custard toast air fryer
intro
Silky vanilla custard baked on thick crusty sourdough in the air fryer, topped with fresh spring berries. A 13-minute, minimal-cleanup breakfast with crisp edges and luxuriously smooth filling.
Ingredients
Steps
Press bread centers
Place the two thick sourdough slices on the center maple cutting board. Use the back of the 1 tbsp stainless steel measuring spoon to firmly press the center of each bread slice down, creating a 1cm deep well that leaves a 1cm raised crust border around the edge. Be careful not to press all the way through the bread; the intact well will hold the custard without leaking during cooking.
Whisk custard base
Crack the whole egg into the matte light grey silicone mixing bowl. Add the 1/4 cup whole-milk Greek yogurt, 1 tbsp maple syrup, 1/2 tsp vanilla extract, 1/4 tsp ground cinnamon, and pinch of flaky sea salt. Use the mini stainless steel whisk to stir the mixture for 45-60 seconds until completely smooth, with no lumps of yogurt or streaks of egg remaining. The finished custard will be pale golden, with the thin, pourable consistency of heavy cream.
Fill bread with custard
Pull the non-stick basket out of the matte black air fryer, and place the pressed sourdough slices flat in the basket, leaving 2cm of space between them to allow air circulation. Carefully pour half of the smooth custard mixture into the well of each bread slice, stopping just 2mm below the top of the raised crust edge to avoid overflow as the custard puffs during cooking. Do not overfill, as excess custard will drip onto the air fryer heating element and burn.
Air fry until set
Slide the air fryer basket fully closed. Set the air fryer to 175C (350F) and cook for 7-8 minutes; no preheating is required. The custard will puff slightly as it cooks, and is ready when the center is fully set with no liquid sloshing when the basket is nudged, and the bread crust is deep golden brown and crisp. Avoid cooking beyond 9 minutes, as high heat will cause the egg custard to curdle and develop a rubbery texture.
Check custard doneness
When the timer finishes, pull the air fryer basket out carefully (the basket and edges will be very hot). Gently jiggle the basket to test doneness: the center of the custard should have a firm, slight wobble, with no loose liquid sliding across the surface. If runny liquid is visible, cook for 1 additional minute. Use the offset stainless steel spatula to carefully lift the toasts out of the basket, transferring them to the top matte cream stoneware plate from the right-side stack.
Garnish and serve
Arrange the fresh sliced strawberries and whole blueberries evenly across the top of the warm custard. Add a light, even dusting of powdered sugar from the stainless steel shaker, and a tiny extra pinch of flaky sea salt to balance the sweet, creamy flavor. Serve immediately while warm, as the custard will deflate slightly and the crust will lose crispness as it cools.
Tips
2.Skip preheating the air fryer for this recipe: a preheated cavity will toast the bottom of the bread too quickly before the custard has time to set, resulting in burnt crust edges and a runny, undercooked center.
3.Let the toasts rest for 1 full minute after removing them from the air fryer before adding berries: this short rest lets the custard firm up slightly so it does not squish out when bitten into, and prevents delicate fresh berries from warming and turning mushy.

OMG this is such a game changer for busy school mornings! I threw this together in 2 minutes, air fried for 8 exactly like the recipe said, and my two picky eaters devoured it before I even finished making my coffee. SO good, I already added this to our weekly breakfast rotation. Tasted like fancy French toast without all the messy pan cleanup!
Made this for a quick post-gym snack this morning and was shocked how good it was. Used sourdough because that’s all I had, added a dash of nutmeg, and it hit. 8 minutes was perfect, no sogginess at all. Will definitely make again.
I brought these to my friend’s potluck brunch last weekend and everyone was asking for the recipe! I topped mine with fresh berries and a drizzle of maple syrup, they looked so fancy no one believed they took 10 minutes total to make. 10/10
Super easy, cheap to make, and tastes way more indulgent than it is. I used regular sandwich bread because I didn’t have anything fancy, and it still turned out great. Perfect for meal prep too — I made a batch on Sunday and grabbed one each morning on my way to work.
Tried this after seeing my granddaughter make it on TikTok. Didn’t think toast could be this creamy! I added a little extra cinnamon because I love it, cooked it 7 minutes instead of 8 so it was a little softer, just how I like it. Great recipe.
Used gluten free brioche for this and it worked perfectly! I was worried the custard would make the GF bread soggy, but the air fryer crisped the edges just right. My husband who doesn’t even eat GF said he loved it. Win!
Wait, do I need to spray the air fryer basket first? I’m scared the toast will stick and I’ll ruin it! This looks so good I don’t want to mess it up on my first try.
Just made this and added a scoop of vanilla protein powder to the custard mix, absolute chef’s kiss. Tastes like a treat but has extra protein to keep me full through my morning meetings.
I tried this last night and the edges got super charred after 8 minutes! Did I do something wrong? My air fryer runs a little hot I think, but I followed the temp exactly.
Y’all, I topped mine with a little peach compote and a dollop of whipped cream after it cooked and it tasted like dessert for breakfast! My whole family thought I spent forever making it, nope, 8 minutes in the air fryer. So easy.
Can I make this with plant based milk and egg substitute? I’m in a dorm and don’t keep regular dairy or eggs on hand, but this looks too good to pass up.
These reheat so well! I stored the leftovers in an airtight container in the fridge for 3 days, popped them back in the air fryer for 1 minute to crisp up, and they tasted just as good as fresh. Total meal prep win.
I sprinkled a few mini chocolate chips on top of the custard before air frying and oh my gosh, it was like having a chocolate cream pie on toast. My kids begged for seconds immediately.
Wait, is this better with brioche or regular white bread? I have both in my pantry right now and can’t decide which to use for my first batch!
Made these for my family brunch today and they were a total hit! I set up a little topping bar with berries, powdered sugar, Nutella, and maple syrup so everyone could customize their own. So fun.
This might be a silly question, but what temperature do I set my air fryer to? The recipe says 8 minutes cook time but I totally missed the temp note, oops! Don’t want to undercook the custard.
I added a swirl of cream cheese frosting on top after cooking and it tasted exactly like a cinnamon roll but way less work. I’m never making regular toast again, tbh.
Wait, has anyone made this for a quick dinner? I know it’s a breakfast thing but I’m so tired after work and have all the ingredients, it feels like it would work for a quick sweet dinner too.
I don’t have an air fryer yet (I know, I’m late to the party!) — would this work in a regular toaster oven if I adjust the cook time? This looks too good to wait until I buy one.