ButterBurger
intro
Juicy butter-basted beef patties, melted cheese, and soft butter-toasted buns come together for the iconic, rich Wisconsin-style comfort food classic.
Ingredients
Steps
Form beef patties
Divide 680 grams of 80/20 ground beef into 4 equal 170-gram portions. Gently shape each portion into a 10cm (4-inch) wide, 1.5cm thick patty, pressing a shallow 1cm dimple in the center of each to prevent bulging during cooking. Season both sides evenly with 3 grams (1 teaspoon) kosher salt and 1 gram (½ teaspoon) black pepper, then set aside at room temperature for 10 minutes.
Preheat pan, melt butter
Place a large 30cm (12-inch) cast-iron skillet over medium-high heat (190°C/375°F) for 3 minutes until the surface is faintly smoking. Add 85 grams (6 tablespoons) of salted butter to the skillet; once fully melted and foaming subsides (about 45 seconds), tilt the pan to coat the entire cooking surface evenly with butter.
Sear first patty side
Carefully place the seasoned patties into the buttered skillet in a single layer, as a 30cm (12-inch) pan will fit all 4 patties without overcrowding. Maintain medium-high heat, and cook for 3 full minutes without moving the patties, until the bottom develops a deep golden-brown, crispy seared crust.
Baste patties and add cheese
Flip each patty with a stiff metal spatula, then immediately tilt the skillet slightly to pool melted butter at one edge. Use a large spoon to continuously baste the top of each patty with hot butter for 2 minutes. Place one 28-gram slice of American cheese on top of each patty, then continue basting for 1 more minute until cheese is fully melted and patties reach an internal temperature of 71°C/160°F for medium doneness. Transfer cooked patties to a clean plate to rest for 2 minutes.
Toast hamburger buns
Turn stovetop heat down to medium (175°C/350°F). Place the cut, split sides of the 4 soft white hamburger buns face-down into the remaining melted butter and beef drippings in the skillet. Toast for 45 seconds until the cut surfaces are light golden and lightly crisp, then remove buns from the pan and set aside.
Assemble butter burgers
Layer each bottom toasted bun with 15 grams of drained dill pickle slices and 30 grams of thinly sliced raw yellow onion, top with one rested cheese-covered beef patty, then cap with the matching top toasted bun. Serve immediately while patties are hot and buns are crisp from toasting.
Tips
2.Never press down on patties with a spatula while cooking, as this forces out flavorful butter and beef fat, resulting in dry, less juicy burgers.
3.Use soft white hamburger buns instead of crusty artisanal rolls, as the soft, pillowy texture absorbs melted butter and patty juices for the authentic Midwestern bite.

OMG, this tastes exactly like the butterburgers I grew up eating at small town drive-ins in Wisconsin! I made these for Sunday family dinner and every single person went back for seconds. The butter on the bun? Total game changer, I’ll never make a regular burger again.
Took these to a neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were asking me for the recipe before I even set the platter down! Super easy to throw together even when you’re juggling 3 kids running around the yard. 10/10, will be making these all summer long.
Wait, how well do these hold up for meal prep? I usually make burger patties on Sunday for the week, but I’m worried the buttery bun will get soggy if I assemble them ahead of time.
So easy even I didn’t burn it! I only have a tiny dorm griddle and these came out perfectly juicy. My roommate thought I ordered takeout, lmao. 10/10 for broke college students who don’t want to eat ramen every night.
My kids are SO picky, they usually turn their nose up at any homemade burger that isn’t from the fast food place down the street, but they devoured these! Even asked if we could have them again for their birthday cookout next month.
I’ve been grilling burgers for 50+ years and I’ll admit, I thought butter on the bun was a silly fad. Tried this recipe on a whim for my grandkids last weekend and boy, was I wrong. The crunch from the butter-toasted bun is unbeatable. Only note: I cooked mine over charcoal instead of a pan, still turned out perfect.
Total win for weeknight dinners! All the ingredients are super cheap, I already had most of them in my fridge, and it only took 20 minutes like the recipe said. No fancy gadgets needed, which is perfect for my tiny kitchen.
Wait, I grew up in Chicago and I thought I knew what a good butterburger was, but this recipe is next level. I added a little fried onion on top and it tasted just like the ones I’d get after high school football games. So nostalgic!
Tried making these last night and my patties kept falling apart on the griddle? Did I do something wrong? I used 80/20 ground beef like the recipe said.
Made these for my partner who’s from Milwaukee and he said they tasted exactly like home! We don’t have any good Midwestern food spots out here in Seattle so this is going into our regular dinner rotation for sure.
Has anyone tried adding a little garlic butter to the buns instead of regular butter? I’m obsessed with garlic and feel like that would kick this up a notch!
These were SO good, but I found them a little too greasy for my taste? I think I used a little too much butter on the buns, oops. Next time I’ll go lighter on the butter and it’ll be perfect.
Tested these out ahead of our college football tailgate next month and they’re a home run. I made slider-sized versions so they’re easy to grab between plays, and they stayed juicy even when I kept them warm in a crockpot for an hour.
This is the first burger recipe I’ve ever made that didn’t come out dry! The tip about not pressing down on the patties while they cook is a game changer, I used to do that all the time and wonder why all the juice ran out.
As a Wisconsin native living in Texas, I’ve been craving a real butterburger for years. This recipe is spot on! I topped mine with sharp cheddar and raw onion just like my favorite spot back home, and I almost cried when I took the first bite.
Used a gluten free brioche bun for this and it worked perfectly! Just made sure to toast it a little longer with the butter so it got crispy, no soggy bun at all. So happy I can enjoy a butterburger without the gluten bloat!
Made these last night after seeing the recipe pop up on my feed, and my husband already asked if we can add these to our weekly meal rotation! The crispy buttered bun pairs so well with the juicy, salty patty, it’s better than any fast food burger we’ve had in ages.
Made a double batch of these for our office potluck yesterday and there were zero leftovers! People were raving about them all afternoon, even the guy who only brings fast food to work said they were the best burgers he’s ever had. Only complaint is now everyone is signing me up to bring burgers to every work event, oops.
Just moved into my first apartment and this is the first real meal I’ve cooked that didn’t come out of a box! It was so easy to follow, I didn’t mess anything up, and my roommate said it tasted like restaurant food. I feel like a real adult now, lmao.