first watch french toast
intro
Fluffy, custardy thick-cut French toast, the beloved First Watch classic, dusted with cinnamon, topped with fresh berries and warm maple syrup for a cozy, nostalgic weekend treat.
Ingredients
Steps
Whisk Custard Mixture
Crack 4 large eggs into the 9-inch clear glass pie dish set on the light maple cutting board. Add 1 cup half-and-half, 2 tbsp granulated sugar, 1 tsp pure vanilla extract, 1 tsp ground cinnamon, and 1/4 tsp kosher salt. Use the stainless steel wire whisk to beat the mixture for 45-60 seconds until completely smooth, with no streaks of egg white remaining and a pale golden hue. Avoid over-whisking to prevent excess surface bubbles that can create uneven browning.
Preheat Cooking Skillet
Place the 12-inch matte charcoal grey non-stick skillet on the stovetop (set into the right counter section) over medium-low heat (325°F / 160°C). Preheat for 3 full minutes, testing readiness by flicking a drop of cold water onto the surface: the water should dance across the pan and evaporate in 3-4 seconds. Do not use higher heat, as this will burn the toast exterior before the interior custard sets.
Soak Bread Slices
Working one slice at a time, submerge a 1.5-inch thick brioche slice in the custard. Let soak 20 seconds per side, so custard penetrates 1/4 inch into the crumb without making the bread soggy enough to fall apart. Lift each slice with a fork, letting excess custard drip back into the pie dish for 2 seconds before transferring to the skillet. Never soak slices longer than 30 seconds per side, as this results in a mushy, undercooked center.
Cook First Toast Side
Add 1 tbsp unsalted butter to the preheated skillet, swirling to coat the pan evenly once melted. Place 2 custard-soaked brioche slices in the pan, leaving 1 inch of space between them so they do not steam each other. Cook 3 to 3.5 minutes on the first side, until the surface is deep golden brown with slightly crisp, caramelized edges, and no wet custard seeps out when the edge is nudged. Turn heat down slightly if bread browns in under 3 minutes to avoid burning.
Flip and Cook Through
Use the stainless steel slotted turner to carefully flip each French toast slice. Cook the second side for 2.5 to 3 minutes, until matching golden brown, and the center of the slice springs back immediately when pressed gently with the turner, indicating the custard is fully set. Transfer cooked slices to a clean plate tented loosely with aluminum foil to keep warm while cooking remaining batches, adding 1 tbsp fresh butter to the skillet between each batch to prevent sticking.
Plate and Dust Garnish
Arrange 2 cooked French toast slices per serving on the 27cm matte cream ceramic dinner plate, stacked at a slight angle to showcase crisp edges. Mix 1 tbsp extra granulated sugar with 1/4 tsp ground cinnamon in the small cream ceramic ramekin. Hold the 8cm fine-mesh stainless steel sieve 6 inches above the toast, and tap gently to dust a light, even coating of cinnamon sugar across the top of the stack. Top with a 1 tsp pat of cold unsalted butter in the center of the top slice.
Top with Fruit and Syrup
Arrange 1/4 cup sliced strawberries and 2 tbsp fresh blueberries alongside the toast stack on the plate. Warm 1/2 cup pure maple syrup for 30 seconds in the microwave until fluid, then drizzle 2 tbsp over the top of the toast, allowing a small amount to pool at the base of the plate. Serve immediately while the toast is hot, with extra warm syrup on the side.
Tips
2.Maintain consistent medium-low heat while cooking: high heat will burn the sugar and butter on the bread surface before the egg custard in the center sets, leading to charred edges and raw, runny insides. Low, slow cooking ensures even browning and fully set custard.
3.Don’t skip the small amount of salt in the custard: the pinch of kosher salt cuts through the richness of eggs and half-and-half, amplifies vanilla and cinnamon notes, and balances the sweetness of maple syrup and fresh fruit toppings.

OMG I have been chasing that First Watch French toast high for YEARS since my local location closed down during the pandemic. This recipe is dead on! The thick-cut brioche I used soaked up just the right amount of custard without getting soggy, and that tiny hint of orange zest? *Chef’s kiss* My kids begged for seconds before they even finished their first pieces. Total game changer for lazy weekend brunch!
This was SO good! My only note is that I cooked mine a little too long on the first batch because I thought the thick bread would need more time — ended up with slightly crispy edges that were still tasty, but the second batch I cooked at medium-low per the instructions and it was perfect. Brought a platter of these to my neighborhood potluck last Sunday and they were gone in 10 minutes flat.
Easy enough to make even for a guy who burns toast 50% of the time. 20 minute cook time is no joke, I had the whole thing on the table before my coffee finished brewing. Topped with maple syrup and a little powdered sugar, tasted exactly like what I order when I hit First Watch after my early morning workouts. Will be adding this to the regular weekend rotation.
Wait a second — I used Texas toast instead of brioche because that’s all I had in the fridge for meal prep this week, and it still slapped? I was worried the bread would be too thin, but I dipped each slice for a full 45 seconds instead of the quick dip the recipe calls for and it came out so thick and custardy. Saved me $15 on brunch takeout this weekend, no cap.
Made this for my mom’s birthday breakfast this morning and she kept saying it was better than the actual First Watch we went to for Mother’s Day last year! I added a little extra vanilla extract because I love that flavor, and served it with fresh strawberries and candied pecans on top. 10/10, will be making for every family breakfast from now on.
Solid recipe, super easy to follow. I will say I wish there was a little more spice in the custard base for my taste, so I added a pinch of nutmeg and a dash of allspice on my second go-round and that was perfect for me. Great base recipe to tweak to your own preferences, no weird hard to find ingredients which is a huge win.
Taste was great! But I think I messed up the custard to bread ratio? My slices came out a little soggier than I remember First Watch’s being, even after cooking them the full time per the recipe. Did anyone else have this issue? I used sourdough instead of brioche, maybe that was the problem?
Just pulled this off the griddle and wow, I’m impressed. The thickness is exactly what I’ve been craving — none of that thin, floppy French toast that gets drowned in syrup. I topped mine with a little salted butter and warm maple syrup, and it tastes just like the order I get every time I visit my sister in Florida and we hit First Watch. No notes, 10/10.
Made this with my 3rd grade cooking club after school today! The recipe was so simple that the kids could help measure and dip the bread (with supervision near the griddle, of course) and every single kid asked for seconds. Even the kids who say they ‘hate sweet breakfast’ cleaned their plates. This is going to be a go-to for class events from now on!
Has anyone tried making a big batch of these and freezing them for quick weekday breakfasts? I meal prep most of my breakfasts for the week and I’m wondering if these hold up in the toaster straight from the freezer like store-bought frozen French toast does. The flavor was chef’s kiss when I made them fresh this weekend, just curious about make-ahead potential!
Made these for the guys before our early tee time last Saturday and they were raving about them the whole round. Way better than the sad donuts we usually grab on the way to the course. I added a little maple syrup right into the custard instead of just pouring it on top, and it gave the whole thing that perfect sweet, warm flavor all the way through. Will be our new pre-golf breakfast staple.
I used to work at First Watch back in college and helped make the French toast custard every single morning. I cannot believe how spot on this recipe is — you even nailed the little bit of vanilla and cinnamon ratio that we used! I haven’t had it since I quit working there 6 years ago and this took me right back. Amazing job.