Turkey Bagheli Pot Pie
intro
A cozy Turkish-American fusion pot pie, pairing garlicky bagheli (fava beans) and savory ground turkey with flaky golden puff pastry, brightened with dill and lemon for warm, herby comfort.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep Filling Components
Place the acacia wood cutting board in the center of the work area. Using the 8-inch chef knife, finely dice the yellow onion, mince the garlic cloves, chop the fresh dill, and zest the lemon, transferring each prepped ingredient to separate small glass prep bowls. Bring a small pot of water to a boil, blanch fava beans for 1 minute, then shock in ice water; slip off the tough outer skins to reveal bright green inner beans, and add peeled beans to a prep bowl. Pat the ground turkey dry with a corner of the linen towel to remove excess moisture for better browning.
Sauté Turkey and Aromatics
Set the sage green enameled Dutch oven on the induction cooktop, heat to medium. Add 1 tablespoon olive oil and 2 tablespoons unsalted butter, swirling until butter melts and foaming subsides. Add diced onion, sauté for 3 minutes until soft and translucent, then add minced garlic and cook for 30 seconds until fragrant (do not let garlic burn). Add ground turkey, breaking it apart into small crumbles with the beech wood wooden spoon, and cook 5-6 minutes until no pink remains, seasoning with 1/2 teaspoon flaky salt and 1/4 teaspoon black pepper.
Simmer Fava Bean Filling
Add peeled fava beans and frozen peas to the Dutch oven, stirring to combine with the turkey mixture. Pour in heavy cream, 1 tablespoon fresh lemon juice, remaining 1/2 teaspoon salt and 1/4 teaspoon pepper, stirring gently. Bring to a gentle simmer (small bubbles breaking at the surface), then reduce heat to low and cook 4 minutes, until cream thickens enough to coat the back of the wooden spoon. Stir in 3/4 of the chopped dill and all lemon zest, then remove pot from heat to cool 5 minutes.
Roll Puff Pastry Top
Lightly dust a clean section of the acacia cutting board with all-purpose flour. Unfold the thawed all-butter puff pastry sheet, and use the stainless steel rolling pin to roll it into a circle 2 inches wider than the Dutch oven diameter, leaving enough pastry to overhang the rim for a tight seal. Cut three 1-inch slits in the center of the pastry circle to allow steam to vent during baking.
Assemble and Egg Wash
Carefully lift the rolled puff pastry and drape it over the top of the cooled filling in the Dutch oven, pressing edges firmly against the pot rim to seal, crimping overhanging pastry into a rustic, uneven edge with your fingers. Crack the large egg into the small cream ceramic ramekin, beat lightly with a fork until smooth. Use the silicone pastry brush to coat the entire exposed pastry surface with a thin, even layer of egg wash, taking care not to let egg pool in the center vent slits.
Bake Until Golden
Transfer the uncovered Dutch oven to a preheated 400°F (200°C) oven. Bake for 30-35 minutes, until puff pastry is deep golden brown, puffed 1-2 inches above the pot rim, and flaky, with thick filling bubbling up through the center vent slits. If pastry edges darken too quickly after 20 minutes, tent with a narrow strip of aluminum foil to prevent burning. Remove from oven and let rest 10 minutes before serving to allow the filling to set.
Plate and Garnish
Use the metal serving spoon to cut a generous wedge of pot pie, lifting carefully to keep the crust intact, and set it on a matte off-white ceramic dinner plate. Garnish with a sprinkle of the remaining fresh dill, a light twist of black pepper, and a tiny pinch of flaky sea salt. Serve warm.
Tips
2.Let the filling cool for 5 minutes before adding the pastry top: piping hot filling will melt the butter in the puff pastry prematurely, leading to a soggy, dense crust instead of a light, flaky, raised top.
3.For an extra authentic Turkish flavor boost, stir 1/4 teaspoon ground sumac into the filling with the lemon juice: its bright, tart, slightly earthy note pairs perfectly with creamy fava beans and savory turkey without overpowering the dish.

Made this last night for meal prep for the week and it held up so well! The bagheli seasoning is such a nice twist on regular pot pie, I was worried it would be too exotic for my husband but he went back for thirds. Only note is I added a handful of frozen peas because we had them on hand, worked great.
Wait, bagheli? I had no idea what that was when I clicked the recipe but I decided to give it a shot anyway. SO good. The warm, herby flavor pairs so perfectly with the creamy turkey and veggie filling. I made this for my buddy’s football watch party and everyone was asking for the recipe. Total win.
