baileys cocktails
intro
Three luxuriously creamy, perfectly balanced Baileys cocktails—spiced hot sipper, mudslide, and espresso martini twist—ideal for cozy winter gatherings, smooth and rich without cloying sweetness.
Ingredients
Steps
Measure all ingredients
First, use the polished stainless steel jigger to measure out all ingredients for accuracy: 240ml Baileys Original Irish Cream, 120ml whole milk, 60ml plain vodka, 60ml Kahlua coffee liqueur, 60ml cooled freshly brewed espresso. Set all measured liquids in small clear prep cups near the cocktail shaker. Place the coupe glass and rocks glass in the freezer to chill for 5 minutes while you prep the drinks, leaving the two hot toddy mugs out at room temperature.
Warm spiced milk
Pour the 120ml whole milk into the matte black enamel saucepan on the portable induction burner, add 1/2 tsp ground cinnamon, and heat over medium-low heat for 3-4 minutes, stirring occasionally with the twisted-handle bar spoon, until small bubbles form around the edge of the pan and the milk reaches 70C/160F. Do not boil the milk, as high heat will cause curdling when mixed with alcohol. Remove the pan from heat immediately once the correct temperature is reached.
Build hot Baileys drinks
Divide 120ml of the measured Baileys evenly between the two thick-walled hot toddy mugs (60ml per mug). Pour the warm spiced milk evenly over the Baileys in each mug, stirring gently once with the bar spoon to combine. Avoid over-stirring, as this can create a watery texture.
Garnish hot cocktails
Top each hot mug with 20g of fluffy whipped cream, a light dusting of unsweetened cocoa powder (about 1/8 tsp per mug), and one whole cinnamon stick placed across the rim of each mug as a built-in stirrer. Set the finished hot mugs toward the back of the counter to retain heat while you prepare the cold cocktails.
Shake mudslide cocktail
Add 1 cup of crushed ice to the Boston cocktail shaker, then pour in 60ml Baileys, 30ml vodka, and 30ml Kahlua. Seal the shaker tightly, and shake vigorously for 15 seconds, until the outside of the shaker feels frosty to the touch. Retrieve the chilled rocks glass from the freezer, add 1/2 cup of fresh crushed ice to the glass, then strain the shaken mudslide mixture over the ice using the fine-mesh strainer.
Finish mudslide drink
Sprinkle 1 tbsp of dark chocolate shavings over the top of the mudslide, letting a few shavings rest on the ice surface for added texture. Set the finished mudslide beside the hot mugs on the counter while you prepare the final cocktail.
Mix espresso martini
Empty the remaining ice and melted water from the Boston shaker, then add 1/2 cup fresh crushed ice, 60ml Baileys, 30ml vodka, and 60ml cooled espresso. Seal the shaker tightly, and shake extra vigorously for 20 seconds — the extra agitation creates the signature light, frothy top on the martini. Retrieve the chilled coupe glass from the freezer, and double-strain the mixture into the glass using the fine-mesh strainer to catch any small ice chips.
Garnish espresso martini
Top the center of the martini foam with three whole dark roast coffee beans, arranged in a small triangle as the classic garnish. Arrange all four finished cocktails in a loose semi-circle at the center of the counter for serving.
Tips
2.Never boil milk for the hot Baileys: high heat causes milk proteins to curdle when mixed with the alcohol in Baileys, creating a lumpy, unpleasantly textured drink instead of a smooth, luxurious sip. Heat only until small bubbles form around the pan edge, around 70C/160F.
3.Shake the espresso martini for 5 seconds longer than other creamy cocktails: the extra agitation creates a thick, stable frothy top that holds the coffee bean garnish in place, instead of letting the foam dissolve immediately after pouring.

OMG these were such a game changer for my girls' night last weekend! I cannot believe how fast they came together—literally 5 minutes like the recipe says, no fancy tools needed. The salted caramel one was everyone’s favorite, I had people begging for the recipe before they even finished their first glass. 10/10 will be making these for every holiday get together from now on!
