Supreme Pizza
intro
Loaded with savory cured meats, crisp veggies, melted cheese, and zesty tomato sauce, this classic Italian-American supreme pizza is a crowd-pleasing, shareable favorite.
Ingredients
Steps
Preheat oven and prep peel
Place a 12-inch pizza stone or rimmed baking sheet on the middle oven rack, then preheat the oven to 245°C (475°F) for 20 minutes to ensure a fully hot cooking surface for a crisp crust. Lightly dust a pizza peel or 12-inch square of parchment paper with 1 teaspoon of fine cornmeal to prevent sticking.
Shape pizza dough
Set the 450g room-temperature pizza dough on the cornmeal-dusted peel or parchment. Gently press it into a 12-inch round, leaving a 1cm (1/2 inch) thicker raised border for the crust edge; avoid over-stretching or tearing the dough to prevent a tough texture. Brush the raised crust edge lightly with 1 teaspoon of olive oil.
Add sauce and base cheese
Spread the 120ml low-moisture pizza sauce evenly across the flat inner section of the dough, leaving the oiled crust border completely clear. Sprinkle 180 grams (1.5 cups) of the shredded low-moisture mozzarella in an even layer over the sauce to create a barrier that prevents soggy crust from wet toppings.
Layer meat toppings
Evenly distribute the 85g cooked, drained, crumbled Italian sausage and 60g thin-sliced pepperoni across the base cheese layer, spacing pieces so every bite includes both meats. Avoid piling toppings in the center of the pizza, as this traps moisture and leads to a soggy, undercooked middle.
Add veggie toppings
Scatter the 50g diced green bell pepper, 40g thinly sliced red onion, 30g sliced black olives, and 50g thin-sliced button mushrooms evenly over the meat layer. Top with the remaining 46 grams (0.5 cup) of shredded mozzarella, 2 tablespoons of grated parmesan, and 1 teaspoon of dried oregano to anchor veggies and add savory depth.
Bake until crisp
Carefully slide the pizza (on its parchment paper, if using) directly onto the preheated pizza stone or baking sheet. Bake for 12–14 minutes at 245°C (475°F), until the crust edge is deep golden and crisp, the cheese is bubbly across the surface, and pepperoni edges are slightly curled and crispy.
Rest, slice, and serve
Use the pizza peel to lift the baked pizza out of the oven, then transfer it to a wire cooling rack to rest for 3 minutes. Slice into 8 equal wedges and serve immediately. The short rest prevents hot cheese and toppings from sliding off when cut.
Tips
2.Fully cook and drain all grease from Italian sausage before adding it as a topping, to prevent greasy pools from forming on the pizza surface and making slices soggy.
3.Let refrigerated pizza dough rest at room temperature for 30 minutes before shaping, as cold dough will shrink back repeatedly and be difficult to stretch into an even round.

OMG this homemade supreme pizza is a total game changer for our Friday family pizza nights! I was so used to grabbing takeout, but this crust came out perfectly crispy, and the topping combo of pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions and olives hit every single note. My kids devoured two slices each before I even sat down! Only note: I added a little extra mozzarella because we’re cheese fiends over here. 10/10 will make every week.
Made this for our Sunday football watch party with the guys and it was gone in 10 minutes flat. Everyone kept asking where I ordered it from, couldn’t believe I made it from scratch! The cook time was exactly 45 minutes like the recipe said, which was perfect because I squeezed it in between pregame shows. Will definitely be making this for our next work potluck too.
I prepped all the toppings and portioned the dough on Sunday so I could throw this together quick on a busy weeknight, and it worked like a charm! I split the recipe into two smaller personal pies so my partner and I could customize a little (he hates black olives, total weirdo) and both of us were obsessed. Way better than the sad frozen pizzas we used to rely on for chaotic weeknights.
Okay, I’m a total beginner when it comes to making dough of any kind, so I was nervous to try this since the difficulty is listed as medium, but it was way more straightforward than I thought! My only mishap was piling on too many toppings on my first try, so the middle got a little soggy even though the crust edges were perfectly crispy. Any tips for avoiding that sogginess next time I make it?
Grew up in Brooklyn grabbing corner slice pizza every Friday after school, so I’m ridiculously picky about my supreme pies. I was fully skeptical a homemade recipe could measure up to my go-to neighborhood spot, but this is legit. The sauce has the perfect amount of oregano and garlic, the crust has that ideal chewy-crispy fold you can only get from a hot oven, and the topping ratio doesn’t skimp on anything. My only tiny tweak was adding a little sprinkle of grated parmesan on top right when it came out of the oven, total chef’s kiss.
Made this with my 7 year old tonight for our weekly kid cook night, and we had such a blast! She loved sprinkling the toppings on (even if half the pepperoni ended up in her mouth before it made it to the pizza) and she was so proud to tell her dad she made dinner all by herself. The flavor was SO good, even with the slightly lopsided crust and very uneven topping distribution. We’re already planning to make a controversial pepperoni and pineapple version next week, don’t @ me.
I’ve had a pizza stone sitting in my garage for two years that I’ve never touched, and this recipe finally gave me the excuse to break it out. Crust came out better than any restaurant pizza I’ve had in the last year, no cap. I added a handful of sliced mushrooms to the topping mix too, since supreme pizza isn’t complete without mushrooms in my opinion. 10/10, zero notes.
I was worried the sauce would be too bland because I didn’t have any fresh basil on hand when I went to make this, so I added a pinch of red pepper flakes and a tiny splash of balsamic vinegar, and oh my GOD it was so good. My roommate said it’s the best pizza she’s ever had, even better than the fancy wood-fired place downtown that charges $25 a pie. The medium difficulty rating felt totally fair, nothing too complicated even when I was fumbling around measuring ingredients right after getting home from work.
Made this for date night last night with my partner, and we both agreed it’s way more fun than going out to a crowded restaurant. We rolled the dough out together, argued over how many black olives was too many olives (for the record, there’s no such thing as too many), and ended up with a perfect crispy pizza that paired so well with the cheap red wine we picked up on the way home. 10/10 date night activity, will be repeating for sure.
I tried swapping half the all-purpose flour for whole wheat to make the crust a little more fiber-heavy, and it still turned out amazing! I was worried the crust would be dense or grainy, but it was still chewy and delicious, I could barely even tell the difference. I also used turkey Italian sausage instead of regular pork sausage to cut down a little on saturated fat, and no one in my family noticed a single difference. Definitely a huge win for a slightly healthier version of our usual takeout favorite.
Brought this to my neighborhood block party potluck last weekend and people were coming up to me asking for the recipe all night. I thought I made enough for 20 people and we still ran out in 20 minutes flat! The best part is it held up really well even on the 10 minute walk over to the park, no soggy crust or congealed cheese like delivery pizza gets when it sits out for a bit. 100% my new go-to dish for every group gathering from now on.