best hot toddy
intro
Warming, aromatic, and perfectly balanced, the best hot toddy chases winter chills, soothes scratchy throats, and wraps you in soft, cozy comfort with every spiced, honey-sweet sip.
Ingredients
Steps
Heat Fresh Water
Fill the matte brushed stainless steel electric kettle with 12 ounces (360ml) of cold filtered water, then set to boil. Heat until the water reaches a rolling boil (212°F / 100°C), then turn off the kettle and let it rest for 30 seconds so it stops bubbling vigorously. Water at a full rolling boil can scorch honey and make whiskey taste harsh, so this short rest is critical for a smooth, balanced drink.
Slice and Stud Lemon
Place the whole fresh lemon on the small honey-toned wood cutting board. Use the stainless steel paring knife to cut two 1/4-inch thick round slices from the center of the lemon, reserving the tapered end pieces on the edge of the board for optional extra juice. Push 3 whole cloves into the rind of each lemon slice, spacing them evenly around the edge so they do not fall out during steeping.
Add Honey to Mugs
Twist open the gold metal lid from the clear glass honey jar, setting the lid on the counter immediately beside the jar. Use the wooden honey dipper to measure 1 tablespoon (20g) of raw wild honey into the bottom of each 12oz clear glass toddy mug. Twirl the dipper slowly as you lift it from the mug to avoid sticky drips on the marble counter.
Dissolve Honey Thoroughly
Pour 6 ounces (180ml) of the slightly rested hot water from the electric kettle into each mug, pouring directly over the honey at the bottom. Use the long-handled twisted stainless steel bar spoon to stir each mug vigorously for 15 seconds, until the honey is completely dissolved and no thick golden streaks remain pooled at the bottom of the glass.
Add Whiskey and Lemon
Pour 2 ounces (60ml) of bourbon whiskey from the amber bottle into each mug, pouring slowly to avoid splashing hot liquid. Gently drop one clove-studded lemon slice into each drink. Do not stir vigorously after adding whiskey and lemon, as this can agitate the cloves and release bitter, astringent oil into the drink too quickly.
Steep and Serve
Place one 10cm curled cinnamon stick into each mug, leaning it against the inner rim so part of the stick extends above the liquid for easy gripping. Let the toddy steep for 2 minutes to let the clove and cinnamon flavors infuse gently, then give the drink one slow, gentle stir with the bar spoon. The toddy is ready to serve when it cools to a sip-friendly 160°F (71°C), hot enough to warm you but not scalding.
Tips
2.Choose smooth bourbon or blended Scotch instead of peaty Islay single malt: Smoky, peaty whiskies clash with bright lemon and sweet honey, giving the toddy a harsh, medicinal flavor instead of its signature cozy, balanced taste.
3.Do not over-steep the spices: Leaving cloves or cinnamon in the drink for longer than 5 minutes leaches bitter tannins into the liquid. If you prefer a stronger spice flavor, add an extra cinnamon stick rather than extending steep time.

OMG this is exactly what I needed when I came down with that nasty winter cold last week! Threw it together in 2 minutes flat, soothed my scratchy throat instantly and tasted way better than the sad hot toddies I’ve ordered at bars. Will be making this all cold and flu season for sure!
Super solid recipe! I swapped the regular honey for wildflower honey from my neighbor’s beehive and it slapped. Only reason it’s not 5 stars is I wish it had a little more clove kick, but that’s just personal preference.
Made this for our little neighborhood potluck pre-game last weekend when it was 20 degrees outside, and everyone was begging for the recipe! It’s so easy even my 16 year old can make it without messing up, total game changer for cold winter nights.
Just got back from a freezing 4 mile hike in the mountains and made this the second I walked in the door. Warmed me right up from my toes to my nose, SO good. I added a tiny cinnamon stick stirrer and it felt like a fancy apres-ski drink without the fancy price tag.
Wait why did no one tell me a hot toddy actually works for a brutal sore throat? I was skeptical because I don’t even really like whiskey, but this was so smooth and my throat felt 50% better 10 minutes after drinking it. Life saver.
It’s fine, super quick to make which is nice, but I feel like it’s missing something? Maybe a splash of orange bitters? Tasted a little plain to me compared to hot toddies I’ve had at cocktail bars.
Made this for my husband last night when he was complaining about chills after working outside all day, and he said it’s better than the one his grandma used to make! That’s the highest possible praise in our house, tbh. We’ll be adding this to our regular winter rotation.
Brought a spiked and a non-alcoholic version (swapped whiskey for extra apple cider) to our church potluck last Sunday and both batches were gone in 15 minutes! The non-alcoholic one was such a hit with the kids and the folks who don’t drink, I never would have thought to make that version if I hadn’t seen how simple the base recipe is.
Just got off a 12 hour overnight shift in the ER, it’s sleeting outside, and this is the first thing I made when I got home. Literally the perfect wind-down drink, I don’t even have the energy for complicated recipes right now and this came together so fast I almost cried. 10/10.
Super easy to make in my dorm room with just the microwave, no fancy equipment or stove required! Only knock is I used cheap bourbon instead of whiskey and it was a little harsh, but that’s 100% my bad for using what I had lying around.
I’ve been making hot toddies for over 40 years, and let me tell you, this recipe is as close to perfect as it gets. No fancy frills, just the right ratio of ingredients, done in 2 minutes. My granddaughter asked for the recipe after she tried it last weekend, so that says something.
My seasonal allergies have been absolutely wrecking my throat and sinuses this week, and this hot toddy is the only thing that’s given me any relief! I didn’t have fresh lemon so I used bottled lemon juice and it still turned out great, which is perfect because I didn’t feel like running to the store.
Made this for our at-home date night last night when we didn’t feel like going out in the snow, paired it with warm chocolate chip cookies and it was better than any overpriced cocktail we would’ve gotten at a downtown bar. My partner said it’s their new favorite cold weather drink, huge win!