Bagel Cart Bagel
intro
Chewy, golden New York City street cart-style bagels, boiled then baked for a crisp crust and dense soft interior, served with a classic cream cheese schmear.
Ingredients
Steps
Mix bagel dough
In a large stand mixer fitted with a dough hook, combine 500g high-gluten bread flour, 7g instant yeast, 10g kosher salt, 15ml (1 tbsp) barley malt syrup, and 300ml warm (40°C/105°F) water. Knead on medium-low speed for 8 minutes, until the dough is smooth, tight, and pulls cleanly away from the bowl sides; it will be firmer than standard bread dough with no sticky residue on your fingers when touched.
First dough rise
Coat the inside of a clean large glass bowl with 5ml (1 tsp) neutral canola oil, form the kneaded dough into a tight ball, and place it seam-side down in the bowl. Cover tightly with plastic wrap and let rest in a warm, draft-free spot (24°C/75°F) for 60 minutes, until the dough doubles in size and springs back slowly when poked with a floured finger.
Shape bagel rounds
Punch the risen dough firmly in the center to release all trapped air, then divide it evenly into 4 equal 200g portions. Roll each portion into a tight, smooth ball, then press a floured index finger through the center of each ball to create a 5cm (2 inch) hole. Stretch the hole slightly to prevent it from closing during baking, set shaped bagels on a parchment-lined baking sheet, cover with a damp cotton tea towel, and rest for 15 minutes.
Boil bagel batches
Preheat your oven to 220°C (425°F) while the shaped bagels rest. Fill a large stockpot with 4 liters (1 gallon) of cold water, bring to a full rolling boil over high heat, then stir in the remaining 30ml (2 tbsp) barley malt syrup and 14g (1 tbsp) baking soda. Gently lower 2 bagels at a time into the boiling water, cook for 60 seconds per side, then lift out with a slotted spoon, let excess water drain for 10 seconds, and return to the parchment-lined baking sheet.
Top and bake bagels
While the boiled bagels are still slightly damp on the surface, sprinkle 20g (2 tbsp) of everything bagel seasoning evenly over the tops of all 4 bagels. Bake on the middle oven rack at 220°C (425°F) for 20 minutes, rotating the baking sheet 180 degrees at the 10-minute mark to ensure even browning, until the bagels are deep golden brown with a shiny, crisp outer crust.
Cool and serve
Transfer the baked bagels to a wire cooling rack to rest for 10 minutes; do not cut them immediately, as this allows the chewy interior crumb to set fully. Slice each bagel horizontally across the middle, then spread 56g (2 oz) of room-temperature full-fat plain cream cheese evenly across both cut sides, just as a New York street cart vendor would serve them.
Tips
2.Use high-gluten bread flour (12-14% protein) for the chewy, dense texture cart bagels are known for; all-purpose flour has lower protein and will result in soft, bread-like bagels that lack the classic bite.
3.Wait for a full rolling boil before adding bagels, and never boil more than 2 at a time: overcrowding the pot lowers water temperature, making bagels absorb excess water and turn out soggy and flat.

OMG these taste EXACTLY like the everything bagels I grab from the cart outside my office in midtown! I was so skeptical I could get that chewy, perfect crust at home but this recipe nailed it. Did a quick boil with a little honey like the recipe said and the texture was chef’s kiss. My husband ate three straight out of the oven lmao. Game changer for weekend brunch!
Really solid bagel recipe! Cook time was pretty spot on for a weekend bake, I made a dozen on Sunday and have been grabbing them for quick breakfasts all week. Only knock is I think my water was a touch too hot when I proofed the yeast so my first batch didn’t rise as much, second batch was perfect though. Will absolutely make again.
SO good! I added a little cinnamon raisin mix to half the batch for my kids and they went crazy for them. Way better than the grocery store bagels that are all squishy and no chew. Already texted this recipe to my whole mom group for our next potluck.
Tried this yesterday to go with my morning cold brew and wow, chewy, malty, exactly the bagel I miss from my NYC college days. Wait, quick question — has anyone tried making these ahead and freezing them? I want to stock up for busy work weeks.
Hmm, these were tasty but mine came out a lot denser than I expected. I followed the recipe exactly but I think I overworked the dough when I was kneading? Not sure, might need to try again when I have more time to focus.
Made these for our neighborhood block party last weekend and people were asking me for the recipe left and right! I did a mix of plain, sesame, and everything so there was something for everyone. Even the guy who swears he only likes NYC deli bagels said these were the real deal. Total win!
Loved that these don’t have all the weird preservatives you get in store bought bagels! I topped mine with a little avocado and red pepper flakes for a post-gym breakfast and it kept me full for hours. Cook time felt a little long but it’s 100% worth the effort for how good these turn out.
Wait a SECOND. I’ve been chasing that perfect bagel cart bagel since I moved to Florida 3 years ago and I swear this is it. The chewy crust, the soft inside, that slight malty sweetness from the boil? I could cry. No more paying $15 to have bagels shipped down from NYC for me lmao.
Was nervous to try these because I’m a total beginner and the difficulty says medium, but the steps were super easy to follow! I messed up the shaping on a couple so they look a little wonky but they taste incredible. My roommates are already begging me to make another batch this weekend.
Pro tip for anyone making these: toss a handful of cornmeal on your baking sheet before you put the bagels on, they don’t stick at all and you get that perfect little crunchy bottom just like the cart bagels. I’ve made this recipe three times now and it’s never let me down.
These are so good! I made a batch with whole wheat flour for a little extra fiber and they turned out great, just needed a touch extra water to get the dough the right consistency. Only thing is I wish the recipe had notes on how to do different toppings, but I just experimented and it worked out.
Made these for Father’s Day brunch last weekend and my whole family lost their minds. We set up a little bagel bar with lox, cream cheese, capers, tomato, red onion, the works. Felt like we were at a fancy deli instead of our own kitchen. 10/10, will be a monthly tradition from now on.
Wait, help! I’m halfway through making these and my dough isn’t rising at all? I used instant yeast like the recipe said, did I kill it? The bagels are gonna be for my partner’s birthday breakfast tomorrow and I’m panicking a little 😅
SO good! I added a little jalapeño and cheddar to a few of the bagels before boiling and they were insane. The chew is exactly right, not bready at all like so many homemade bagel recipes I’ve tried. This is my go-to bagel recipe from now on, no contest.
These are a total meal prep game changer! I make a batch every Sunday, slice them up, and keep them in the fridge for quick breakfasts all week. Toast them up for 3 minutes and they taste just as fresh as the day I baked them. Way cheaper than buying bagels every morning too, I’ve saved so much money this month!