooking.
Season Chicken Thighs
Pat the chicken thighs completely dry with a corner of the fixed blue kitchen towel (dry meat helps spices stick and prevents watery, diluted sauce). Sprinkle the garlic powder, smoked paprika, salt, and pepper evenly over both sides of each thigh, rubbing lightly to adhere the spices to the meat surface.
Load the Instant Pot
Lift the stainless steel inner pot out of the 6-quart Instant Pot base (positioned center-right on the counter). Spread the diced onion in an even thin layer at the bottom of the pot, then pour in the chicken broth and apple cider vinegar. Arrange the seasoned chicken thighs in a loose layer on top of the onions (slight overlapping is fine, no need for a perfect single layer). Pour 3/4 cup of the BBQ sauce evenly over the chicken, reserving the remaining 1/4 cup in the measuring cup for finishing.
Pressure Cook Chicken
Wipe any sauce drips from the rim of the inner pot with a corner of the blue towel, then seat the inner pot back into the Instant Pot base. Lock the lid into place, turn the steam release valve to the 'Sealing' position. Select the 'High Pressure' setting, set cook time to 12 minutes. The pot will take 8-10 minutes to build pressure before the countdown timer starts.
Release Pressure Safely
When the 12-minute cook time ends, let the pressure release naturally for 10 minutes (do not touch the steam valve during this time). After 10 minutes, carefully nudge the steam release valve to 'Venting' using the end of the beech wood wooden spoon to keep hands away from hot steam, releasing any remaining pressure. Wait until the silver float valve drops completely before unlocking the lid, tilting the lid away from your face to let escaping steam flow away from you.
Shred Tender Chicken
Once the float valve drops, unlock the lid and tilt it away from you to catch drips. Use the black silicone-tipped tongs to transfer the cooked chicken thighs from the inner pot to the bamboo cutting board. The chicken will be extremely tender, pulling apart easily when touched. Use the two stainless steel forks to shred the chicken into bite-sized strands, discarding any tiny bits of excess fat or cartilage as you work. Do not discard the cooking liquid and softened onions left in the inner pot.
Toss in Glazed Sauce
Turn the Instant Pot to the high 'Saute' setting. Let the remaining cooking liquid and onions simmer for 3-4 minutes, stirring occasionally with the wooden spoon, until the liquid reduces by half and thickens to a light syrup consistency. Turn the pot off, return all shredded chicken to the inner pot, add the reserved 1/4 cup BBQ sauce, and stir thoroughly to coat every strand of chicken in the thick, glossy sauce.
Plate and Rest
Let the sauced chicken rest for 2 minutes to absorb sauce flavor, then use the tongs to mound a generous 1.5-cup serving onto the cream stoneware dinner plate. Set the small glass ramekin of extra BBQ sauce to the right of the plate for dipping.
Tips
2.Skip premium artisanal BBQ sauce to keep costs low: generic store-brand original BBQ sauce works perfectly, as the added apple cider vinegar, smoked paprika, and slow-cooked onion elevate the flavor to taste homemade for a fraction of the price.
3.Always allow 10 minutes of natural pressure release before venting: quick-releasing immediately can cause chicken to seize and turn tough, and may lead to hot, sticky BBQ sauce splattering out of the steam valve and making a mess.
4.Stretch the recipe for extra servings on a tight budget: add one 15oz can of rinsed black beans or 1 cup of frozen corn when tossing the chicken in sauce to add fiber and volume for 1-2 additional servings for under $1 extra.

OMG this recipe is such a game changer for busy weeknights! I threw this together after soccer practice last night, total cook time was right at 35 minutes just like the recipe said, and my two picky kids devoured it. No fancy expensive ingredients needed, which is perfect for our tight grocery budget right now. Served it on buns with a side of coleslaw, 10/10 will make again for our next family dinner!
Meal prepped this on Sunday for the whole week and it held up perfectly! Spent like $8 total on chicken thighs and a cheap bottle of BBQ sauce, made 6 servings? Unbeatable value. I toss it on rice, on salad, even in wraps for lunch between classes. SO good, way better than paying $12 a meal for takeout on campus.
