Annie's Mac and Cheese
intro
Creamy, nostalgic stovetop mac and cheese made with iconic Annie's organic cheddar, upgraded for extra richness without losing beloved childhood comfort flavor, ready in 20 minutes.
Ingredients
Steps
Boil Salted Water
Fill the 4-quart brushed stainless steel stock pot with 6 cups cold tap water, stir in 1 teaspoon kosher salt, and set on the front left stovetop burner over high heat. Bring to a full rolling boil (approximately 8 minutes), where large bubbles break continuously across the water surface. Skip adding oil to the water, as it prevents cheese sauce from sticking to noodles later.
Cook Elbow Pasta
Tear open the dry elbow pasta packets from both mac and cheese boxes, pour all pasta into the boiling water. Stir immediately with the long beech wood stirring spoon to prevent noodles from sticking to the pot base. Cook for 8 minutes, stirring occasionally, until pasta is al dente: tender but with a slight firm bite at the center, not mushy. Before draining, carefully pour 1/4 cup of cloudy starchy pasta water into the clear glass measuring cup to reserve for sauce adjustment.
Drain Cooked Pasta
Turn off stovetop heat. Set the matte pastel blue silicone colander in the undermount stainless steel sink. Use the quilted cream cotton pot holder to grip the hot pot handle, and pour all pasta and water into the colander to drain fully. Do not rinse the pasta: the starchy outer coating helps cheese sauce cling smoothly to noodles. Shake the colander gently to remove all excess water.
Melt Butter for Sauce
Return the empty stock pot to the stovetop over low heat. Add 4 tablespoons unsalted butter to the warm pot, stirring with the beech wood spoon until fully melted into a smooth golden liquid, about 1 minute. Do not let the butter brown, sizzle aggressively, or burn, as this will create a bitter off-flavor in the finished sauce.
Mix in Cheese Powder
Tear open both cheddar cheese powder packets, pour all bright orange cheese powder into the melted butter. Stir constantly with the beech wood spoon for 30 seconds until a thick, smooth, lump-free orange paste forms, with no dry clumps of powder left on the pot bottom or sides.
Combine and Stir Sauce
Add all drained elbow pasta back into the pot with the cheese paste. Pour in 1/2 cup whole milk, the reserved 1/4 cup starchy pasta water, optional 1/4 cup shredded sharp cheddar, 1/4 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper, and pinch of ground nutmeg. Stir vigorously for 1-2 minutes, until every noodle is evenly coated in a glossy, creamy cheese sauce that coats the spoon when lifted. Adjust consistency as needed: add 1 tablespoon extra milk if too thick, or stir over low heat 1 minute if too thin.
Plate and Serve
Scoop generous portions of the warm mac and cheese into the matte off-white ceramic shallow pasta bowls. Top each serving with a light extra sprinkle of black pepper, and serve immediately while hot and creamy.
Tips
2.Never rinse cooked pasta for mac and cheese: rinsing washes away the starchy outer coating on noodles that helps cheese sauce cling evenly, leading to watery, sliding sauce and bland flavor.
3.Add a tiny pinch of ground nutmeg to cheddar sauce: the warm spice doesn't taste like nutmeg in the final dish, but it amplifies the nutty, savory notes of cheddar for a deeper, more rounded cheese flavor with zero extra work.

OMG this is the only stovetop mac and cheese recipe I will ever make from now on! 15 minutes total? Game changer for weeknight dinners when my two boys are screaming for food right after soccer practice. It’s so creamy, no grainy cheese sauce at all, even when I use a mix of sharp cheddar and a little colby jack I had leftover in the fridge. Took this to our neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were begging for the recipe! Wait quick question—can I make this ahead for meal prep and reheat it later in the week without the sauce breaking?
Super easy recipe, tasted way better than the boxed stuff I grew up on. Only thing I did different was add a pinch of smoked paprika and a little handful of crispy breadcrumbs on top for a tiny crunch. My picky 7 year old ate two full servings and asked if we could have it again tomorrow. Total win for family dinner night.
Made this in my dorm room on a little hot plate and it turned out perfect!!! No fancy equipment needed, ingredients are super cheap and easy to grab at the campus grocery store. Way better than paying $12 for sad cafe mac and cheese. 10/10 will be making this every week when I don’t feel like walking to the dining hall.
Wait why did I think making creamy mac and cheese from scratch was hard? This took literally 15 minutes like the recipe said, zero stress. I brought this to my friend’s game night and everyone thought I spent an hour on it. Only tiny note: I used pre-shredded cheese first and the sauce was a little thicker than I wanted, so next time I’ll shred my own like the recipe says.
Tried this last night for my daughter’s birthday dinner per her request (she is OBSESSED with mac and cheese) and she said it’s the best I’ve ever made. The sauce is so silky, no weird clumps even when I messed up and added the cheese a little too fast at first. Quick question for folks who have made this—has anyone added bacon or pulled pork to it to make it a little heartier? Thinking about making it again for our camping trip next weekend.
SO good! I’m a terrible cook and I still pulled this off without burning anything or making a lumpy sauce. The recipe steps are so straightforward, no weird fancy ingredients I had to track down at a specialty store. Added a little hot sauce on top for a kick and it was chef’s kiss. My roommate walked in and thought I ordered takeout lmao
I’ve been making mac and cheese for my grandkids for over 40 years and I have to say, this recipe is a keeper! It’s quick, it’s creamy, it doesn’t require baking in the oven for half an hour which is perfect when the little ones are running around the house and can’t wait for dinner. I added a tiny pinch of nutmeg like my mom used to and it gave the sauce such a warm, cozy flavor. Will definitely be adding this to my regular rotation.