1.Can I use a different type of whiskey if I don’t have blended Scotch or bourbon on hand?
▾
Absolutely! Rye whiskey works beautifully for a spicier, bolder kick, while Irish whiskey makes a smoother, milder toddy. Skip heavily peated scotches for this recipe, though—their bold smoky flavor can overpower the delicate balance of honey, bright lemon, and warm clove that makes a classic hot toddy so comforting.
2.Is there a vegan substitute for raw honey in this recipe?
▾
Definitely. Swap raw honey for an equal amount of pure maple syrup, which has a rich, warm sweetness that pairs perfectly with whiskey and spices. Opt for light, Grade A golden maple syrup instead of dark, robust varieties, so its deep woody notes don’t overpower the bright fresh lemon and aromatic whole clove in the drink.
3.How hot should the water be so I don’t ruin the whiskey’s flavor?
▾
Aim for filtered water heated to 160–170°F, just below a rolling boil. Water that’s fully boiling (212°F) will evaporate too much of the whiskey’s nuanced flavor and can make the raw honey taste oddly flat. I heat mine on the stovetop or use a temperature-controlled kettle for the most consistent, perfectly balanced result.
4.Can I use ground cloves instead of whole cloves for this recipe?
▾
I strongly recommend whole cloves for this recipe—ground clove will leave a grainy, muddy texture at the bottom of your mug and can easily make the drink taste overly bitter if you add even a pinch too much. If that’s all you have, use just 1/8 of a teaspoon per serving, and stir really well to fully incorporate it before sipping.
5.Can I make a non-alcoholic version of this hot toddy for kids or sober guests?
▾
Of course! Skip the whiskey entirely, and swap in 1.5 ounces of steeped chamomile or rooibos tea per serving to add warm, earthy depth. Keep all the other ingredients the same—warm filtered water, raw honey, fresh lemon, and a couple whole cloves—for a cozy, soothing drink perfect for cold days or sore throats.
6.Why does the recipe specify fresh lemon instead of bottled lemon juice?
▾
Bottled lemon juice has a flat, sharp, almost metallic taste from processing and preservatives that throws off the toddy’s carefully balanced flavor. Fresh lemon has bright, zesty, aromatic notes that cut through rich whiskey and sweet honey, and a quick squeeze from a quarter-lemon per serving takes barely any extra prep effort.
7.How much whiskey should I add per serving for the best flavor balance?
▾
Stick to 1.5 ounces (one standard shot) of blended Scotch or bourbon per 8-ounce mug for the most approachable, well-balanced toddy. If you prefer a stronger drink, you can bump it up to 2 ounces, but any more than that will overpower the honey, lemon, and clove, and make the drink taste harsh instead of smooth and soothing.
8.Can I add extra spices like cinnamon or nutmeg to customize my hot toddy?
▾
Absolutely! A 1-inch cinnamon stick steeped right in the mug is my go-to extra addition, and a light grating of fresh nutmeg on top adds a lovely warm aroma. Just stick to whole spices for steeping to avoid the grainy texture ground spices leave, and don’t add so many that they cover up the core honey-lemon-whiskey flavor.
9.Will drinking a hot toddy actually help soothe cold or sore throat symptoms?
▾
It can definitely bring temporary, cozy relief! The warm liquid soothes scratchy throat tissue, the raw honey coats irritation, and the fresh lemon adds a bright hit of vitamin C. Just note that alcohol can be dehydrating, so stick to one toddy if you’re under the weather, and pair it with extra plain water to stay hydrated.
10.How do I keep my hot toddy warm long enough to sip it slowly?
▾
Preheat your mug before you build the drink! Just pour boiling water into the mug, let it sit for 30 seconds, then dump it out before adding your whiskey, honey, lemon, cloves, and hot filtered water. This simple step keeps your toddy at the perfect sipping temperature for 15–20 minutes, instead of turning lukewarm after just a few sips.
11.Do I need to strain the whole cloves out of my toddy before drinking?
▾
You don’t have to, but I recommend fishing them out after 3–4 minutes of steeping, or pouring the toddy through a small fine-mesh strainer if you prefer. Whole cloves get intensely bitter if they steep too long in hot liquid, and biting into a whole clove mid-sip is a sharp, unpleasant surprise that ruins the cozy vibe.
