Door County Fish Boil
intro
A beloved communal Wisconsin tradition of briny boiled whitefish, potatoes, and onions, finished with a dramatic boil-over to cut rich fish oils.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep outdoor boil station
Set a 19L (5 gallon) heavy-gauge stockpot on a sturdy outdoor propane burner or open fire grate, positioned at least 3 meters (10 feet) from flammable structures or materials. Fill the pot with 12L (3 gallons) of cold tap water, add 120g kosher salt, 1 tbsp whole black peppercorns, and 3 bay leaves, then cover and bring to a rolling boil over high heat (12-15 minutes).
Boil the red potatoes
Once the water reaches a hard, churning rolling boil, remove the pot lid and carefully add the whole scrubbed unpeeled red potatoes. Maintain a steady medium-high rolling boil (do not turn down heat enough to stop bubbling) and cook uncovered for exactly 12 minutes, until potatoes yield slightly when pierced with a paring knife but do not split open.
Add onion quarters
After the potatoes have cooked for 12 minutes, gently lower the peeled, quartered yellow onions (kept intact at the root end to prevent pieces from separating and dissolving) into the boiling pot. Maintain the medium-high rolling boil, and cook uncovered for an additional 8 minutes, until onion edges turn soft and translucent.
Cook the whitefish
Once the onions have cooked for 8 minutes, carefully lower the 900g of skin-on whitefish steaks into the pot, preferably in a stainless steel wire mesh boil basket for easy removal. Return the water to a steady medium-high rolling boil, and cook the fish uncovered for exactly 10 minutes; done fish will flake easily when prodded with a fork and float near the water surface.
Do signature boil-over
After the fish has cooked for 10 minutes, turn the burner to its highest heat setting (for traditional open-fire setups, add 1 tbsp of kerosene directly to the fire below the pot, never into the water, with extreme caution) to trigger a vigorous, foamy boil-over that lasts 30-45 seconds. This step spills strong, fishy surface oils over the pot edge for a milder, cleaner flavor. Turn off the heat immediately once the boil-over subsides.
Drain and serve hot
Lift the wire boil basket (or use a large slotted spoon to remove ingredients in batches) from the pot, and let all excess briny water drain for 60 seconds. Arrange the fish, potatoes, and onions on a large serving platter, drizzle evenly with 120ml melted unsalted butter, and serve immediately with lemon wedges on the side.
Tips
2.If using the traditional kerosene method for the boil-over, never pour kerosene directly into the water or onto the food, keep a Class B fire extinguisher within arm’s reach, and stand well back to avoid burns from splashing boiling water.
3.Skip add-ins like shrimp, corn on the cob, or smoked sausage common to Low Country boils—authentic Door County fish boils only feature the simple trio of whitefish, potatoes, and onions, served with butter and lemon.

Made this for our neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were lined up for seconds! I was a little nervous about the boil timing since I’ve never done a fish boil outside of a restaurant, but the 45 minute cook time was totally accurate. SO good, even the folks who say they don’t like white fish were raving.
Pretty solid recipe! Grew up going to fish boils every summer with my grandparents, and this is 90% there. I will say I always add a little extra salt to the boil water and throw in a handful of baby pearl onions that the recipe didn’t mention, but that’s just my family’s tweak.
Just finished making this for my teen son and his friends after their football practice, and the whole pot was gone in 10 minutes. Zero leftovers, which is always the highest compliment in my house. Medium difficulty is spot on, not too fussy even when you’re cooking for a crew.
Flavor was great, but I messed up the potato timing! Mine came out a little underdone when I added the fish, so we had to fish them out (pun intended) and boil them a little longer. Will definitely give it another go though, the taste was worth the extra hassle.
Tweaked this to make it over our campfire propane burner on our last trip to the mountains and it was *chef’s kiss*. Felt like we had a little slice of Lake Michigan up at 8,000 feet! We paired it with coleslaw and crusty rye bread just like they do up in Door County.
I’ve been dying to try a Door County fish boil ever since I saw a travel doc about it, and this recipe did NOT disappoint. OMG, I used fresh cod from my local fish monger and it was so flaky and flavorful, not fishy at all. My roommate who hates seafood even tried a bite and said it was delicious!
This was such a fun, nostalgic meal to make for my parents’ anniversary. My dad visited Door County on his honeymoon with my mom back in the 80s and he said the taste was exactly how he remembered. Only reason it’s not 5 stars is I wish there was a note about what sides pair best, I guessed coleslaw and it worked but would’ve loved the official rec.
Great recipe! I was worried this wouldn’t hold up for meal prep since fish can get soggy, but I stored the boiled potatoes, onions, and fish separate from the broth and it reheated beautifully for lunches all week. Will absolutely add this to my weekly rotation.
We do a weekly fish fry every Friday during Lent, and this was such a fun change of pace from our usual battered cod. The whole family got such a kick out of the boil process, it felt like a little event instead of just a regular weeknight meal. My kids loved helping dump the ingredients into the pot!
So happy this recipe is naturally gluten free! I have celiac and so many classic fish recipes are battered or have hidden gluten, but this was totally safe for me to eat and packed so much flavor. I brought it to my book club potluck and everyone was asking for the recipe.
First time ever making any kind of boil, and it turned out way better than I expected! Medium difficulty was fair—there are a few steps to keep track of, but the instructions were clear enough that even a total newbie like me didn’t mess it up too bad. My only oops was forgetting to buy lemons for serving, oops.
We stopped in Door County on our cross country RV trip last summer and went to a famous fish boil place, and I swore I’d never be able to make it at home. This recipe proved me wrong! Made it in our RV kitchen with minimal equipment and it tasted exactly like the restaurant version. Total game changer for our camp meal rotation! Mind blown.
Really solid base recipe! I added a couple tablespoons of old bay and a pinch of cayenne to the boil water to give it a little extra kick, since my household likes things spicy. Turned out amazing, will absolutely make again.
Made this for my grandkids when they came to visit last weekend, and they went crazy for it! I was worried the kids would turn their noses up at boiled fish, but they loved dipping it in melted butter just like I taught them. Even the pickiest eater asked for thirds.
Made this for my partner for our at home date night after we had to cancel our trip to Door County this year, and it was so romantic! We set the table with checkered tablecloths, poured some cold beer, and it felt like we were right there at a lakeside boil. 10/10, will make again for special occasions.
This is such an affordable meal to make for a crowd! I fed 6 people for under $25 total by getting frozen cod, cheap bagged potatoes, and sweet onions from the grocery store clearance rack. Tasted like a million bucks, no one would’ve guessed how budget friendly it was.
Tasted great, but I used salmon instead of cod because that’s what I had on hand, and it was a little too rich for the boil. Next time I’ll stick to the recommended white fish like the recipe says, lesson learned!
Made this for our tailgate before the Buckeyes game last weekend and it was the most popular item on the food table. People kept coming over to ask what I was making because the smell was drifting through the whole parking lot. So easy to make on a portable burner, 10/10 for tailgates.
I’ve had fish boils in Door County three separate times, and this recipe is hands down the most accurate home cook version I’ve ever tried. The ratio of salt in the boil is perfect, the cook time for the fish is exactly right so it doesn’t get mushy. Total home run.
Leftovers were amazing! I chopped up the leftover fish and potatoes, fried them up in a little butter with some eggs for breakfast the next day, and it was better than the original boil. Who knew leftover fish boil would make such a good breakfast hash?