Jersey Tomato Pie
intro
A beloved regional savory pie from New Jersey, featuring ripe summer tomatoes, melted cheese, and a flaky crust, baked to golden, tangy perfection.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep and drain tomatoes
Arrange the ¼-inch thick sliced Jersey tomatoes in a single layer on a wire rack set over a rimmed baking sheet. Sprinkle evenly with ½ teaspoon of kosher salt, then let rest for 30 minutes at room temperature to draw out excess moisture. Pat slices dry thoroughly with paper towels before use to prevent a soggy crust.
Mix and chill pie crust
In a large mixing bowl, combine 240g all-purpose flour and 1 teaspoon fine sea salt. Add 113g cold cubed unsalted butter, and use your fingertips or a pastry cutter to work the butter into the flour until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs with pea-sized butter chunks. Drizzle in 60ml ice water 1 tablespoon at a time, mixing gently until the dough just comes together. Form the dough into a 1-inch thick disk, wrap tightly in plastic wrap, and chill in the refrigerator for 20 minutes while the tomatoes drain.
Blind bake the crust
Preheat oven to 200°C (400°F). Sprinkle a 9-inch ceramic pie dish evenly with 1 tablespoon cornmeal to prevent sticking. Roll the chilled dough out on a lightly floured surface to a 12-inch circle, then press it firmly into the prepared pie dish, crimping the edges decoratively. Line the crust with parchment paper, fill with ceramic pie weights or dried beans, and bake for 15 minutes on the middle oven rack. Remove the parchment and weights, then bake for 5 more minutes until the base is pale golden. Set aside to cool for 5 minutes.
Layer the pie filling
In a small mixing bowl, combine 226g shredded low-moisture mozzarella, 50g grated Parmigiano-Reggiano, minced garlic, 1 teaspoon dried oregano, remaining ½ teaspoon kosher salt, ½ teaspoon black pepper, and half of the torn fresh basil. Spread this cheese mixture in an even layer across the bottom of the cooled par-baked crust, creating a moisture barrier. Arrange the patted-dry tomato slices in overlapping, shingled layers on top of the cheese to cover the entire surface, then drizzle evenly with 2 tablespoons extra-virgin olive oil.
Bake the assembled pie
Reduce oven temperature to 190°C (375°F). Place the assembled pie on the middle oven rack, and bake for 30 to 35 minutes, until the crust is deep golden brown, the cheese is bubbling around the edges, and the tomato tops are slightly wrinkled and roasted. If the crimped crust edges brown too quickly, cover them with a thin strip of aluminum foil halfway through baking to prevent burning.
Rest and garnish pie
Remove the baked pie from the oven, and let it rest for 15 minutes at room temperature to allow the filling to set – this prevents the cheese and tomatoes from sliding out when sliced. Top with the remaining torn fresh basil and a light sprinkle of flaky sea salt (if desired) before serving warm or at room temperature.
Tips
2.Use only low-moisture mozzarella for this recipe; fresh mozzarella packed in water releases too much moisture even when patted dry, and will ruin the crisp crust texture.
3.For authentic Jersey tomato pie texture, always spread the cheese directly against the par-baked crust to create a moisture barrier, rather than layering tomatoes directly on the crust.

Grew up in Trenton, NJ and have been chasing that perfect tomato pie taste since I moved out west 10 years ago. OMG this recipe is SPOT ON. The crust is crispy on the bottom, not soggy at all, and the sauce has that bright, tangy tomato flavor I remember. Made it for my roommate last night and she thought I ordered takeout from back home. 10/10 no notes.
Tried this for our weekly Sunday family dinner and my kids devoured it! Usually they pick off the cheese and complain about crust, but they asked for seconds before I even sat down. Only thing I messed up was stretching the crust too thin on the first try, but the second pie came out perfect. SO good, will be adding this to our regular rotation.
Wait, cook time is almost two hours? Is this worth making for Sunday meal prep? I usually make 3-4 meals on Sundays to get through the work week, wondering if this holds up reheated?
Brought this to my neighborhood block party potluck last weekend and people were asking me for the recipe before I even set the platter down! Everyone kept saying it was way better than the local pizza place down the street. Total game changer.
Medium difficulty isn’t lying, y’all. My first crust was a lumpy mess and I almost gave up, but I followed the dough instructions to the letter on the second go and it came out fantastic. Don’t skip the step where you let the dough come to room temp before stretching, that’s non-negotiable. The sauce is so simple but packed with flavor, no weird added sugars like store bought pizza sauce.
Taste was amazing, but has anyone tried this with a gluten free flour blend? I have celiac and tried it with my usual all purpose GF blend and the crust came out super crumbly, couldn’t even pick up a slice. Flavor was 10/10 but texture was a bummer.
As someone who grew up 10 minutes from the original Papa’s Tomato Pie, I’m very picky about this stuff. This is the closest home recipe I’ve ever tried. The cheese under the sauce? That’s the key move that so many copycat recipes miss. Absolute perfection.
Made this on my pizza stone on the grill last weekend since it was too hot to turn the oven on, and it came out insane. Got the grill up to 500 degrees, let the stone preheat for 30 minutes, and the crust had that perfect charred edge just like the boardwalk spots down the shore. 10/10, will be making this all summer.
Made this in my tiny dorm oven with a cheap baking sheet because I don’t have a pizza stone, and it still came out so much better than the late night delivery pizza we usually order. I split one pie with my three roommates and we fought over the last slice. Only thing I added was a little sprinkle of parmesan on top after baking, chef’s kiss.
Wait, is this supposed to be less cheesy than regular pizza? I followed the cheese measurement exactly and it felt like there was barely any, but my partner said it was perfect. I’m used to extra cheese loaded pizza, so maybe that’s just me? Flavor was still great, just curious!
This is the first yeast dough I’ve ever made from scratch and I was so nervous I’d mess it up! I had to re-read the dough rising steps three times, but the final pie was so good my mom asked if I ordered it from a restaurant. So proud of how it turned out, but man that 1 hour+ rise time felt like forever waiting to eat.
Added a sprinkle of red pepper flakes and a handful of sliced pepperoni on top of the sauce for a little extra kick, and it was *chef’s kiss*. The base recipe is so solid, it’s super easy to tweak with your favorite toppings without ruining that classic tomato pie vibe. Already planning to make it again this weekend with some roasted garlic.
I did a price breakdown on this and the whole pie costs less than $5 to make, which is wild compared to the $20 takeout pizza we usually get on Friday nights. All the ingredients are pantry staples I already had on hand except for the fresh mozzarella, so this is going to be our new go-to Friday night meal. Way better for the budget, and tastes way better too.
Flavor was incredible, but my crust came out totally soggy in the middle even after baking it for the full time listed. What did I do wrong? I used a regular baking sheet, no pizza stone, maybe that’s the issue?
Made this for our Eagles watch party last Sunday and everyone was raving. The tangy sauce pairs so good with a cold beer, it was the perfect game day food. Even my cousin who swears he only likes Chicago deep dish went back for three slices. I call that a win.