Sicilian Pizza
intro
Thick, square-cut Sicilian pizza boasts a crispy, fluffy olive oil-kissed crust, tangy tomato sauce, and melted cheese, ideal for sharing with family.
Ingredients
Steps
Mix pizza dough
In a large mixing bowl, combine 500g 00 flour, 7g instant yeast, and 320ml warm water, stirring until a shaggy, lumpy mass forms. Add 10g fine sea salt and 30ml (2 tbsp) extra-virgin olive oil, then knead by hand on a clean counter for 7 minutes until the dough is smooth and elastic. Cover the bowl tightly with plastic wrap and let rise in a warm 24°C/75°F spot for 1.5 hours until doubled in volume.
Prep baking pan
Pour the remaining 30ml (2 tbsp) of olive oil across a 33x45cm (13x18 inch) rimmed aluminum sheet pan, using a silicone pastry brush to spread oil evenly across the entire pan bottom and 1cm up the sides. Do not line the pan with parchment paper, as direct contact between dough and hot oil creates the signature crispy, fried crust edge.
Stretch dough in pan
Turn the doubled, risen dough out directly onto the oiled sheet pan. Use lightly oiled fingertips to gently press, dimple, and stretch the dough to cover the entire pan surface. If the dough springs back and resists shaping, let it rest 5 minutes to relax the gluten before resuming stretching. Cover the pan loosely with a clean cotton kitchen towel and let the dough rest 20 minutes at room temperature.
Layer sauce and cheese
Spoon the lightly drained crushed San Marzano tomatoes over the rested dough, leaving a 1cm (1/2 inch) bare crust border around the pan edges, and spread into a thin, even layer. Avoid over-saucing to prevent a soggy finished crust. Sprinkle the shredded low-moisture mozzarella evenly over the sauce, followed by grated pecorino Romano and dried oregano.
Bake until crispy
Place the sheet pan on the middle rack of an oven preheated to 260°C (500°F). Bake for 18-20 minutes, rotating the pan 180 degrees halfway through the cook time to ensure even browning, until the crust edges are deep golden and crispy, cheese is bubbly with light brown spots, and the crust bottom lifts cleanly from the pan with a thin metal spatula.
Cool and slice
Immediately after removing the pan from the oven, run a thin metal spatula under the entire pizza to release it from the pan, then transfer it to a wire cooling rack for 5 minutes (this prevents trapped steam from making the bottom crust soggy). Cut into 8 equal square slices and serve warm.
Tips
2.For the lightest, fluffiest crust, do not press all the air out of the dough when stretching it in the pan—gentle dimpling preserves the air pockets that create the signature tender, open crumb.
3.For a traditional Sicilian topping variation, add 60g (1/2 cup) thinly sliced sweet yellow onion and 50g (1/3 cup) pitted, chopped oil-cured black olives over the cheese before baking.

OMG this is the real deal! I grew up eating Sicilian pizza at my nonna’s house in Brooklyn and I’ve been chasing that flavor for years. The thick, crispy bottom and pillowy center? *Chef’s kiss* Made this for Sunday family dinner and everyone went back for seconds, even my picky teen who only eats takeout. 10/10 will be making this every other week for meal prep!
Made this for our college football watch party potluck last weekend and it was gone in 10 minutes flat. People kept asking who ordered takeout from the fancy Italian place downtown! The crust holds up so well even loaded with pepperoni, sausage, and extra cheese. No soggy middle at all, which is usually my problem with thick crust pizza.
Wait, has anyone tried making this with a 1:1 gluten free flour blend? I have celiac and I’m dying for a good thick crust pizza that doesn’t taste like cardboard.
Game changer! I usually avoid yeast doughs because I’m convinced I’ll kill the yeast, but the step-by-step instructions here were so easy to follow. My kids loved it so much they asked if we can have 'homemade square pizza' every Friday night from now on. Only thing I changed was adding a sprinkle of parmesan to the crust before adding sauce.
