Scrapple Sandwich
intro
Crispy pan-fried scrapple stacked with tangy condiments and melted cheese on toasted sourdough, a beloved Pennsylvania Dutch comfort classic.
Ingredients
Steps
Slice chilled scrapple
Remove the chilled 450g scrapple block from its packaging, pat all surfaces dry with paper towels to remove excess moisture, and cut into 8 even 1cm (1/2 inch) thick slices. Avoid cutting thinner slices, as they will easily break apart during frying.
Pan-fry scrapple until crisp
Heat a large cast-iron skillet over medium heat to a 175C/350F surface temperature. Add 1 tablespoon (14g) of salted butter, swirling to evenly coat the pan bottom. Arrange scrapple slices in a single layer (cook in 2 batches if needed to avoid overcrowding) and cook 4 minutes per side until deep golden brown, with crispy edges and no soft, mushy centers. Transfer cooked scrapple to a paper-towel lined plate to drain excess grease.
Toast bread and melt cheese
Reduce stovetop heat to medium-low (150C/300F). Add the remaining 2 tablespoons (28g) of salted butter to the same skillet, swirling to coat the pan. Place all 8 sourdough slices in the pan and toast 2 minutes per side until light golden and crisp at the edges. During the last 30 seconds of toasting, place one 30g cheddar slice on 4 of the bread pieces (the sandwich tops) to soften and melt slightly.
Spread sandwich condiments
Transfer all toasted bread slices to a clean cutting board. Lay the 4 non-cheese slices (sandwich bottoms) in a row, and spread 1.5 teaspoons (7.5ml) of spicy brown mustard evenly across each, followed by 1 tablespoon (15ml) of unsweetened apple butter, spread to cover the full bread surface.
Layer sandwich fillings
Stack 2 crispy scrapple slices on each condiment-covered bread bottom, pressing lightly to anchor them to the spread. Top the scrapple on each sandwich with 10g (loose 1/3 cup) of fresh arugula and 7.5g (1 tablespoon) of thinly sliced pickled red onion. Place the melted-cheese toast slices on top of each stack, with the melted cheese side facing down toward the fillings.
Press and serve warm
Press each assembled sandwich down gently with a spatula to help the layers adhere and prevent fillings from sliding out. Cut each sandwich diagonally into two equal triangles, and serve immediately while the scrapple remains crisp and the cheese is soft and melted.
Tips
2.Do not overcrowd the skillet when cooking scrapple; work in batches if needed to keep pan temperature high, which prevents soggy, grease-soaked scrapple.
3.For a classic breakfast twist, swap sourdough for soft white sandwich bread, add one crispy fried egg per sandwich, and replace apple butter with a light drizzle of pure maple syrup for sweet-savory balance.

OMG, I grew up eating scrapple sandwiches for Saturday breakfast with my grandpa and I have not been able to get the crispy edge right for YEARS. This recipe is a total game changer! Cooked it exactly 4 minutes per side on medium heat like the recipe said, and it was perfectly crispy, no mushy middle at all. Piled mine on toasted sourdough with a little spicy brown mustard and pickles, SO good. My husband thought I ordered it from our old neighborhood diner back in PA.
Made these for a quick weeknight dinner last night when I forgot to thaw chicken for the meal plan, and my kids went crazy for them! I was worried they’d turn their noses up at scrapple since they’re usually super picky, but the crispy texture won them over. I served them with tater tots and a side of apple butter for dipping, and even my 7 year old asked for seconds. 10/10, adding this to our regular rotation.
I’ve always made scrapple on the griddle for weekend brunch, but pan-frying it per this recipe got it so much crispier than I ever have before. I brought a batch of these sandwiches to my neighborhood potluck last weekend and they were gone in 10 minutes flat! People kept asking where I got the recipe. Only tiny knock is I wish the recipe mentioned how long to let the scrapple rest after slicing so it doesn’t stick as bad, but that’s a minor thing. Overall amazing.
I’d never even heard of scrapple before my roommate brought some home from the grocery store, and I was low-key scared to cook it lol. This recipe was so easy to follow, even for a total beginner like me! 20 minutes total from start to finish, no fancy ingredients needed, and it came out crispy just like the photos. Mine was a little salty for my taste, but that’s probably just the brand of scrapple I bought, not the recipe.
Obsessed with how easy this is to prep for weekday breakfasts! I pan-fry a whole pack of scrapple slices on Sunday, store them in the fridge, and then just crisp them up for 30 seconds on each side in the morning to build my sandwich. Saves me so much time on busy school mornings, and it’s way more filling than a boring granola bar.
Took a recommendation from a comment on here and added a drizzle of hot honey to my sandwich, and wow… life changing. The crispy salty scrapple, spicy sweet honey, a little arugula for crunch? I ate this for lunch three days in a row. No regrets.
Grew up in Ohio eating these at every little diner off the highway, and this recipe tastes exactly like what I remember. Most recipes I’ve tried cook the scrapple too low and it gets mushy, but the high-medium heat here gets that perfect shatteringly crisp crust that crunches when you bite into it. Served mine on white toast with ketchup, just like my dad used to make.
Made these for a girls’ brunch I hosted last Saturday, and everyone was begging for the recipe before they left! I set up a little topping bar with different mustards, cheese, pickles, jams, and hot sauces so people could build their own sandwiches. It was so low-effort but looked super impressive, 10/10 will be making this again for my next gathering.
Made this at 1am after a night out with friends and it hit DIFFERENT. Crispy, greasy, perfect sandwich to soak up a fun night. 10/10, no notes, will be making this every time I have friends over after the bar.
Super easy to make this gluten free! I just used my favorite GF sourdough bread and made sure the scrapple I picked up didn’t have any hidden wheat fillers, and it turned out just as crispy and delicious as the regular version. Great easy recipe for GF folks who miss classic diner breakfasts!
I’ve been making scrapple sandwiches for over 40 years, and I have to say, this method of getting the pan nice and hot before laying the slices down is the trick I was missing my whole life. No more stuck, broken scrapple, no more mushy bits. Told my son about this recipe and he made it for his family last night, said his kids loved it too.