creole cream cheese
intro
Tangy, velvety fresh Creole cream cheese is a beloved New Orleans breakfast staple, soft and spoonable, perfect topped with fresh strawberries and cold cream for a nostalgic treat.
Ingredients
Steps
Warm Milk to Temperature
Pour the 1.9L whole milk into the 4-quart stainless steel stock pot. Place over low heat, stirring occasionally with the slotted spoon to prevent scorching on the bottom, until the milk reaches exactly 75°F (24°C) as measured with the digital instant-read thermometer. Do not overheat, as high temperatures will kill the culturing bacteria needed for proper curd formation. Return the pot to its fixed center-left position on the counter after heating.
Stir in Buttermilk Culture
Pour the 240ml full-fat cultured buttermilk into the warmed milk, stirring slowly and thoroughly with the slotted spoon for 30 seconds to fully distribute the live cultures throughout the milk. Do not stir aggressively, as this can disrupt future curd formation. Let the mixture rest for 5 minutes at room temperature.
Mix in Diluted Rennet
Stir 1/4 teaspoon liquid vegetable rennet into 2 tablespoons cool filtered water in the small clear glass ramekin to dilute it. Pour the diluted rennet into the milk mixture, stirring very slowly in up-and-down motions for 15 seconds to evenly distribute the coagulant. Stop stirring as soon as the rennet is fully incorporated to avoid breaking early curds.
Allow Curds to Form
Cover the stock pot with its matching stainless steel lid, and leave it in its fixed center-left position in a draft-free spot away from direct window breeze to rest undisturbed for 12-18 hours at a steady 70-75°F (21-24°C). The curds are fully set when the mixture pulls away from the sides of the pot in a single soft mass, with clear pale yellow whey pooled around the edges, and a texture similar to soft silken tofu.
Cut Curds Into Cubes
Uncover the pot. Use the stainless steel curd knife to cut the set curd mass into 2.5cm (1 inch) even cubes, slicing straight down first in parallel lines across the pot, then turning the pot 90 degrees and slicing again to make a grid. Let the cut curds rest for 10 minutes to allow whey to separate from the curd pieces, which will look like soft pale ivory cubes floating in clear yellow whey.
Drain Whey From Curds
Line the 22cm stainless steel colander with the 3 layers of unbleached cheesecloth, making sure the cloth overhangs the edges by 5cm on all sides. Pull the 3-quart clear glass mixing bowl from under the colander and set the colander inside it to catch draining whey. Gently ladle the cut curds and whey into the cheesecloth-lined colander using the slotted spoon. Let the curds drain at room temperature for 2 hours, until the whey stops dripping and the curds form a thick, soft mass. Do not press the curds, as this will make the cheese too dense; traditional Creole cream cheese has a soft, spreadable, slightly lumpy texture.
Season and Chill Cheese
Gather the edges of the cheesecloth together to lift the drained curd mass, and transfer it to a clean bowl. Sprinkle 1/2 teaspoon fine sea salt over the curds, stirring very gently with the serving spoon to distribute the salt evenly without mashing the curds completely. Transfer the seasoned cheese to the clear glass mason jar, cover with its silver lid, and chill in the refrigerator for at least 4 hours before serving to allow the flavor to mellow.
Plate With Classic Toppings
Scoop a 1/3 cup portion of the chilled Creole cream cheese onto the matte cream ceramic serving plate using the large stainless steel serving spoon. Pour 2 tablespoons of heavy cream from the glass creamer pitcher around the base of the cheese, top with sliced fresh strawberries, and a light sprinkle of raw cane sugar if desired. Serve immediately, chilled.
Tips
2.Never press or squeeze the curds during draining. Unlike firm cheeses such as paneer or cheddar, traditional Creole cream cheese has a soft, spoonable, slightly lumpy texture; pressing curds will squeeze out too much moisture and result in a dry, crumbly final product.
3.Save the drained pale yellow whey from the colander for use in biscuit dough, smoothies, or chicken brines. It is high in protein and lactic acid, adds a subtle tang to baked goods, and eliminates food waste from the cheesemaking process.

OMG, I’ve been looking for a real traditional Creole cream cheese recipe for YEARS! My grandma used to make this when I was a kid growing up outside New Orleans, and every store-bought version I’ve tried tastes like boring regular cream cheese. I was worried the 18 hour timeline would be a pain, but 99% of it is inactive time?? Total game changer. I set the culture before bed, drained it while I made brunch, and chilled it while we ate beignets. Tastes exactly like I remember. 10/10, serving this at our next family crawfish boil!
Tried this for our neighborhood potluck last weekend and it was a huge hit! I was a little intimidated by the medium difficulty rating at first, but the instructions were super clear even for someone who’s never made homemade cheese before. My kids loved it slathered on homemade banana bread, and my husband ate half the batch with fresh strawberries before we even left for the potluck oops. Only note: I let mine drain a little extra long because I prefer a thicker, firmer texture, and it turned out perfect.
Total win for meal prep! I make a batch every Sunday now, and it lasts all week in the fridge. Way less added garbage than the flavored cream cheeses at the grocery store, and I can mix in jams, honey, or even savory herbs depending on what I’m feeling for breakfast. The long inactive time is perfect because I don’t have to stand over the stove babysitting it. 10/10, will be making this on repeat.
Wait, has anyone tried this with raw milk instead of regular pasteurized? I get raw milk from a local farm out here and I’m curious if it’ll change the texture or flavor too much. I messed up a ricotta recipe a few months back using raw milk and don’t want to waste ingredients on this if it’s going to flop.
Made this for my Creole-themed brunch last weekend and everyone was asking for the recipe! I will say, I messed up the first batch because I forgot to check the temperature of my milk before adding the culture (it was way too cold, oops) so it didn’t set right. Second batch was perfect though, so don’t skip that temp check step! SO good topped with praline pecans.
Pretty solid recipe! I was worried the 12 hour culture step would be too much for my busy schedule, but I just popped it in the oven with the light on before I left for work and it was ready to drain when I got home. The chill step is non-negotiable though— I tried a bite right after draining and it was fine, but after 4 hours in the fridge the flavor mellowed out so much and got that perfect tangy Creole taste. Will make again.