Lobster Benedict
intro
Indulgent New England twist on classic eggs Benedict, featuring butter-poached lobster, runny-yolk poached eggs, and rich creamy hollandaise on crisp toasted English muffins.
Ingredients
Steps
Butter-poach the lobster
Use kitchen shears to cut through the soft underside membrane of each lobster tail, gently pull out the raw lobster meat, and discard the shells. Melt 56g (1/4 cup) unsalted butter in a small saucepan over low heat (maintain 120C/250F, no bubbling or browning), add the lobster meat, and poach for 6-7 minutes, turning once halfway, until the meat is opaque pale pink and firm to the touch. Remove lobster from butter, slice into 1cm thick medallions, and cover loosely with foil to keep warm.
Toast English muffins
Split each English muffin horizontally into two equal halves, arranging all 8 halves cut-side up on a rimmed baking sheet. Toast under a preheated high-heat broiler, positioned 20cm (8in) from the top heating element, for 2-3 minutes until the cut surfaces are golden brown and crisp at the edges. Remove from the broiler, brush each cut side with a thin layer of the leftover butter used to poach the lobster, then arrange 2 halves per serving plate, covering loosely with foil to keep warm.
Poach the fresh eggs
Fill a large deep saucepan with 10cm (4in) of water, bring to a gentle simmer (85C/185F, small bubbles rising from the pan base, no rolling boil) over medium-low heat, then stir in 15ml (1 tbsp) white vinegar and 3g (1/2 tsp) kosher salt. Crack each of the 8 whole eggs into separate small 60ml (1/4 cup) ramekins. Gently slide 4 eggs at a time into the simmering water, cooking for 3 minutes per batch for fully set whites and soft, runny yolks. Remove cooked eggs with a slotted spoon, drain briefly on paper towels, and trim any ragged, wispy egg white edges; keep warm while poaching the second batch.
Whip hollandaise sauce
Fill a small saucepan with 2.5cm (1in) of water, bring to a bare simmer over low heat. Set a heatproof glass bowl over the pan to create a double boiler, ensuring the bowl bottom does not touch the simmering water. Add the 3 egg yolks and 15ml (1 tbsp) fresh lemon juice to the bowl, whisking constantly for 2 minutes until the yolks turn pale yellow and thicken enough to coat the back of a spoon. Slowly drizzle in the remaining 170g (3/4 cup) warm melted butter while whisking nonstop, until the sauce is smooth, thick, and creamy. Remove from heat, stir in the remaining 15ml (1 tbsp) lemon juice, 1g (1/4 tsp) cayenne pepper, and remaining 2g (1/4 tsp) kosher salt; cover to keep warm.
Assemble the stack layers
Divide the sliced butter-poached lobster medallions evenly across the 8 toasted muffin halves, arranging the lobster in a neat, even layer on each buttered muffin surface. Top each lobster-topped muffin half with one drained poached egg, adjusting the egg gently to sit centered on the stack so it does not slide off.
Sauce and garnish
Spoon 30ml (2 tbsp) of warm hollandaise sauce over each poached egg, allowing the sauce to drip slightly down the sides of each stack. Sprinkle all servings evenly with the 15g (1/4 cup) finely chopped fresh chives and a light pinch of extra cayenne pepper for color and subtle heat. Serve immediately while all components are warm, before the hollandaise cools or egg yolks set.
Tips
2.Add vinegar to egg poaching water to help egg whites coagulate quickly and prevent wispy, spread-out eggs; never use a rolling boil, as turbulent water will break apart the delicate eggs.
3.Keep all cooked components (lobster, muffins, eggs) loosely covered with foil while prepping other elements to ensure the final dish is served warm, as cold lobster or muffins will ruin the luxurious texture.

OMG this was the star of our Mother's Day brunch last weekend! I was nervous about making hollandaise from scratch but the instructions were so straightforward, even my 16 year old helped whisk it. The lobster was buttery and tender, no rubbery bits at all. My mom said it was better than the version we get at our favorite coastal diner. 10/10 will make again for our next family gathering!
Made this for my wife’s birthday breakfast in bed and she cried (happy tears!). Cook time was right around 40 minutes like the recipe said, which was perfect because I didn’t want to be stuck in the kitchen all morning while she was waiting. Only note is I added a tiny pinch of old bay to the hollandaise and it slapped. Will definitely be adding this to our regular weekend rotation.
Tried this for a solo date night in after a long work week and it felt like such a fancy treat without the crazy restaurant price tag. I skipped the English muffin and served it over roasted asparagus to cut a few carbs and it was chef’s kiss. SO good, even for a medium-difficulty recipe I didn’t feel overwhelmed at all.