Wait a second, can I make a non-alcoholic version of these for my teen cousin’s birthday dinner? She loves creamy sweet drinks but obviously can’t have the Baileys, was thinking of swapping for that Baileys non-alc creamer? Would that work?
SO good. I made these for my poker night with the guys and even the boys who claim they ‘hate sweet drinks’ went back for seconds. The espresso variation hit so hard, perfect pick me up when we were halfway through the tournament and getting sleepy. No notes, this recipe is flawless.
I was a little short on Baileys so I swapped a quarter of it for vanilla vodka in the white chocolate version and wow, that might be my new go-to. Super creamy, not too strong, just the right amount of sweet.
I hosted a potluck for my book club last night and these were the first thing gone off the snack and drink table! I was stressed I wouldn’t have time to make fancy drinks between all the food prep, but 5 minutes flat? Total lifesaver. Even my friend who is super picky about creamy cocktails loved the mint chocolate one.
Made these for my date night in with my partner last night and they tasted just like the fancy $18 cocktails we get at the downtown cocktail lounge. Saved so much money making them at home, will absolutely be making these again.
Love the flavor of these but when I made them last night the texture was a little clumpy? I think I added the ice too fast maybe? Any tips to get that super smooth creamy texture next time?
Made these for our Fourth of July cookout and I swear every single adult at the party asked me for the recipe. I added a little red white and blue sugar rim to make them festive and they looked so cute. 10/10, easy enough even for a guy who burns toast half the time.
Wait I was skeptical because a lot of creamy cocktail recipes are way too heavy for me, but these are perfectly balanced! Not too thick, not too sweet, the Baileys flavor comes through without being overpowering. I brought the ingredients to my office happy hour last Friday and my whole team was obsessed.
I tested these for my annual Christmas party this year and they are going to be the star of the drink menu. I added a little crushed candy cane on the rim of the mint chocolate one and it tastes like a boozy peppermint patty, so good.
Hey! I have celiac so I have to be super careful with ingredients—are these naturally gluten free if I use regular Baileys? I thought Baileys had gluten in it but I saw somewhere the original is GF now? Would love to make these for my sister’s baby shower (adults only, obviously lol).
Made these after a long day of hiking last weekend with my friends and they were the perfect cozy nightcap. We sat around the fire pit sipping them and it was chef’s kiss. So easy to throw together even when you’re tired and sore from a 10 mile hike.
I’m a broke college student and I was able to grab all the ingredients for under $30 to make these for my roommate’s birthday pregame. Way cheaper than going out to the bars, and they taste way better than the cheap seltzers we usually drink. 10/10 for any college kid looking for a fancy but easy drink.
I swapped the regular Baileys for the vegan Baileys Almande and used coconut cream instead of heavy cream and these turned out AMAZING. You honestly can’t even tell they’re dairy free, my non-vegan friends had no idea.
Made these for our tailgate before the Buckeyes game last weekend and they were a touchdown. So easy to mix up in a big batch and pass around in disposable cups, no fancy glassware needed. Will be a regular for all future tailgates.
My husband and I made these for our first Friday night in our new house and it felt like such a special little celebration! We are total cocktail newbies so we were worried we’d mess them up, but the instructions were so straightforward, zero mistakes. The salted caramel one is our new favorite.
How many servings does this recipe make as written? I’m hosting 25 people for a Halloween party next weekend and need to know how much to scale it up so I don’t run out mid-party. Also, can I make it in a big punch bowl instead of individual glasses?
These taste exactly like the boozy milkshakes I used to get at the old diner in my hometown when I turned 21. So nostalgic, creamy, perfectly sweet. I added a little maraschino cherry on top of each one and it gave such a fun retro vibe. Obsessed.
The espresso Baileys version is my new go-to morning cocktail for weekend brunch. It’s like having a boozy latte that’s sweet and creamy, pairs perfectly with pancakes and bacon. I’ve already made it three Sundays in a row.
I made these for my grandkid’s graduation party last weekend (for the adults, obviously!) and everyone raved about them. I’m 72 and I don’t know much about fancy cocktails, but these were so easy even I could pull them off. I even let my teenage granddaughter (who’s 19, almost 20!) have a tiny sip and she said they tasted like dessert.