Poppy Seed Bagel
intro
Chewy, golden-crusted New York-style poppy seed bagels with a crisp, seed-studded exterior and soft, dense interior, perfect for slicing and spreading with cream cheese.
Ingredients
Steps
Mix Shaggy Dough
Pour 300ml warm (40°C/105°F) water into the large stainless steel mixing bowl, stir in 1 tbsp barley malt syrup with the beech wood spoon until dissolved. Sprinkle 7g instant yeast over the surface, let rest 5 minutes until a thin layer of foam forms across the water top, indicating active yeast. Add 500g bread flour and 2 tsp fine sea salt, stir firmly until all dry flour is incorporated into a stiff, shaggy mass with no loose flour left in the bowl bottom.
Knead Smooth Dough
Turn the shaggy dough out onto the unfloured maple cutting board. Knead by hand for 8-10 minutes, folding the dough over itself and pushing forward with the heel of your hand, turning a quarter turn after each fold. The dough is ready when it is smooth, elastic, and springs back slowly when poked with a finger, with no sticky residue left on the board or your hands.
First Dough Rise
Form the kneaded dough into a tight smooth ball, place it back into the lightly oiled stainless steel mixing bowl, and cover the bowl top with the cream linen towel pulled temporarily from its fixed corner. Let rise in a warm, draft-free spot for 1 hour, until the dough has doubled in size and leaves a slow-recovering indent when poked 1cm deep with a floured finger.
Shape Bagel Rounds
Once risen, punch the dough down firmly to release all trapped air, turn it out onto the maple cutting board. Use the stainless steel dough scraper to divide the dough evenly into 8 pieces, each ~100g. Roll each piece into a tight smooth ball, then poke a hole through the center of each ball with your floured thumb, stretching the hole to 5cm wide to form the classic bagel shape. Place shaped bagels on the parchment-lined baking sheet, cover again with the linen towel, and let rest 15 minutes while you preheat the oven to 220°C/425°F and bring a large pot of water to a rolling boil.
Boil Bagels Briefly
Once the stock pot water is at a rolling boil, stir in 1 tbsp baking soda. Working in batches of 2-3 bagels at a time to avoid crowding, gently lower bagels into the boiling water. Boil for 1 minute per side, flipping with the spider strainer, so each side is cooked and puffed slightly. Boiled bagels will have a slightly wrinkled, glossy surface.
Coat with Poppy Seeds
Use the spider strainer to lift boiled bagels from the water, letting excess water drain off for 10 seconds. Immediately press the top surface of each wet bagel into the shallow cream dish filled with poppy seeds, coating the top thickly and evenly. Return seeded bagels to the parchment-lined baking sheet, seed-side up, spacing them 5cm apart.
Bake to Golden Crust
Place the baking sheet of seeded bagels into the preheated 220°C/425°F oven. Bake for 18-20 minutes, rotating the sheet halfway through, until bagels are deep golden brown on the crust, with poppy seeds toasted and fragrant, and the internal temperature reaches 93°C/200°F.
Cool on Wire Rack
Remove baked bagels from the oven, immediately transfer them from the baking sheet to the chrome wire cooling rack. Let cool for at least 15 minutes before slicing, to allow the crumb to set properly; cutting hot bagels will result in a gummy, compressed crumb.
Tips
2.Do not skip the 1-minute per side boiling step: the hot water gelatinizes starches on the dough surface, creating the shiny, crisp, chewy crust that defines a good bagel, and prevents the dough from over-puffing in the oven into a soft roll shape. Adding baking soda to the water raises the pH, encouraging deeper, faster browning in the oven.
3.Coat bagels in poppy seeds immediately after pulling them from the boiling water, while the surface is still damp and starchy: dry bagel surfaces will not hold seeds securely, leading to most of the poppy seeds falling off when you slice, toast, or eat the bagels. Do not pat bagels dry before adding seeds.

OMG these poppy seed bagels taste exactly like the ones I used to get from my neighborhood bakery in Brooklyn growing up! Chewy on the inside, perfectly crisp crust, the poppy seeds don’t all fall off when you take a bite which is a total win. Made them for Sunday family breakfast and everyone went back for seconds. SO good!
Total game changer for my weekly meal prep! I baked a double batch on Sunday, sliced them up, popped them in the freezer, and now I’ve got quick breakfasts all week. Toast one up, add a little cream cheese and lox, and it’s better than any coffee shop run. Worth the extra effort even with the medium difficulty!
I was super intimidated because I’ve never made bagels before, but the instructions were so clear! Mine came out a little lumpy looking but the flavor was spot on. Next time I’ll make sure to boil them a tiny bit longer for that extra chewy texture. Even my picky teen ate two before school!
Brought these to my neighborhood block party potluck last weekend and people were begging for the recipe! I served them with a side of honey walnut cream cheese and they were gone in 10 minutes flat. Will absolutely be making these again for our next gathering.
Wait, has anyone tried making these with whole wheat flour instead of all purpose? I try to sneak in whole grains where I can for my kids, but I don’t want to mess up the chewy bagel texture.
These were so good but I burned the bottom of my first batch 😅 Turns out my oven runs 25 degrees hot, so I turned it down for the second round and they came out perfect. Don’t skip the boiling step y’all, that’s non-negotiable for that real bagel chew!
I’ve been making bagels for 40 years and this recipe is hands down one of the best poppy seed versions I’ve tried. The ratio of salt to poppy seed on the crust is exactly right, not too salty, not too bland. My grandkids fought over the last one at brunch last Sunday!
Pro tip from my test run: toast the poppy seeds for a minute or two before you sprinkle them on top right before baking! It brings out such a nuttier, deeper flavor that takes these bagels to the next level. Trust me on this.
I thought 30 minutes cook time meant total time, oops! Forgot about the dough rising time, so my bagels were a little late for Saturday breakfast, but no one complained because they tasted incredible. Definitely block out enough time for the dough to proof, folks!
These are perfect for post-long run breakfasts! I love that I can control the ingredients, no weird preservatives like the store bought ones. I add a little everything bagel seasoning to half the batch for my partner and he’s obsessed too.
Help! My bagels came out super flat and didn’t hold their round shape when I boiled them. Did I overproof the dough? I let it rise for almost 3 hours because I got caught up watching a football game 😬
I moved to California 3 years ago and I have been chasing a good NYC-style bagel ever since. These are the closest I’ve ever made at home! I did add a tiny bit of malt syrup to the boiling water like I remember the bagel shops doing, and it was chef’s kiss.
My kids loved these so much that they asked me to put mini bagel versions in their school lunches all week! I made them half the size, baked them the same way, and they’re perfect for little hands. Game changer for school lunch ideas, I was stuck in a total sandwich rut.
Has anyone tried making these in an air fryer instead of baking them in the oven? I hate heating up my whole kitchen in the Florida summer heat, so I try to use my air fryer for everything if I can.
Made these for our monthly brunch club meetup and they were the star of the spread! We had cream cheese, lox, capers, tomato, onion, all the fixings, and everyone said they were better than the local bagel shop’s version. 10/10, will be making these for every brunch from now on.