Old Forge Pizza
intro
Iconic rectangular, square-cut Pennsylvania regional pizza with a crisp oiled crust, bright uncooked tomato sauce, and a creamy, melty two-cheese blend.
Ingredients
Steps
Mix pizza dough
In a large mixing bowl, combine 360ml warm (38°C/100°F) water, 10g granulated sugar, and 7g instant yeast. Let sit 5 minutes until the surface appears foamy, indicating active yeast. Add 480g all-purpose flour, 12g kosher salt, and 30ml (2 tbsp) olive oil, stirring with a wooden spoon until a shaggy, sticky dough forms with no dry flour pockets. Cover the bowl with a damp kitchen towel, and let rest in a warm (24°C/75°F) spot for 60 minutes until the dough doubles in volume.
Shape crust in pan
Generously grease a 33cm x 46cm (13x18 inch) half-sheet pan with the remaining 15ml (1 tbsp) olive oil, coating the bottom, corners, and inner sides fully to prevent sticking and create a crispy crust. Turn the risen dough out onto the oiled pan, and use olive-oiled fingertips to press and stretch the dough evenly across the entire pan surface, pushing it all the way to the edges with no thick raised rim. Let the pressed dough rest, uncovered, for 20 minutes to relax the gluten so it does not shrink during baking.
Make tomato sauce
While the pressed dough rests, stir 400g undrained crushed tomatoes, 9g minced garlic, 1g dried oregano, 1g ground black pepper, and 5g chopped fresh basil in a medium bowl until fully combined. Do not cook the sauce—traditional Old Forge pizza uses raw, bright tomato sauce to prevent a soggy crust. Set the sauce aside at room temperature, and preheat your oven to 245°C (475°F) as the dough finishes resting to ensure it is fully hot for baking.
Assemble pizza layers
Once the rested dough has puffed slightly across the pan, use the back of a metal spoon to spread all of the tomato sauce in a thin, even layer across the entire dough surface, taking care to avoid thick sauce pools that can make the crust soggy. Evenly sprinkle 340g shredded low-moisture mozzarella over the sauce, then top with 113g shredded white American cheese, spreading the cheese all the way to the pan edges to create a crispy, cheesy perimeter.
Bake to crisp perfection
Place the assembled pizza on the middle rack of the preheated 245°C (475°F) oven. Bake for 20-22 minutes, rotating the pan 180 degrees at the 11-minute mark to ensure even browning, until the cheese is bubbly with scattered golden brown spots, and the crust edges are deep golden and crisp to the touch.
Rest and slice to serve
Remove the baked pizza from the oven, and let it rest directly in the pan for 8 minutes to set the cheese and crust—this prevents toppings from sliding when cut. Use a sharp rotary pizza cutter to cut the pie into 12 even square slices (3 cuts across the short side, 4 cuts across the long side) and serve warm.
Tips
2.Do not substitute fresh mozzarella for low-moisture mozzarella in this recipe; fresh mozzarella has a very high water content that will seep into the crust and leave it soggy instead of crisp.
3.White American cheese is a key traditional ingredient for Old Forge pizza, creating the signature smooth, creamy melt and mild, rich flavor; avoid yellow American or extra-sharp cheeses that will overpower the classic taste.

OMG I grew up eating Old Forge pizza every Sunday after church and I have spent YEARS trying to find a recipe that nails that chewy, crispy crust and perfect cheese blend. This is IT!!! Made it for our family dinner last night and my husband asked if we could have it again this weekend. Game changer, no cap.
Made this for my kids’ soccer team potluck last weekend and every single slice was gone before I even got a bite! The only tweak I made was adding a little extra oregano because my crew loves it. SO good, will be adding this to our monthly meal rotation.
Wait, 2+ hours cook time? I thought this would be a faster weeknight meal, tbh. Flavor was great when I tested it last Saturday but it’s definitely more of a weekend project for us. Crust was chef’s kiss though, can’t lie.
Bro. Bro. I’ve been making pizza at home for 10 years and this dough recipe is unreal. I cooked it on my baking steel at 500 degrees like the recipe said and got that perfect charred bottom I’ve been chasing forever. 10/10 no notes.
Tried swapping in a 1:1 gluten free flour blend for the regular AP flour for my celiac daughter, and it turned out way better than I expected! The crust was a little crispier than the traditional version but the whole family ate it with no complaints.
I’m a diehard deep dish fan so I went into this skeptical, but wow. The square cut, the slightly sweet sauce, that melty cheese that goes all the way to the edges? It’s a whole different vibe but I’m obsessed. Made it for movie night with my roommates and we fought over the last corner piece.
Made a double batch of the dough on Sunday, portioned it out, and froze half for quick meals later in the week. It thawed perfectly in the fridge overnight and baked up just as good as fresh! Such a great recipe to prep ahead for busy school nights.
Okay full transparency, this is the first homemade pizza I’ve ever made that didn’t turn out a soggy, lumpy mess. The instructions were so easy to follow even for someone who burns toast half the time! My roommates thought I ordered takeout lmao.
Wait a second, Old Forge pizza is supposed to have that slightly sweet tomato sauce right? I added a teaspoon of sugar to my sauce like my grandma used to and it tasted exactly like the pizza we got on family trips up north when I was a kid. So nostalgic.
I loaded mine up with extra provolone like the recipe mentions and it was *chef’s kiss*. Only thing I messed up was stretching the dough a little too thin on one side, so it leaked a little cheese in the oven, but that just made crispy cheese bits so it was a win honestly.
I’ve been making pizza every Friday night for my grandkids for 18 years, and this is the new recipe they’re begging for every week. I was a little intimidated by the medium difficulty rating but it was totally manageable, even for my old hands. Perfect crumb, perfect sauce ratio.
Added a sprinkle of crushed red pepper to the sauce and a handful of pickled jalapeños on top for a little kick, and it went so hard. If you love a little heat on your pizza, don’t sleep on that combo. The base recipe is so solid it’s easy to tweak to your taste.
Wait, quick question — I don’t have a baking sheet big enough for the full rectangle size the recipe calls for. Can I split the dough into two smaller squares and bake them on separate sheets? Don’t want to mess up the ratios!
Made this in my portable outdoor pizza oven for a tailgate last weekend and people were coming over from three other tailgates to ask for the recipe. I thought Old Forge style was too thick for a portable oven but it cooked up in like 8 minutes flat and was a total showstopper.
Loaded mine up with sautéed mushrooms, bell peppers, and black olives, and even my meat-obsessed brother said it was one of the best pizzas he’s ever had. The crust is so flavorful it doesn’t even need a ton of toppings to be incredible.
I could drink this tomato sauce straight from the bowl, no joke. I was worried the herb blend would be too much but it’s perfectly balanced — not too oregano-heavy, not too garlicky, just right. I even used the leftover sauce on pasta the next night!
This was way cheaper than ordering takeout for my family of 4, and it tasted 10x better. All the ingredients are just regular pantry staples I already had on hand, no fancy specialty stuff required. Will be making this at least twice a month now.
Okay, I have to admit I was a total hater when my boyfriend said we should make homemade pizza instead of ordering from our favorite spot. But this crust? The crispy edges, the soft middle, that buttery taste? I’m eating my words (and a third slice). 10/10, better than our local takeout.
Let this dough cold ferment in the fridge for 24 hours instead of doing the room temp rise, and the flavor was next level. If you have the extra time, I can’t recommend that hack enough — it gives the crust that tangy, complex taste you get at fancy pizza shops.