1.What cut of pork is most authentic for Michoacán-style carnitas, and can I use a leaner cut instead?
▾
Boneless pork shoulder (also called Boston butt) is the only authentic, reliable pick here, cut into uniform 5cm chunks for even cooking. Skip lean cuts like pork loin—they lack the rich intramuscular marbling that melts during slow cooking to keep meat shreddable and juicy, while creating those signature crispy golden edges. Lean cuts will turn tough and dry every time.
2.Do I really need to use lard for authentic carnitas, or can I substitute cooking oil?
▾
Lard is non-negotiable for true Michoacán-style carnitas—it delivers that rich, deep, savory flavor and ultra-crispy edge you can’t replicate with neutral cooking oil. If you have a dietary restriction, use rendered leaf lard for the closest result, or high-smoke-point avocado oil as a last resort, though the flavor will not match traditional versions.
3.Why is navel orange used in this recipe, and can I swap it for a different citrus?
▾
Navel orange adds that signature bright, subtle sweet-tart note that cuts through the rich pork and lard, without the harsh sourness of lime or bitter Seville orange. Toss in wedges to simmer with the pork so its oils and juice infuse slowly as the meat cooks. Avoid swapping for mandarins, which are overly sweet and lack balanced acidity.
4.What size should I cut the pork chunks to get the perfect carnitas texture?
▾
Aim for uniform 5cm (roughly 2-inch) chunks across the entire cut of pork. This size is ideal: large enough that the meat doesn’t dry out during long slow cooking, but small enough that every piece develops a nice crispy outer edge at the end of cooking. Uneven chunks lead to overcooked dry bits and undercooked chewy pieces.
5.How do I get that ideal mix of tender, shreddable meat and crispy golden edges?
▾
Cook the pork low and slow first in lard with the onion, garlic, and orange until it is fork-tender enough to shred easily, then turn the heat up slightly for the last 8 to 10 minutes. Let the edges of the pork sizzle and turn golden, stirring gently to avoid burning, so you get that perfect textural contrast in every bite.
6.Can I make these carnitas in a slow cooker instead of a stovetop Dutch oven?
▾
Absolutely! Toss all your ingredients (pork, lard, onion, garlic, orange) into the slow cooker, cover, and cook on LOW for 6 to 7 hours until the pork is fall-apart tender. To get the signature crispy edges, transfer the cooked pork to a rimmed baking sheet and broil for 3 to 5 minutes, watching closely to avoid burning.
7.What does the quartered yellow onion add to the recipe, and do I serve it with the final pork?
▾
The quartered yellow onion infuses the lard and pork with a deep, sweet, savory base flavor as it simmers, so you won’t need extra powdered onion seasoning. You can fish out the soft, translucent onion pieces once cooking is done, or chop a few up and mix them into the shredded pork for extra flavor if you prefer.
8.How do I use the crushed garlic so it doesn’t burn and make the carnitas bitter?
▾
Use 6 to 8 whole crushed garlic cloves (not finely minced) for a 3 to 4 pound pork shoulder, so the garlic flavor is warm and mellow rather than sharp. Since we add the garlic at the start of the low-and-slow braise, it won’t burn easily, but avoid cranking heat too high early on to prevent bitter, burnt garlic notes.
9.How long do leftover carnitas last, and what’s the best way to reheat them without sogginess?
▾
Store cooled leftover carnitas in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 4 days, or freeze for up to 3 months. To reheat without sogginess, spread the pork in a thin layer in a dry cast iron skillet over medium heat, tossing occasionally, until warmed through and edges crisp back up. Skip the microwave, which makes meat rubbery.
10.Are traditional Michoacán carnitas spicy, and what warm spices work best?
▾
Authentic Michoacán-style carnitas are not heavily spicy—they rely on warm, earthy spices like cumin, Mexican oregano, and a tiny pinch of cinnamon to complement the pork and citrus, rather than fiery hot chiles. Add these spices when you add the onion and garlic for balanced, traditional, well-rounded flavor.
11.Do I need to fully submerge the pork in lard to cook carnitas properly?
▾
You don’t need to fully submerge the pork in lard for great carnitas—this is a common home cook myth. Use about 1/2 cup of lard for a 4-pound pork shoulder; the pork will release its own fat and juices as it cooks, creating enough liquid to braise the meat slowly without wasting huge amounts of lard.
12.Can I use bone-in pork shoulder instead of boneless for this recipe?
▾
Bone-in pork shoulder works just as well as boneless for this recipe, and will even add a little extra deep, meaty flavor from the bone as it cooks. Just cut the meat away from the bone into 5cm chunks before cooking, and toss the cleaned bone into the pot for extra savoriness, removing it before you shred the final pork.
13.What are the best ways to serve these Michoacán-style carnitas?
▾
These carnitas are incredibly versatile! Serve them in warm corn tortillas for classic street tacos, topped with diced white onion, cilantro, and a squeeze of lime, or pile them into burritos, rice bowls, or loaded nachos. The crispy, citrus-kissed pork pairs perfectly with tangy salsa verde, pickled red onions, and creamy guacamole.