Wait, y'all are saying this comes out as tender as slow smoked BBQ chicken? I was skeptical because I usually spend 6 hours on my smoker for pulled BBQ chicken, but for 35 minutes in the Instant Pot? I had to try it. Flavor was great, texture was super tender, my only tiny note is I added a splash of liquid smoke to match that smoky flavor I love. Perfect for when I don't have all day to tend the smoker.
Made this last night for dinner and my kids asked for seconds before they even finished their first helping! I didn’t even have to thaw the chicken first, just tossed the frozen breasts right in the pot with the sauce, set it, and forgot it while I helped with homework. Total win for a mom who’s juggling 3 different after school activity schedules. We’re bringing the leftovers to our neighborhood potluck this weekend!
This is my new go-to frugal protein for meal prep! I make a batch every Sunday now, it costs pennies per serving and I don’t get bored of it because I can switch up the BBQ sauce flavor every week. Last week I used honey BBQ, this week I went spicy. Tried it on baked potatoes last night and *chef’s kiss*. Only thing is, does anyone else find it a little too watery if they don’t do a quick sauté after pressure cooking?
Brought this to my office potluck yesterday and people were hounding me for the recipe before the lunch hour was even half over! I shredded it up, put out a tray of buns, pickles, and onion slices, and people built their own sandwiches. It was so easy to make the morning of, I didn’t have to wake up at the crack of dawn to prep like I usually do for potlucks. Zero leftovers, that’s how you know it’s a hit!
As someone who’s surviving on the last $20 in my bank account until graduation, this recipe was a lifesaver. I already had an Instant Pot I got as a high school graduation gift, picked up a value pack of chicken and a $2 bottle of BBQ sauce from the dollar store, and ate like a king for 4 days. Way better than the ramen I’ve been living on for months. 10/10 no notes.
Tried this for my son’s birthday cookout this past weekend when our grill ran out of propane 20 minutes before guests arrived. Panic mode activated, dumped everything in the Instant Pot, and it was done before everyone finished their first round of chips and dip. Nobody even believed I made it in the pressure cooker! Question for the author – could I use bone-in skin-on thighs for this instead of breasts to save even more money?
So happy I found this! I’ve been looking for easy gluten-free weeknight meals that don’t cost a fortune, and this fits the bill perfectly. I just double-checked that my BBQ sauce was certified GF, threw everything in, and it came out amazing. My husband who swears he ‘hates healthy food’ went back for two servings. We’ll be adding this to our regular rotation for sure!
I don’t think I’ll ever make BBQ chicken any other way. I’m the kind of person who hates doing dishes, and this is literally one pot, minimal prep, no stirring, no watching the stove. I sat on my couch and watched a whole episode of my show while it cooked. Tossed it on some store-bought mac and cheese and had the coziest lazy Sunday dinner ever. So worth it.
Made this to take to my daughter’s soccer team snack night and the girls went crazy for it! I made little sliders with sweet Hawaiian rolls and they were gone in 10 minutes flat. So easy to transport, didn’t get soggy, and I didn’t spend a fortune feeding 12 hungry 10 year olds. Win win win.
Ran the numbers on this and it comes out to about $1.37 per serving. Are you KIDDING me? That’s cheaper than fast food, and way healthier. I used the cheap bone-in chicken thighs that were on manager’s special at my grocery store, a store brand BBQ sauce, and it tasted just as good as the BBQ chicken I get at my local smokehouse that costs $14 a plate. Absolute staple for anyone trying to cut their grocery bill.
Wait I messed this up the first time I made it – I accidentally put the pressure valve to vent instead of seal, so it took way longer than 35 minutes. Even with my user error, it still came out amazing! Shredded perfectly, the flavor was spot on, and my family didn’t even notice I messed up. Tried it again last night following the directions exactly, and it was even faster. Anyone else ever make that dummy mistake with their Instant Pot?
Used our own home-canned BBQ sauce and home-raised chicken for this recipe, and it was the best meal we’ve had all month! So simple, no fancy steps, let the quality of the simple ingredients shine. We had it with fresh green beans from the garden and cornbread, perfect farm to table dinner that didn’t require heating up the whole kitchen with the oven in this summer heat.