12.Can I make a big batch of hot toddies for a holiday party instead of single servings?
▾
Definitely! Multiply the recipe to serve your group, and keep the batch warm in a slow cooker set to the lowest heat setting. Hold off on adding the whiskey until 10 minutes before guests arrive, so the low heat doesn’t cook off all the alcohol, and set out extra lemon wedges and whole cloves so guests can tweak their drinks to taste.
OMG this hot toddy was an absolute game changer when I came down with that nasty cold last week! I swapped the regular honey for wildflower honey from my local farmers market and it hit SO good. My husband even asked for a second mug after his long shift at the fire station. 10/10 will be making this all winter long!
Super easy recipe, threw this together in literally 8 minutes last night when we had friends over for our holiday potluck pre-game. I used a bourbon instead of rye whiskey and it was perfectly smooth. Only note is I wish I’d made a bigger batch!
Made this for our family movie night last weekend when it was 12 degrees outside! Even my teen who swears they hate all warm drinks asked for a refill. I added a tiny cinnamon stick to each mug and it made the whole house smell amazing.
Okay I was skeptical because I’ve had really bad hot toddies at bars before, but this recipe is foolproof! Perfect balance of sweet, tart, and warm whiskey heat. It didn’t cure my cold but it definitely made my sore throat and stuffy nose way more bearable for a couple hours.
Made this for my book club meetup last night and everyone was begging for the recipe! I garnished each glass with a lemon wheel and a whole clove and it felt so fancy, even though it took zero effort. Will be adding this to my regular rotation for sure.
Packed the ingredients for this in our camp thermos last weekend when we were hiking in the Rockies, mixed it up with hot water from our camp stove at the summit. Absolute peak (pun intended) warm up after 4 hours of hiking in 20 degree wind. So glad this recipe is so simple to make even off grid.
Wait hear me out, I know it’s 75 degrees here in Arizona in December but I still make this every single night after work. There’s something so comforting about a warm whiskey drink even when it’s not freezing out, y’all. I skip the extra cloves because I’m not a huge spiced fan and it’s still perfect.
Got home at 2am after a terrible late shift at the hospital, threw this together in 10 minutes and it literally melted all my stress away. I added a dash of nutmeg on top because I had some in my pantry and it was chef’s kiss. Easy, fast, exactly what I needed.
This was my first time ever making a hot toddy and it was so easy! I was worried I’d mess up the ratios but they’re totally forgiving. I used a cheap blended whiskey I had in the back of my liquor cabinet and it still tasted incredible. No need for fancy stuff!
Okay quick PSA: don’t accidentally use cayenne instead of cinnamon when you’re making these for your family holiday dinner. Learned that the hard way. That said, even the spicy version was pretty good? My cousin who loves spicy food actually asked for the spicy variation recipe, so I guess I accidentally invented a new version? The base recipe is solid regardless of my silly mistake.
Made these for the guys before we went out to do our annual ice fishing trip last weekend. We all had a mug before heading out on the ice and everyone said it was the perfect pre-trip warm up. I added a little extra whiskey per the guys’ request and no one complained, ha.
So happy this recipe is naturally gluten free! I’ve been looking for a cozy warm cocktail I can make for my monthly girls’ night that works for my gluten sensitivity, and this fits the bill perfectly. I used raw honey instead of processed and it was divine.
Made this in my dorm room microwave last night when I was studying for finals and felt a cold coming on. Literally only needed a mug, hot water from the dorm dispenser, a mini bottle of whiskey, a lemon wedge I stole from the dining hall, and a honey packet I had in my backpack. 10/10 no fancy equipment needed, perfect for broke college kids.
I’ve been making hot toddies for 40 years and this recipe is almost exactly the one my mom used to make for us when we were sick as kids. The only difference is she added a tiny pat of butter on top to soothe a scratchy throat. Tried it that way with this recipe and it was just like I remembered. Simple, timeless, perfect.
Panicked last minute when my partner told me his parents were coming over on a super cold night and I had no dessert or fancy drinks planned. Threw these together in 10 minutes, served them with shortbread cookies, and his mom said it was the best welcome drink she’s ever had. Total lifesaver recipe for when you have unexpected guests!