Pastry Stout Craft Beer
intro
Velvety, indulgent pastry stout brewed with dark cacao, vanilla, and cold brew coffee, boasting rich roasted notes, a creamy mouthfeel, and subtle sweetness for cold winter sipping.
Ingredients
Steps
Mill All Grains
Set up the hand-crank stainless steel grain mill on its light oak base at the left side of the counter. Adjust the mill gap to 0.04 inches to crack, not pulverize, the grain kernels. Pass all Maris Otter pale malt, roasted barley, chocolate malt, and flaked oats through the mill, collecting the cracked grain in a clean prep bowl. Check that no whole kernels remain, and husks are broken but intact to avoid astringency in the finished beer.
Heat Mash Water
Fill the 5-gallon stainless steel brew kettle with 19 liters (5 gallons) of cold filtered water, set it on the matte black induction burner, and heat to 67°C (153°F). Clip the digital food thermometer to the kettle rim to monitor temperature consistently, adjusting the burner power as needed to hold a steady temperature without overheating.
Mash Cracked Grains
Slowly stir all the milled grains into the 67°C (153°F) water using the long stainless steel stirring spoon, stirring thoroughly to eliminate any dry clumps of grain. Hold the temperature steady at 65-68°C (149-154°F) for 60 minutes, covering the kettle with its lid to retain heat. The finished mash will smell sweet and toasty, with a thick, porridge-like consistency.
Sparge and Boil Wort
After 60 minutes of mashing, place the fine-mesh stainless steel strainer across the top of the brew kettle, then slowly pour 7.5 liters (2 gallons) of 77°C (170°F) hot water over the grain bed held in the strainer to rinse residual sugars from the grains, collecting the sweet amber wort in the kettle below. Discard the spent grains, then bring the collected wort to a rolling, steady boil at 100°C (212°F), adjusting the induction burner to maintain the boil without messy boilovers.
Add Hops and Lactose
Once the wort reaches a full rolling boil, add the full 28g (1 oz) of Northern Brewer hops, and stir in all 450g (1 lb) of lactose powder using the stainless steel stirring spoon until the powder is fully dissolved. Maintain a steady boil for 60 minutes, stirring occasionally to prevent wort from scorching on the kettle bottom. The wort will darken to a deep mahogany color as it boils and reduces slightly.
Cool and Pitch Yeast
After the 60-minute boil, turn off the induction burner, and cool the wort as quickly as possible to 20°C (68°F) by setting the kettle in an ice bath. Once cooled, place the stainless steel funnel in the neck of the 5-gallon glass carboy, and pour the cooled wort into the carboy, leaving 2 inches of headspace at the top. Sprinkle the full packet of US-05 ale yeast over the wort surface, seal the carboy with a sanitized airlock filled with neutral sanitizer, and store the carboy in a dark, 18-21°C (65-70°F) space for 14 days to complete primary fermentation.
Add Pastry Adjuncts
After 14 days of primary fermentation, when bubbling in the airlock slows to 1 bubble every 30 seconds, move the carboy back to the counter, sanitize the opening, then add the 85g (3 oz) of dark cacao nibs, split and scraped 2 Madagascar vanilla beans, and 240ml (8 fl oz) of cold brew coffee through the funnel. Reseal the airlock, and let the beer condition for an additional 7 days at the same 18-21°C temperature to absorb the rich pastry flavors.
Bottle and Condition
After 7 days of conditioning on adjuncts, siphon the finished beer into sanitized 12oz glass bottles lined up along the front of the counter, adding 1 teaspoon of priming corn sugar to each bottle to create natural carbonation. Use the bottle capper from the oak caddy to crimp caps tightly on all bottles, then store them at room temperature for 10 days to carbonate, then chill for 48 hours before serving.
Tips
2.Wait to add cacao nibs, vanilla, and coffee until primary fermentation is complete: highly active yeast during the first 14 days will scrub away delicate aromatic compounds, resulting in muted, flat pastry flavors instead of rich, distinct chocolate and vanilla notes.
3.Chill carbonated bottles for a full 48 hours before pouring: this allows fine yeast sediment to settle tightly at the bottle bottom, resulting in a clearer pour, smoother mouthfeel, and a creamier, longer-lasting tan head.

