Mulled Cider
intro
Warm, aromatic spiced apple cider simmered with citrus and whole spices, with balanced sweet-spicy notes perfect for cozy winter holiday gatherings.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep flavor ingredients
Wash the 150g navel orange thoroughly, slice it into 1cm thick rounds, and gently push 4 whole cloves into each of 2 orange slices to prevent loose cloves from floating in the cider. Peel the 20g ginger piece, slice it into 3mm thick coins, and measure out all remaining spices (3 cinnamon sticks, 6 allspice berries, 2 star anise) and 3 tablespoons dark brown sugar.
Combine cider and aromatics
Pour the full 2L of fresh unfiltered apple cider into a 4L heavy-bottomed stockpot or Dutch oven set over medium-low heat. Add the clove-studded orange slices, remaining plain orange slices, sliced ginger, measured whole spices, and dark brown sugar to the pot, stirring once with a wooden spoon to fully dissolve the sugar.
Heat to gentle simmer
Warm the cider mixture for 8-10 minutes on medium-low heat, stirring occasionally, until it reaches a gentle steady simmer with small bubbles breaking at the surface (internal temperature 82°C/180°F). Do not bring to a rolling boil, as high heat will cook off bright apple flavor and leach bitter compounds from the spices.
Steep to infuse flavors
Once the cider reaches a simmer, reduce heat to the lowest stovetop setting, cover the pot partially with its lid (leave a 2cm gap to allow excess steam to escape), and let the cider steep undisturbed for 15 minutes. Avoid frequent stirring during steeping to prevent the cider from turning cloudy.
Strain out solid ingredients
After 15 minutes of steeping, turn off the stovetop heat. Set a fine-mesh metal sieve over a 3L heatproof glass serving pitcher or punch bowl, and pour the hot mulled cider through the sieve to catch all orange slices, ginger, and whole spices; discard the used solids.
Finish and serve warm
If using the optional 120ml dark rum, stir it into the strained cider just before serving. Ladle the warm cider into heatproof ceramic mugs, garnish each with a thin fresh orange wheel and 1 small cinnamon stick if desired, and serve at 71°C/160°F for ideal drinking temperature.
Tips
2.For a kid-friendly non-alcoholic version, skip the rum entirely; add 60ml (1/4 cup) pure maple syrup for extra woody sweetness if you prefer a richer, deeper flavor profile.
3.Leftover mulled cider will keep for up to 3 days in a sealed glass container in the refrigerator; rewarm it gently over low stovetop heat instead of microwaving on high to avoid flat, dull flavor.

OMG this spiced mulled cider was an absolute game changer at our neighborhood fall potluck last weekend! I threw it together in 30 minutes exactly like the recipe said, even swapped the regular apple cider for hard cider on a whim for the adult crowd, and people were coming back for thirds. The spice balance is perfect—not too clove-heavy like every other mulled cider recipe I’ve tried before. My kids loved the non-alcoholic batch I made on the side, they begged for refills before we even left the house! 10/10 will be making this on repeat all fall, including for our Thanksgiving dinner.
Such an easy recipe, total lifesaver when my kid’s high school cross country team came over after their chilly meet last week. I added a couple extra cinnamon sticks and a splash of fresh orange juice because that’s what my grandma used to put in her mulled cider, and it turned out SO good. Only tiny note? I wish I’d made a double batch, it was gone in 10 minutes flat between all the hungry teens!
Made this last night while my roommates and I carved pumpkins, and it made the whole apartment smell like literal fall heaven. No crazy fancy ingredients, no fussy steps, exactly what I want for a low-key weeknight fall activity. I couldn’t find whole allspice berries at my corner store so I skipped ’em, and it still tasted amazing—definitely grabbing them next time I’m at the grocery store to see what depth they add.