Meal prepped three of these last Sunday to eat throughout the week and they held up amazing! I cut them into individual squares, wrapped them in foil, and reheated them in the toaster oven for 5 minutes for lunch. Tastes just as good as day one, way better than any frozen pizza I’ve ever bought.
Okay, don’t judge me but I accidentally let the dough rise for an extra hour because I got caught up in a video game. Was it still good? Absolutely, the crust was even airier! Only issue was my cheese slid off a little because I probably put too much sauce on. Oops.
This is the closest I’ve ever gotten to the Sicilian pizza I had on a trip to Palermo a few years ago. The thickness is perfect, not too bready, not too thin. The tip about letting the dough do a cold rise in the fridge overnight? Total game move, the depth of flavor is unreal.
Added spicy soppressata and a drizzle of hot honey on top after baking and WOW. The sweet heat pairs so perfectly with the thick, savory crust and tangy tomato sauce. My roommate said this is better than the $30 pizza we get from our local fancy spot.
Made this for my son’s soccer team banquet and all the kids devoured it. I was worried the thick crust would be too filling for them after running around all afternoon, but they came back for thirds. Even the other parents were asking for the recipe!
Took me a minute to get the dough pressed all the way to the edges of the pan without it springing back, I almost gave up! But once I let it rest for 15 minutes like the recipe said, it spread super easy. Crust came out perfectly crispy on the edges, chewy in the middle.
Made this vegan by swapping the cheese for dairy-free mozzarella and using olive oil instead of butter in the crust prep, and it came out SO good! I was worried the crust wouldn’t get that crispy golden bottom without dairy, but it was perfect. My nonna (who is very picky about her Sicilian pizza) even approved!
Made this for a date night in with my partner last night and we had so much fun stretching the dough and picking out toppings together. We did half mushroom and olive, half pepperoni, and ate the whole thing while watching old movies. Way more fun than ordering delivery, and way cheaper too!
Help! I made this last night and my crust came out really dense, not light and airy like the photos. Did I not knead it enough? I was scared to over-knead so I probably stopped too early.
Cooked this on my outdoor pizza oven attachment for the grill instead of the kitchen oven and OH MY GOODNESS. The wood fire flavor took this to a whole other level. Got that perfect char on the bottom crust just like the pizza shops back in New Jersey. 100% recommend trying it on the grill if you can.
This recipe is a total meal prep staple for me now! I make a double batch every Sunday, cut into squares, and keep them in the fridge for quick lunches and busy weeknight dinners. The crust doesn’t get soggy even after 4 days in the fridge, which is a miracle for thick crust pizza.
Loaded this up with four different cheeses: mozzarella, provolone, fontina, and a little pecorino sprinkled on top right after it came out of the oven. So cheesy, so gooey, the thick crust held every bite without flopping over. I think I ate three slices before I even sat down at the table. SO good.
The tomato sauce recipe included here is so simple but so flavorful! I usually doctor up my pizza sauce with a million spices, but the minimal seasoning here lets the sweet tomato flavor shine through. I even used the leftover sauce on pasta later that week, no regrets.
I live in a tiny studio apartment with a tiny oven, so I was worried I couldn’t make this, but I split the dough in half and made two smaller square pies in my 9x9 baking pans. Worked like a charm! The crust still got that perfect crispy edge, even in my janky old apartment oven.
Brought this to my office potluck yesterday and I’m pretty sure my coworkers are going to start paying me to make this for them every week. The boss even asked for the recipe, which is the highest compliment you can get at a work potluck, honestly. Worth every minute of prep time.
I’ve tried so many thick crust pizza recipes that turn out like soggy bread with toppings, but this one? The crust is crispy on the bottom, chewy around the edges, light and airy in the middle. Exactly what I’ve been looking for. The tip about oiling the pan generously? Total game changer, that crispy fried bottom is unbeatable.