Jalapeño Cheddar Bagel
intro
Chewy, crusty New York-style bagels bursting with spicy pickled jalapeños and melted sharp cheddar, perfect for toasting or loading with breakfast sandwich fillings.
Ingredients
Steps
Activate Dry Yeast
Pour 300ml warm (105-110°F) water into the large clear glass mixing bowl. Stir in 1 tbsp granulated sugar and 7g active dry yeast with the stainless steel dough whisk. Let rest 5 minutes at room temperature, until the surface forms a 1cm thick layer of foamy, bubbly yeast, indicating the yeast is active. If no foam forms after 5 minutes, the yeast is expired and should be replaced for best results.
Knead Bagel Dough
Add 500g bread flour and 2 tsp kosher salt to the activated yeast mixture. Stir with the dough whisk until a shaggy, rough, flour-dusted dough forms, then turn the mixture out onto the clean bamboo cutting board. Knead by hand for 10 minutes, folding and pressing the dough repeatedly, until it becomes smooth, elastic, and pulls back slowly when poked, with no sticky residue left on your hands or the board. Avoid adding extra flour unless the dough is extremely sticky, as excess flour will create dense, tough bagels.
Fold in Mix-Ins
Flatten the kneaded dough ball into a 2cm thick disk on the cutting board. Sprinkle 1 cup of the shredded sharp cheddar and all of the patted-dry chopped pickled jalapeños evenly across the dough surface. Fold the edges of the dough inward over the fillings, then knead gently for 2 minutes to distribute the cheese and jalapeños evenly throughout the dough, so no large clumps are concentrated in one spot. Use the serrated utility knife to chop any larger jalapeño pieces as needed before folding.
Shape and Proof Dough
Divide the filled dough into 8 equal 110g pieces using the serrated utility knife. Roll each piece into a tight, smooth ball on the cutting board, then poke a hole through the center with your thumb, stretching the hole to 5cm wide to form the classic bagel shape. Arrange shaped bagels 5cm apart on the parchment-lined rimmed aluminum baking sheet, cover loosely with the oatmeal linen tea towel, and let proof in a warm spot for 30 minutes, until bagels are puffy and spring back slowly when poked gently with a finger.
Boil Bagels in Water
While bagels proof, fill the large stainless steel stock pot with 4L of water, bring to a rolling boil over high heat, then stir in 2 tbsp baking soda. Once the water is at a gentle, steady rolling boil, use the slotted spider strainer to lower 2-3 bagels at a time into the water, cooking 1 minute per side. Bagels will puff slightly and float to the surface within 30 seconds, indicating they are ready to flip.
Top and Bake Bagels
Use the spider strainer to remove boiled bagels from the water, letting excess water drain off for 10 seconds over the pot, then return them to the parchment-lined baking sheet. Brush the top of each bagel with beaten egg using the pastry brush, then sprinkle the remaining 1/2 cup shredded cheddar evenly over the tops. Bake at 220°C (425°F) for 18-20 minutes, rotating the tray halfway through baking, until bagels are deep golden brown, cheese is melted and slightly crispy on top, and the crust feels firm to the touch.
Cool Bagels on Rack
As soon as bagels come out of the oven, use a thin spatula to transfer them from the baking sheet to the chrome wire cooling rack. Let cool for at least 15 minutes before slicing or serving, to allow the interior crumb to set properly—cutting bagels while too hot will result in a gummy, compressed interior.
Tips
2.Do not skip the boiling step, and ensure the baking soda water is at a steady rolling boil before adding bagels. Boiling gelatinizes the starch on the dough surface, creating the signature chewy, crisp bagel crust that cannot be achieved from baking alone.
3.Reserve 1/2 cup of shredded cheddar to top bagels right before baking instead of mixing all cheese into the dough. Cheese mixed into the dough melts into rich, savory pockets inside the crumb, while the top cheese bakes into a crispy, salty, cheesy outer crust for layered texture.

OMG these jalapeño cheddar bagels are a GAME CHANGER!! I’ve been buying the overpriced ones from my local bagel shop for years and these taste even better. The sharp cheddar gets so crispy on the outside and the jalapeño has just the right kick without being overwhelming. Made a double batch for meal prep this week and my roommate already stole two 😂
Made these for Saturday morning breakfast with the kids and they went crazy for them! I left the seeds in half the jalapeños for my husband who loves extra heat, and seeded the rest for the kids. 25 minute cook time was totally doable even with the chaos of weekend morning sports prep. Only note is I wish I’d added a little extra cheddar on top before baking, next time!
Took a stab at these for my office potluck last week and people were begging for the recipe! I was a little nervous since I’ve only made plain bagels before, and the medium difficulty rating had me worried, but the steps were super straightforward. The cheddar oozes a little while baking which makes the edges so crispy and delicious. 10/10 will make again
SO good! I’ve been intimidated to make homemade bagels forever because I thought the boiling step was too much work, but these came together way faster than I expected. The jalapeño and cheddar combo is the perfect savory balance to my morning iced latte. I did add a tiny sprinkle of everything bagel seasoning on top of a couple and *chefs kiss*. Only tiny gripe is I wish the recipe mentioned to line the baking sheet with parchment because the melted cheddar drips a ton and left me with a sticky mess to scrub, otherwise 10/10!
These are now a weekly staple for my Sunday meal prep! They hold up so well in the fridge for 4-5 days, and 30 seconds in the toaster makes them taste fresh out of the oven. I love that I don’t have to stop at the bagel shop on my way to work anymore, saves me so much time and money. Worth every minute of prep!
Made these in my tiny dorm kitchen last night and my whole floor could smell them lmao. Ended up sharing half the batch with people down the hall and everyone said they were better than the bagels from the campus café. Only mess up was I forgot to poke a big enough hole in the middle so a couple of them closed up while baking, oops. Still tasted amazing though!
Brought these to our family barbecue last weekend and even my super picky father-in-law asked for seconds! I served them sliced with a side of jalapeño cream cheese and they were the first appetizer gone. I was worried they’d be too spicy for the older crowd but the heat was super mild when I fully seeded all the jalapeños. Will absolutely be making these again for our next gathering
I’ve tried three different jalapeño cheddar bagel recipes online and this is by far the best one. The ratio of cheese to jalapeño is perfect, the bagel has that ideal chewy texture you want from a good bagel, and the cook time is way shorter than other recipes I’ve tested. I did add a pinch of garlic powder to the dough and it elevated it even more. Can’t recommend enough