Okay, difficulty says medium and I’d say that’s fair — I’m a pretty new baker and I almost messed up the roux for the filling, but I followed the steps slow and it came out great. Cook time was right at 45 minutes for me too, no surprises. The only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is I wish there was a little more guidance on how to crimp the crust edges, mine looked a little wonky haha.
Made this with smoked turkey leftover from a weekend BBQ and holy cow, that smoky flavor with the bagheli spices? Chef’s kiss. I did add a dash of hot sauce on top when serving, which gave it the perfect little kick for my taste. Will absolutely be adding this to my regular rotation.
How does this reheat? I’m looking for recipes I can make on Sunday and pack for work lunches all week, I hate when pot pie gets all mushy when you microwave it.
My grandma used to make something similar with bagheli spices but I lost her recipe years ago, so I was so excited to find this! It tasted just like I remembered, I actually teared up a little when I took the first bite. Thank you so much for sharing this, it’s going to be a holiday staple in my house from now on.
Idk, I followed the recipe exactly but my bottom crust got totally soggy. What did I do wrong? I blind baked it for 10 minutes like the note said but it still was mushy under the filling. Flavor was great, texture just threw me off.
Brought this to our neighborhood block party last weekend and it was gone in 10 minutes flat! People kept coming up to me asking if I’d bought it from a fancy bakery, little did they know it was way easier than it looks. Pro tip: top with a little flaky sea salt right when it comes out of the oven, it elevates the whole thing.
Made this for a casual date night in and my boyfriend was so impressed he thought I ordered takeout from that fancy British pie shop downtown. The only swap I made was using a mix of sweet potato and regular potato in the filling, added such a nice subtle sweetness. 10/10, date night win.
Told my kids we were having ‘bagel pot pie’ because I misread the name, they were so confused when there were no bagels in it. Joke’s on them though, they ate every last bite even without the bagels. Will be making this again, even if I still accidentally call it bagel pot pie.
Swapped the regular pie crust for a gluten free all-purpose crust and it worked perfectly! The seasoning is so flavorful you can’t even tell it’s GF, my whole family (who eats regular gluten) didn’t notice a difference. Great recipe that’s super easy to adapt for dietary needs.
I’ve never made a pot pie from scratch before, I usually just buy the frozen kind, and this was so much better! I was intimidated by the medium difficulty rating but the steps were super straightforward, I didn’t even burn anything. My roommate is already begging me to make it again next weekend.
I was worried the bagheli spice would be too overpowering because I’m a total wimp when it comes to strong spices, but it was perfectly balanced! It’s warm and cozy without being spicy, just super flavorful. I did cut the black pepper a little just to be safe, and it was perfect for me.
How long do leftovers keep in the fridge? I’m making this for Friendsgiving and want to make sure I can send people home with leftovers without it going bad too fast.
Tried this last night and it was solid. The filling was super creamy, the turkey was tender, the crust was flaky. I think next time I’ll add a little more garlic because I’m a garlic fiend, but that’s just personal preference. Definitely a solid weeknight dinner option if you prep the veggies ahead.
My wife made this last night and I was fully prepared to pick out all the carrots and celery, but the seasoning was so good I ate all the veggies without even complaining. Don’t tell her I said that though, I’ll never hear the end of it. 5 stars no cap.
Made mini versions of these in muffin tins for my kid’s school bake sale and they sold out in 20 minutes! I cut the crust into circles, pressed them into the tin, added the filling, and put a little crust circle on top. Perfect hand-held size, all the parents were asking for the recipe.
This recipe is so affordable to make! I used leftover turkey from a cheap grocery store rotisserie turkey breast I picked up on sale, frozen mixed veggies, store bought crust, and the whole thing cost under $10 to make and fed 4 people. Total win for my college student budget.
This is the ultimate cold weather comfort food! I made it on Sunday when it was pouring rain outside and the whole house smelled amazing for hours. It was warm, creamy, so satisfying, exactly what I wanted on a gross fall day. Served it with a little side salad and it was the perfect dinner.
I’m usually a classic beef pot pie guy, no frills, no weird spices, but my wife convinced me to try this turkey version and I’ve been converted. The bagheli spice isn’t ‘weird’ at all like I thought it would be, it just adds a really nice depth of flavor that regular pot pie is missing. I’ll still make my beef version sometimes, but this is going in the regular rotation for sure.