Cheddar Bagel
intro
Crusty, chewy New York-style cheddar bagels with crispy melted cheese edges, perfect for toasting and slathering with cream cheese for a satisfying savory bite.
Ingredients
Steps
Mix and Knead Dough
In the large stainless steel mixing bowl, combine warm water, granulated sugar, and active dry yeast. Let sit 5 minutes until foamy to confirm yeast is active. Use the box grater to shred all cheddar, setting 80g aside for topping. Add bread flour, fine sea salt, and 120g of shredded cheddar to the yeast mixture. Mix by hand until a shaggy mass forms, then turn out onto the clean maple countertop. Knead for 10 minutes by hand, using the dough scraper to lift sticky bits from the counter, until the dough is smooth, elastic, and springs back when poked lightly with a finger. Form into a tight ball.
Let Dough Rise
Wipe the large mixing bowl lightly with a thin coat of neutral oil, place the kneaded dough ball back inside, and cover the bowl with the clear silicone lid. Let rest in a warm spot on the counter for 1 hour, until the dough doubles in size and leaves an indentation when pressed with a floured finger that does not spring back immediately.
Shape Bagel Rounds
Once risen, turn the dough out onto the lightly floured counter. Use the dough scraper and digital scale to divide the dough evenly into 8 equal pieces (each ~105g). Roll each piece into a tight, smooth ball, then press a floured finger through the center of each ball to create a 5cm wide hole. Stretch the hole gently to form the classic bagel shape, ensuring the dough ring is evenly thick all around. Line the rimmed baking sheet with unbleached parchment paper, then arrange shaped bagels on the sheet, leaving 5cm between each.
Proof Shaped Bagels
Cover the shaped bagels on the baking sheet lightly with a small piece of parchment paper, and let rest for 20 minutes at room temperature. Bagels are ready to boil when they float immediately when dropped into a small bowl of cold water.
Boil Bagels in Water
Fill the medium stainless steel stock pot 2/3 full of water, bring to a rolling boil on the induction cooktop over high heat, then stir in the 1 tbsp baking soda. Working 2-3 bagels at a time (do not crowd the pot), boil bagels for 1 minute per side, flipping gently with the slotted metal spatula. Remove boiled bagels from the water with the slotted spatula, letting excess water drain off, then return them to the parchment-lined baking sheet, hole side up.
Top with Cheddar
Beat the large egg with 1 tsp of water in the small clear glass ramekin to make egg wash. Use the pastry brush to lightly brush the top surface of each boiled bagel with egg wash, then sprinkle the reserved 80g of shredded sharp cheddar evenly over the top of each bagel, pressing lightly so the cheese adheres to the dough.
Bake to Golden Brown
Place the baking sheet with cheddar-topped bagels into a preheated 425°F (220°C) oven. Bake for 20-22 minutes, rotating the sheet halfway through, until bagels are deep golden brown, the cheddar on top is melted with crispy, browned edges, and the internal temperature reaches 190°F (88°C). Remove from the oven and let cool 10 minutes on the sheet before transferring to the serving plate.
Tips
2.Grate cheddar fresh from a block instead of using pre-shredded store-bought cheese: pre-shredded cheese is coated in potato starch and anti-caking agents that prevent smooth, even melting, so freshly grated cheese creates gooey, crispy cheese edges on the baked bagels.
3.Do not skip the baking soda boil: the alkaline boiling water gelatinizes the starch on the bagel surface, creating the shiny, chewy crust that defines bagels, and helps the cheddar topping adhere firmly instead of sliding off during baking.

OMG these came out SO good! I was nervous about the boiling step since I’ve never made homemade bagels before, but that chewy New York texture was spot on. The sharp cheddar got all crispy on top, my husband ate two straight out of the oven before I even could put cream cheese out.
Game changer for weekend meal prep! I made a double batch Sunday, sliced and froze them, and they toast up perfect all week for quick breakfasts before work. Used extra sharp white cheddar instead of yellow and it slapped. Only note: I added a tiny bit of garlic powder to the topping and it was chef’s kiss.
My kids loved it! I was worried the cheddar would be too strong for my picky 7 year old but she begged for a second bagel after school. We topped ours with a little scallion cream cheese and it was the perfect after school snack. Will absolutely be adding these to our weekend rotation.
Wait, I’ve tried so many copycat NY bagel recipes and this is the first one that actually didn’t turn out dense like a hockey puck! Difficulty level felt totally fair for medium – the instructions were super clear, I didn’t get confused at any step. My only tiny mishap was I forgot to add the cheddar to the top before baking so I sprinkled it on the last 5 minutes and it still melted great.
Brought these to our neighborhood block party potluck last weekend and people were asking me for the recipe before I even set the platter down! I did a half batch plain cheddar and half with a little everything bagel seasoning mixed with the cheese on top, and both flavors were gone in 10 minutes. 10/10, would make for every gathering from now on.
Full transparency: I’ve never baked any kind of bread in my life, and I was convinced I’d mess these up. Took me a little longer than the stated prep time because I was fumbling with the dough shaping, but they actually turned out edible? Like, really good edible? My roommate said they taste better than the bagels we get from the corner shop down the street. Wild.
I was skeptical homemade bagels could live up to the ones I grew up eating on Long Island, but holy cow these hit. The cheddar is sharp enough that you actually taste it, not that weird artificial cheese flavor some bagel shops use. Perfect chewy crust, soft inside, exactly what I was craving.
Made these for our weekend camping trip and they held up perfectly! We toasted them over the campfire with a little butter and they were the coziest breakfast after a cold morning hike. Next time I’m adding some crumbled cooked bacon to the dough for a loaded cheddar bacon version.
Tossed a little cayenne pepper in with the cheddar topping for a tiny kick and it was unreal. Not too spicy, just enough depth to cut through the richness of the cheese. If you like a little heat, don’t sleep on that addition. These bagels are the real deal.
Quick question – can I make the dough the night before and let it do the first rise in the fridge? I want to have fresh bagels for my son’s birthday breakfast but I don’t want to wake up at 5am to make the dough from scratch. These look so good I know he’d love them!