Lobster Newburg
intro
Luxuriously rich lobster in sherry-spiked cream sauce, served over crisp toast points. A historic 1870s Delmonico's New York classic for special meals.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep toast and lobster
Preheat your oven to 180°C (350°F). Trim crusts from 8 slices of white sandwich bread, cut each slice diagonally into 2 equal triangles, and arrange in a single layer on a baking sheet. Bake for 8 minutes until golden and crisp, then set aside. Pat 450g of cooked picked lobster meat dry with paper towels, cut into 2.5cm (1-inch) chunks, and set aside at room temperature.
Sauté lobster in butter
Place a heavy-bottomed 2-quart saucepan over medium-low heat. Add 57g (4 tbsp) of unsalted butter, and melt for 1 minute until foaming subsides (do not let the butter brown). Add the prepared lobster chunks, toss gently to coat fully in butter, and cook for 2 minutes just to warm the meat through.
Deglaze pan with sherry
Pour 120ml (1/2 cup) of dry sherry into the saucepan with the lobster, increase heat to medium to bring the liquid to a gentle simmer. Cook for 3 minutes, stirring occasionally, until the sherry is reduced by half and smells rich and nutty.
Simmer cream sauce base
Reduce heat back to medium-low, then stir in 180ml (3/4 cup) of the heavy cream, 1/2 tsp sweet paprika, 1/4 tsp cayenne pepper, 1 pinch of grated nutmeg, 1 tsp fine sea salt, and 1/4 tsp black pepper. Stir constantly with a wooden spoon, and simmer gently for 4 minutes until the sauce thickens enough to coat the back of the spoon (a line drawn with your finger through the sauce on the spoon will hold its shape).
Temper egg yolk mixture
While the sauce simmers, whisk 3 large egg yolks with the remaining 60ml (1/4 cup) of cold heavy cream in a small glass bowl until completely smooth. Slowly ladle 120ml (1/2 cup) of the hot cream sauce into the egg mixture, whisking nonstop the entire time to prevent the eggs from curdling from the heat.
Thicken finished sauce
Pour the tempered egg yolk mixture back into the saucepan with the lobster and remaining sauce. Stir constantly over low heat (do NOT bring to a boil) for 2 minutes, until the sauce turns velvety, glossy, and thick enough to cling heavily to the lobster chunks. Immediately remove the pan from heat to avoid curdling.
Plate and serve hot
Arrange 4 crisp toast points on each of 4 warm dinner plates. Spoon equal portions of the lobster and sauce over the center of the toast points, add a light dusting of extra paprika for garnish if desired, and serve immediately while the sauce is hot.
Tips
2.Avoid overcooking the lobster: since the meat is already fully cooked, you only need to warm it through, as extended high-heat cooking will turn lobster tough and rubbery.
3.Use dry fino or amontillado sherry for authentic flavor, rather than sweet cream sherry or salted cooking sherry, which will throw off the sauce’s balanced, nutty, savory profile.

OMG this Lobster Newburg was the star of our anniversary dinner last night! I was nervous it’d be too fussy for a medium-difficulty recipe but the steps were so straightforward, and the sherry cream sauce? *Chef’s kiss* SO good, my husband kept going back for seconds even after we were stuffed. Served it over buttered toast points just like the recipe said, total game changer.
Made this for our weekly family Sunday dinner, swapped the fresh lobster for frozen since it was all I could grab last minute at the grocery store. Still turned out really rich and tasty, though I think I overdid the nutmeg a tiny bit. My kids loved it so much they asked if we can have it for their birthday dinner next month! Would absolutely make again, just measuring the spices more carefully next time.
Okay, full transparency, I messed up the roux on my first try and the sauce got all lumpy, so I had to start over. Second time around it came out pretty good, but it was way richer than I expected! I could only eat a small serving before I was full. Probably a me problem since I don’t cook creamy seafood dishes that often, but just a heads up for other new cooks: take your time with the roux!
I was skeptical a “fancy” lobster dish could work for meal prep but I made a big batch on Sunday and ate portions for lunch all week over cauliflower rice (cutting carbs, don’t judge) and it held up perfectly! The sauce didn’t separate at all when I reheated it low and slow in the microwave, which is usually my biggest pet peeve with cream-based seafood dishes. Total game changer for fancy work lunches that make all my coworkers jealous.
I really wanted to love this, but I found the sherry flavor way too overpowering for my taste. I followed the measurement exactly, but after one bite it was all I could taste, and it totally overpowered the lobster. I ended up adding extra heavy cream and a squeeze of lemon to mellow it out, which helped, but I don’t think I’ll make this again. Lobster is too expensive to mess around with recipes that don’t balance flavors right for my palate.
Y’all, I made this for my wife’s birthday and I was so worried I’d mess it up because I mostly stick to smoked meats and barbecue. It came out INSANE. The richness of the sauce paired with the sweet lobster? We ate it over puff pastry shells instead of toast points because that’s what we had in the freezer, and I will never go back. My wife said it was better than the Lobster Newburg we had on our honeymoon in Cape Cod. High praise, let me tell you.
Made this for my parents when they came to visit me at school to prove I don’t just eat ramen and frozen pizza. Used pre-cooked lobster meat from the campus grocery store and it still turned out so fancy! My mom kept taking photos to send to the whole family group chat. Only complaint is it made my tiny dorm kitchen smell like seafood for two days, lmao. Worth it though.
This is now my go-to date night recipe when I want to impress without spending 3 hours in the kitchen. 35 minute cook time is chef’s kiss for a dish that feels like it came from a high-end steakhouse. I served it with roasted asparagus on the side and my date thought I’d been taking secret cooking classes. 10/10, no notes, will be making this at least once a month.
So glad this recipe was easy to adapt for my gluten allergy! I swapped the regular flour in the roux for a 1:1 gluten free all purpose flour blend and you literally could not tell the difference. I was worried the sauce would get gummy or weird textured, but it was perfectly smooth and luxurious. Served it over gluten free garlic bread for my whole family and no one even guessed it was GF!
Brought this to my neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were hovering over the serving dish the second I set it down! I was worried the 35 minute cook time would cut into my prep window for other dishes but it came together so much faster than I expected. Got asked for the recipe by no less than 7 neighbors, already sent them all the link. 10/10, will be making this for every fancy gathering from now on.