lobster and shrimp
intro
Silky butter-poached lobster and plump shrimp in garlicky herb butter, bright with fresh lemon—an indulgent, elegant dish perfect for special moments.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep and Season Seafood
First, place lobsters in the freezer for 15 minutes to sedate them for humane handling. Set the maple cutting board center counter, then use the 8-inch chef knife to split each lobster lengthwise down the middle, removing the thin intestinal vein running down the tail, and cracking the large claws lightly with the knife back to ease post-cooking peeling. Pat the 8 peeled, deveined shrimp dry with a corner of the linen towel, then season lobster and shrimp evenly with 1/2 tsp flaky sea salt and 1/8 tsp ground black pepper. The seafood should be dry to the touch, with no excess moisture on the cutting board.
Build Poaching Butter Base
Remove the cutting board and prepped seafood temporarily to a cool spot on the counter left, then set the 3-quart stainless steel saucier center work zone over medium-low heat. Pour in the 3 tbsp dry white wine and add the 3 crushed garlic cloves, bring to a gentle simmer (160°F / 71°C) and cook for 2 minutes until the wine is reduced by half, smelling fragrant and garlicky, with no harsh alcohol aroma remaining. Do not let the garlic brown, as this will make the butter bitter.
Emulsify Poaching Butter
Reduce heat to low (maintaining a steady 160°F / 71°C, check with the instant-read thermometer placed to the right of the pan). Whisk in the cold butter cubes one at a time, adding the next cube only after the previous one has fully melted into the wine base, creating a smooth, thick, golden emulsified butter sauce. Stir in half the chopped parsley and half the thyme leaves once all butter is added. The sauce should be silky, not separated, with a pale golden color.
Poach Lobster Gently
Use the stainless steel tongs to place the lobster halves cut-side down into the butter sauce, ensuring the tail and claw meat is fully submerged. Maintain a steady 160°F / 71°C temperature (do NOT let the butter boil, as this will make the seafood tough) and poach for 6 minutes. The lobster shells will turn bright, vivid red, and the flesh will turn opaque white at the edges when nearly done.
Add Shrimp to Poach
After the lobster has cooked for 6 minutes, nestle the 8 seasoned shrimp into the butter sauce around the lobster pieces, ensuring all shrimp are fully submerged. Continue poaching at 160°F for a further 3-4 minutes, until shrimp are plump, opaque pale pink, and curl into a tight 'C' shape. The lobster flesh will be fully opaque white, firm but springy to the touch, with no translucent raw spots when checked with the tip of a knife. Total poaching time for lobster is 9-10 minutes; do not overcook, as this will make the flesh rubbery.
Plate Seafood Neatly
Turn off the heat, use the slotted spoon to lift the lobster and shrimp from the butter sauce, letting excess butter drain off for 2 seconds before arranging on the matte cream oval stoneware platter set center counter. Tuck the 2 lemon wedges between the seafood pieces, crack the lobster claws fully to expose the tender meat if needed.
Garnish and Serve
Spoon 1.5 tablespoons of the warm garlic herb butter over the plated seafood, sprinkle with the remaining chopped parsley and thyme, a light pinch of the remaining 1/4 tsp flaky sea salt and remaining 1/8 tsp black pepper. Place the small cream stoneware ramekin of extra melted butter to the right of the platter for dipping, and serve immediately while warm.
Tips
2.Pat shrimp and lobster dry before seasoning: Excess surface moisture will dilute the butter sauce and prevent the seasoning from adhering properly to the seafood, leading to bland, watery bites.
3.Save the leftover poaching butter: Strain out the garlic and herb bits, then refrigerate for up to 1 week to use for sautéing vegetables, tossing with pasta, or dipping crusty bread—it is packed with rich, briny seafood flavor you won’t want to waste.

OMG this butter-poached lobster and shrimp was the star of our anniversary dinner last night! I was nervous it’d be too fussy for an at-home special occasion meal, but 15 minutes cook time? Total game changer. The garlicky butter was so fragrant, my husband kept sneaking bites of shrimp straight out of the pan before I even plated it. 10/10 will be making this for our next dinner party with friends!
SO good! I was worried the medium difficulty rating meant I’d mess up the lobster, but the steps were super straightforward even for someone who almost never cooks seafood. My 7 and 9 year old devoured their portions and asked for seconds, which never happens with "fancy" meals! Only tweak I made was adding a tiny squeeze of fresh lemon at the end, cut through the richness perfectly.
Made this for meal prep this week to pair with roasted asparagus and quinoa, and it held up way better than I thought seafood would! The butter keeps it from getting rubbery when I reheat it at the office, total weeknight win. I skipped adding extra salt because I used salted butter, which worked out perfectly for my taste.
Brought this to our neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were literally hovering over the platter asking for the recipe! I doubled the batch because I know how our block gets around good seafood, and there was literally nothing left by the time everyone went through the line. Only heads up is that it goes fast, so if you’re making it for a crowd, definitely double or triple like I did.
Quick question — has anyone tried this with frozen lobster tails? I live in Ohio so fresh lobster is crazy expensive and hard to track down, I don’t want to waste money on frozen if it’ll turn out rubbery. The 15 minute cook time is perfect for my busy work week schedule, just need to know if frozen works before I shop for ingredients!