14.Why did my carnitas turn out tough and dry instead of tender and shreddable?
▾
Tough, dry carnitas almost always come down to one of two issues: you used a too-lean cut of pork with no marbling, or you cooked the pork at too high a heat too quickly, which squeezes out all the moisture before connective tissue can break down. Keep heat low for the braise stage, and stick to well-marbled pork shoulder for juicy results.
15.Should I season the pork with salt before cooking, or wait until it’s done?
▾
Season the pork chunks generously with kosher salt right before you add them to the pot with the lard—this helps draw out just enough surface moisture to build flavor, and lets the salt penetrate the meat as it slow cooks. Wait to add extra salt at the end until you taste, since rendered pork and lard have their own natural savoriness.
16.Can I add beer or cola to the braise like I’ve seen in other carnitas recipes?
▾
Many modern carnitas recipes use beer, cola, or condensed milk for extra sweetness, but those add-ins are not traditional to Michoacán-style preparations. The classic version relies only on lard, onion, garlic, navel orange, and warm spices to flavor the pork, letting the natural rich taste of slow-cooked pork be the star. Skip add-ins for authentic results.
OMG these carnitas are a GAME CHANGER. I made them for our weekly family taco night last night and everyone went back for seconds, even my super picky 7 year old who turns his nose up at everything! The cook time felt a little long on a weeknight but I prepped the pork the night before and it was totally worth it. Crispy on the edges, juicy in the middle, exactly like the carnitas I had when I visited Morelia a few years back. 10/10 will make again!
Took these to a neighborhood potluck over the weekend and people were literally asking me for the recipe before they even finished their first taco. I used a little extra orange juice like my abuela used to and it came out perfect. Only thing I will say is make sure you don’t skip the step where you crisp it up in the lard – I tried skimping last time I made carnitas and it was so bland and mushy. This recipe nails that authentic texture.
Made a big batch of these on Sunday for meal prep and they held up perfectly all week! I used them for tacos, burrito bowls, even breakfast hash with eggs and potatoes. So versatile, and the flavor only got better as the week went on. Way better than the takeout carnitas I used to buy down the street from my apartment.
This was my first time making carnitas from scratch and I was nervous I’d mess it up, but the instructions were super clear! The only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is I wish there was a note about how hot to keep the lard when crisping – I burned the first batch of edges because I had the stove too high. Still, the rest came out SO good, I’ll just turn the heat down next time.
I made these last weekend for my roommate’s birthday dinner and the flavor was absolutely incredible, but I had to use vegetable shortening because I keep a kosher kitchen and don’t cook with lard. It was good, but I know it was missing that rich, crispy texture lard gives. Is there a better substitute I could use next time? Don’t want to mess up that perfect flavor profile!
My husband is from Michoacán and he said these tasted exactly like the carnitas his tía makes for family reunions! I was so intimidated to make them for him because he’s super picky about authentic Mexican food, but he went back for three servings. Absolute win in my book.
Tried making these in my dorm with a Dutch oven and they turned out way better than I expected! I had to cut the recipe in half because I only have a tiny pot, but it still worked great. A little pricey to buy all the ingredients on a college budget, but worth it for a special weekend meal with my roommates. We ate so much we all had food comas after.
Game changer for taco night! I served these with pickled red onions, cilantro, lime, and that salsa verde recipe you linked, and it was better than any taco truck within 20 minutes of my house. My only note is that 2 hours 45 minutes is no joke – don’t start making this at 6pm if you want to eat before 9pm like I did lmao.
I’ve tried so many carnitas recipes over the years and this is by far the closest to the ones I got at a little roadside stand outside Uruapan when I was traveling in college. The combo of citrus, cinnamon, and bay leaf is so spot on, I can’t believe how simple the ingredient list is for how much flavor it has. Will be my go-to from now on.
I made these last night and the flavor was great, but it was way too salty for my taste! I followed the recipe exactly, used the amount of salt listed, but even after adding extra lime and avocado to cut it, my whole family thought it was over-salted. Did I do something wrong? I used regular table salt instead of kosher salt, would that do it?
Made these for my son’s birthday party over the weekend and set up a little taco bar with all the toppings. My kids loved it so much they asked for carnitas in their school lunches all week, and all the other parents raved about them too! I even had a few people ask if I catered, that’s how good they were. 10/10, will be making these for every big gathering from now on.
SO good. I was worried the cinnamon would be weird because I’ve never had carnitas with cinnamon before, but it adds this warm, deep background flavor that you can’t even place but makes it taste so authentic. I paired it with your pickled jalapeño recipe and it was chef’s kiss. My only regret is not making a double batch because we ate all of it in one sitting.
I grew up eating carnitas at my grandma’s house in Houston and these taste exactly like hers. The crispy bits are the best part – I always pick those out first before anyone else can get to them lmao. Took me longer than 2 hours 45 minutes because my Dutch oven runs a little hot, so I had to turn the temp down, but that’s just my stove being weird. 100% recommend this recipe to anyone who loves real carnitas, not the soggy stuff you get at chain restaurants.