Culver's ButterBurger Cheese
intro
An exact copycat of Culver’s iconic ButterBurger Cheese: juicy seared 80/20 beef, melted American cheese, soft butter-toasted bun, and classic simple toppings for that beloved Midwest fast-food flavor at home.
Ingredients
Steps
Form Beef Patties
Divide the 680g 80/20 ground beef into 4 equal 170g (6oz) portions. Gently shape each portion into a loose 10cm (4-inch) wide patty, roughly 1.5cm thick, taking care not to overwork the meat (over-packing leads to tough, dense burgers). Press a small 1cm dimple into the center of each patty with your thumb to prevent bulging during cooking. Season both sides of each patty evenly with 1 tsp flaky sea salt and 1/2 tsp freshly ground black pepper.
Preheat Griddle, Melt Butter
Place the 12-inch carbon steel griddle pan on the stovetop burner set to medium-high heat, and add 1 tsp canola oil, spreading it thinly across the surface with a folded paper towel. Once the griddle is hot (around 200C/400F, confirmed when water droplets dance and evaporate instantly on contact), add the 4 tbsp unsalted butter to the small stainless steel butter pot set on the cooler edge of the griddle to melt fully, about 1 minute.
Toast Buttered Buns
Brush the cut sides of all 4 split hamburger buns with half of the melted butter. Place the buns cut-side down on the hot griddle, toasting for 30-45 seconds until light golden brown with slight crispy edges. Remove the toasted buns from the griddle with tongs and set them on the edge of the cutting board, toasted side up.
Sear Beef Patties
Carefully place the 4 seasoned patties onto the hot griddle, dimple-side up. Cook for 2.5 minutes without moving them, allowing a deep, crispy browned crust to form on the bottom. Do not press down on the patties while cooking, as this squeezes out flavorful fat and juice leading to dry burgers.
Flip Patties, Add Cheese
Use the thin flexible spatula to slide fully under each patty, getting completely under the browned crust to avoid breaking it, and flip each patty in one smooth motion. Immediately place one slice of American cheese on top of each flipped patty. Cook for an additional 2 minutes for medium doneness (internal temperature 71C/160F, consistent with Culver’s fully cooked style), allowing the cheese to fully melt and drape slightly over the patty edges.
Assemble Burger Layers
Brush the toasted cut side of each bottom bun with a thin layer of remaining melted butter. Portion diced onion, pickle slices, ketchup, and mustard into the 4 small glass ramekins. Spread 1.5 tsp yellow mustard and 1.5 tsp ketchup evenly across each buttered bottom bun. Top each bottom bun with 3 thin dill pickle slices and 1 tbsp finely diced white onion.
Add Patty, Top Bun
Use the spatula to lift each cheese-topped patty from the griddle, letting excess rendered fat drip off for 2 seconds, then place it directly on top of the topped bottom bun. Brush the toasted cut side of each top bun with the last of the melted butter, then place the top bun buttered-side down on top of the patty, pressing down gently to set the layers.
Tips
2.Butter both cut sides of the toasted buns: Most copycat recipes only butter the outside of the bun, but Culver’s brushes melted butter on every toasted inner surface to create that iconic soft, rich, buttery bite in every mouthful.
3.Never press down on patties while they cook: Pressing squeezes all the rendered beef fat and flavorful juices out onto the griddle, leading to dry, bland burgers. Use the thin spatula only for one clean flip to preserve the crispy, caramelized seared crust.

OMG this tastes EXACTLY like the Culver's ButterBurger I get on my road trips home to Wisconsin! I was so skeptical a copycat could nail that buttery, toasted bun and perfectly melty cheese, but 10 minutes of cook time? Total game changer for busy weeknights. My kids devoured two each and asked when we’re making them again.
Made these for my Sunday football watch party and the whole crew was raving. Nobody believed it was a copycat recipe, a couple guys said it was better than the actual fast food version. Pro tip: don’t skip buttering the buns, that’s what makes it taste exactly like Culver’s, y’all.
I don’t live near a Culver’s so I’ve been craving a ButterBurger for literal years. This was so easy to throw together after work, I even added a little pickles and grilled onion like I get when I visit my sister in the midwest. SO good, I’m adding this to my regular meal prep rotation.
This was really tasty! My only note is that I think I over-buttered my buns the first time and they got a little too greasy, so next time I’ll go lighter on the butter spread. The patties themselves were perfectly seasoned though, my husband asked me to make these for our next neighborhood potluck.
Cooked these on our camp griddle while we were boondocking last weekend and they came out perfect even on portable gear! 10 minute cook time is so ideal for quick camp meals where you don’t want to spend an hour prepping. Even our golden retriever was begging for a bite (no, he didn’t get any).
I added a dash of cayenne to the patty seasoning and a slice of pepper jack for a little kick and it was chef’s kiss. The base recipe is so solid it’s easy to tweak without messing up that classic ButterBurger vibe. 10/10, will be making these at least once a week from now on.
As a college kid with basically zero cooking skills, I was shocked how easy this was! I don’t have a fancy grill, just a beat-up cheap nonstick skillet in my dorm, and these turned out way better than the sad cafeteria burgers. Saved so much money instead of driving 20 minutes to the nearest Culver’s for a fix.
Made these for our weekly family Sunday dinner and everyone went back for seconds. My 82 year old dad said they tasted just like the burger joints he went to as a kid, which is the highest compliment I could ever get. Thank you for such a simple, delicious recipe!
Really solid recipe! I pre-formed a bunch of patties and froze them for quick weeknight meals, and they hold up really well in the freezer if you separate them with parchment paper. Only tiny thing is I wish the seasoning amounts were listed by weight for even more consistency, but the volume measurements worked great for my first batch.
I’ve tried at least four different copycat ButterBurger recipes online and this is the only one that actually nails that signature buttery toasted bun flavor. No weird extra ingredients, no overcomplicated steps, just a really solid, simple cheeseburger that tastes exactly like what you get at the Culver’s drive-thru. Absolute keeper recipe, no notes.