OMG this pastry stout came out INSANE. I brought a growler to my friend’s fall potluck last weekend and everyone was begging for the recipe! The chocolate and vanilla notes are so rich, it tastes like a boozy brownie in a glass. 10/10 will be brewing this again for holiday parties.
Pretty solid recipe! I’m pretty new to homebrewing so the medium difficulty had me nervous, but the steps were way easier to follow than other stout recipes I’ve tried. My only note is that mine came out a little less sweet than I expected, so next time I’ll add a touch more lactose. My husband and his buddies still raved about it at our football watch party though!
Game changer. I’ve been homebrewing for 8 years and this is hands down the best pastry stout recipe I’ve ever tested. The 3.5 hour cook time is totally worth every minute—my kids even said the house smelled like a chocolate factory while it was simmering! Question for folks who’ve made this: how long do you usually let it condition in the bottle before cracking the first one?
Taste was great, but I ran into a stuck mash halfway through and it added almost an extra hour to my cook time. Wondering if anyone else had that issue? I followed the grain bill exactly so I was surprised it got so thick.
SO good. I’ve dropped almost $20 a four pack for fancy pastry stouts from local breweries and this homemade version tastes identical, if not better. Made it for my partner’s birthday and he said it was better than the reserve stout we had on our first date. Obsessed.
First time ever attempting a stout (usually stick to IPAs) and this was so fun to make! I added a little extra cacao nibs because I’m a chocolate fiend, and it turned out delicious. Only thing is I think I overcarbonated a couple bottles, oops. Any tips to avoid that next time?
Made this for our annual neighborhood block party and it was the first keg to kick! Everyone kept saying it tasted like a s'mores beer, which I was not mad at. I did toss in a handful of toasted marshmallow bits in the secondary, highly recommend that tweak.
Wait, I was so worried about the medium difficulty rating because I’ve only done two brew days ever, but this was totally manageable! The step-by-step instructions didn’t skip any little details that new brewers like me need. My roommate said it’s better than the pastry stout we waited 2 hours in line for at the beer festival last month.
Solid recipe, great base to play around with add-ins. I did a version with peanut butter powder this round and it tastes like a liquid Reese’s cup, absolute chef’s kiss. Cook time felt like it flew by when I had a game on in the background while I brewed.
Just finished my first sip of this batch after conditioning and OH MY GOD. It’s so smooth, the vanilla and caramel notes are perfect, no weird bitter aftertaste like some stouts I’ve made. I’m already planning my next batch to bring to my family’s Thanksgiving dinner.
Flavor is on point, but I wish the recipe noted how much headspace to leave in the fermenter! I had a little bit of a blowout when fermentation got super active, made a huge mess on my counter. Otherwise, the end result is tasty, just a stressful clean up mid-process.
Brewed this with my teen son for his first ever homebrew project and we had the best time! He picked out this recipe because he loves sweet stouts, and he’s already talking about bringing bottles to show his old high school science teacher how fermentation works. Such a fun weekend activity.
Meal prep but make it homebrew! I brewed a double batch of this on Sunday and now I have a whole fridge full of beer to get me through the busy work weeks and weekend game days. The rich chocolate flavor is the perfect pick me up after a long day.
Really great recipe! I will say if you live in a super humid climate like I do, you might want to adjust your mash temp a tiny bit because mine came out a little thinner than I wanted the first time. Second batch I bumped the temp up 2 degrees and it was perfectly thick and creamy.
Just got done bottling this batch and the sample I pulled was chef’s kiss. I added a little cinnamon and chipotle powder for a tiny kick, and the warmth from the chipotle pairs so well with the dark chocolate notes. Can’t wait for these to condition so I can share them at my office holiday potluck.
I’ve tried so many copycat pastry stout recipes and none of them get that velvety, dessert-like mouthfeel right until this one. My wife who swears she “hates beer” drank two full glasses of this and asked when we’re making more. Absolute win.
SO good. I was worried 3.5 hours would be too long of a brew day for a Sunday, but it went by so fast when I had my playlist going and a friend over to help. We ended up making pizza halfway through to snack on, it was the perfect chill weekend activity. The beer turned out rich, decadent, everything I want in a pastry stout.
Great base recipe! I swapped the regular vanilla extract for vanilla bean paste and added a handful of toasted coconut, and it tastes like a Samoa cookie in beer form. My only complaint is that it’s so good I’m gonna go through my batch way faster than I planned.