Wait has anyone tried pre-making the hollandaise for this? I host a monthly potluck brunch and want to make as much ahead as possible so I’m not running around like a crazy person when guests show up. The rest of the recipe seems easy to prep the night before, but I’m worried the hollandaise will break if I make it too early.
Uh oh, I messed up the first batch of hollandaise so bad it curdled 😭 I followed the steps exactly but I think my heat was too high? Has anyone had this happen? The lobster came out perfect but I had to run to the store and get pre-made hollandaise to save breakfast. Still tasted great but I want to nail the homemade version next time.
My kids are so picky about seafood but they devoured this! I cut the lobster into really small pieces and mixed a little into their portions instead of piling it on top, and they asked for seconds. Who knew lobster benedict would be a kid-approved meal? Game changer for our weekend breakfasts.
Great recipe overall! I used fresh lobster from Pike Place Market which obviously elevated it, but the hollandaise recipe is the real star here. I’ve tried a million hollandaise recipes and this one has the perfect balance of lemon and butter, not too tangy, not too rich. Only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is I wish there was a note about how to pick the best lobster tails for new cooks!
Made this for my anniversary dinner with my partner and it was so romantic! We paired it with mimosas (okay, maybe we had mimosas before we even started cooking, oops) and roasted potatoes on the side. The cook time was totally manageable even with a couple of champagne breaks. 100% making this for our next special occasion.
I was worried lobster would make this too expensive for a regular weeknight meal, but I found frozen lobster tails on sale at my grocery store for $5 each and the whole recipe cost under $20 for two servings! Way cheaper than ordering it at a restaurant where a single lobster benedict is like $28. Tasted just as good too, no skimping on flavor.
Does anyone have a tip for making this gluten free? I know the main swap is GF English muffins, but I’m paranoid about cross contamination and also wondering if there’s any hidden gluten in the hollandaise? I want to make this for my sister’s visit next month, she has celiac so I need to make sure it’s totally safe.
I made this for my roommate’s birthday brunch in our tiny dorm kitchen and it actually worked! I don’t have a double boiler so I used a glass bowl over a pot of boiling water like the note said, and it came together so easy. Our whole floor smelled like butter and lobster, half our dorm knocked on the door asking for bites lmao. 10/10 even with janky dorm equipment.
I’ve been making lobster benedict for over 30 years and I have to say, this recipe is spot on. The ratio of lemon to butter in the hollandaise is exactly how I used to make it back when I ran my brunch spot in Brooklyn. The tip to poach the eggs in a little vinegar is a pro move that a lot of home cook recipes leave out, great job including that. Will be passing this along to my grandkids.
This was solid! I added a dash of hot sauce to the hollandaise and sprinkled some red pepper flakes on top for a little kick, which was chef’s kiss. My only issue was the lobster took a little longer to cook than the recipe said, maybe my tails were thicker? Next time I’ll add a couple minutes.
Our brunch crew tried this last Sunday and everyone went back for seconds! We made a big batch with 6 lobster tails, doubled the hollandaise recipe, and it was so easy to scale up for a crowd. We had it with mimosas, bloody marys, and a side of hash brown casserole. Absolute hit, we’re already planning to make it for our Fourth of July brunch.
Okay, I’m notoriously bad at making fancy breakfast food—every time I try to make poached eggs they turn into weird egg drop soup messes. But I followed the egg poaching tips here to a T and they actually came out perfect! The whirlpool trick? Game. Changer. The whole thing turned out way better than I expected, even my husband was shocked I didn’t burn anything.
This was such a nice treat for my post-long run brunch last weekend! I used whole grain English muffins, cut the butter in the hollandaise by a third, and loaded up on extra lobster for protein, and it was still so satisfying. Didn’t feel like I was eating a sad “healthy” swap at all, and it kept me full for hours after my 10-mile run. Will definitely be making this again after my next race.
I added a little cajun seasoning to the lobster while it was cooking and a dash of paprika on top of the hollandaise, and it gave it such a nice little Louisiana twist. My whole family raved about it, even my super picky father in law who says “brunch isn’t real food.” Only complaint is the recipe didn’t say how long to toast the English muffins, I burned my first batch oops.
I tested this recipe at home last week to see if I could add a lobster benedict special to my food truck menu, and it’s a home run! I made a couple tweaks to make it faster for service, but the base hollandaise and lobster cooking method are exactly what I was looking for. Had a few regulars test it over the weekend and they all asked when it’s going to be on the menu permanently. Huge win!