Five Guys Little Cheeseburger
intro
A spot-on copycat of the iconic Five Guys Little Cheeseburger: juicy thin seared beef patty, melted American cheese, soft toasted sesame bun, and crisp fresh toppings, identical to the fast-casual favorite.
Ingredients
Steps
Portion beef balls
Remove the chilled 80/20 ground beef from the medium clear glass mixing bowl, and divide into two equal 113g (4oz) portions, handling the meat as gently as possible to avoid overworking it (overworked beef produces tough, dense patties). Lightly roll each portion into a loose, round ball—do not squeeze or compact the meat tightly, as loose packing creates tender, juicy patties with crispy edges. Set the beef balls on the maple cutting board to rest for 5 minutes at room temperature. Do not season the beef at this stage, as early salting draws out moisture and prevents crust formation.
Preheat flat griddle
Place the 12-inch cast iron flat griddle in the dead center of the counter, and heat it over medium-high heat until it reaches 400°F (200°C). Test the heat by sprinkling a single drop of water: it should dance across the surface and evaporate completely in 1-2 seconds when the griddle is at proper temperature. Add 1 teaspoon of canola oil to the griddle, and use the folded edge of the cream linen towel to spread the oil into a thin, even layer across the cooking surface, wiping away any excess pooled oil.
Sear and smash patties
Carefully place one beef ball on the left side of the hot griddle, and the second on the right side, leaving 5cm of space between them. Immediately sprinkle the top of each beef ball with half the mixed kosher salt and black pepper from the seasoning shaker. Place a small 10cm square of parchment paper over each beef ball to prevent sticking, then use the flat stiff metal spatula to press straight down firmly on each ball, smashing it into a thin, even patty approximately 12cm (5 inches) wide and 0.5cm (1/4 inch) thick. Remove the parchment paper, and let the patties cook undisturbed for 2 minutes, until the edges are deep golden brown and crispy, and tiny beads of red beef juice bubble up through the uncooked top surface of the patty.
Flip patties, add cheese
Use the stiff metal spatula to carefully scrape under each patty (making sure to lift all the crispy browned maillard crust bits from the griddle surface) and flip it in one smooth, quick motion. Immediately place one slice of yellow American cheese directly on top of each flipped patty, centering it so the edges will melt slightly over the patty sides as it cooks. Let the patties cook for an additional 1 minute 30 seconds, until fully cooked through (internal temperature 160°F / 71°C, no pink remaining, matching Five Guys’ standard well-done preparation). The cheese will be fully melted and slightly translucent, oozing gently over the patty edges when done.
Toast sesame buns
While the patties finish cooking with the cheese, use the stainless steel tongs to place the split sesame seed buns cut-side down on the empty front edge of the griddle. Toast for 30-45 seconds, until the cut surface is light golden brown and slightly crispy, with faint dark marks from the griddle surface. Do not burn the buns—they should remain soft and pillowy on the outer surface, with only a light crunch on the toasted inner cut side.
Layer classic toppings
Use the tongs to lift the toasted bottom buns from the griddle, and place each on a matte white ceramic dinner plate. Layer classic Five Guys toppings on each bottom bun in the traditional order to prevent sogginess: first a thin bed of shredded iceberg lettuce, then two crisp dill pickle slices, one thin slice of beefsteak tomato, and a light sprinkle of diced white onion. The lettuce creates a moisture barrier between the soft bun and hot patty, keeping the bun from getting soggy.
Assemble and serve
Use the metal spatula to lift each cheese-topped patty from the griddle, holding it above the griddle for 2 seconds to let excess rendered grease drip off, then place the patty directly on top of the layered toppings on each bottom bun. Add any additional desired custom toppings (mayo, ketchup, mustard, grilled mushrooms, jalapeños, or grilled onions, per Five Guys’ free topping policy), then place the toasted top bun on the patty. Press down very gently on the top bun to slightly compress the burger, so it holds together when picked up to eat.
Tips
2.Smash the patties immediately after placing them on the hot griddle: waiting even 30 seconds to smash will let the surface set, making it impossible to get the thin, lacy, crispy crust that defines the Five Guys patty texture.
3.Skip mixing seasonings into the ground beef: Five Guys seasons only the outer surface of the patty right before smashing, which lets the pure beef flavor come through and allows the maillard reaction to form a perfect crispy crust without drawing out excess moisture.

OMG this is SO good! I’ve been craving Five Guys all week but didn’t want to drop $15 on a burger combo, so I tried this last night for family dinner. The cook time was literally 8 minutes like it said, super easy even for someone who burns toast half the time. My kids devoured theirs and asked for seconds! Total game changer for busy weeknight meals.
Perfect easy recipe for my dorm! I don’t have a fancy grill, just a cast iron skillet on my hot plate, and these turned out exactly like Five Guys. Way cheaper than ordering delivery every time I’m craving a cheeseburger. Already made this twice this week for me and my roommate.
Tried this for my weekly meal prep yesterday! I made 4 of these little cheeseburgers, wrapped them up, and they reheated so well for lunch today. I was worried the bun would get soggy but I toasted them first like the recipe said and they held up great. Will be adding this to my regular rotation!
I made these last night and they were so close to Five Guys! Quick question though — the recipe calls for American cheese which is what I used, but I only have sharp cheddar at home right now for when I make these for my boyfriend’s birthday cookout this weekend. Will cheddar work okay, or should I run to the store for American?
Took this recipe to our neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were begging me for the recipe! Everyone thought I picked up a whole tray of Five Guys burgers, I had to tell them it was a copycat I made at home. The only tweak I did was add some grilled onions on top, just like I order mine in store. 10/10, will make again.
I’m super picky about my Five Guys burgers, and this copycat is spot on. I was worried the seasoning would be off, but the ratio of salt and pepper on the crispy thin patty, the soft toasted bun, even the way the cheese melts all over the edges — exactly how they make the Little Cheeseburger in store. Cook time was quick too, perfect for when I don’t want to wait in the 20 minute drive-thru line.