ShackBurger
intro
Juicy griddled beef patty, melted American cheese, tangy signature sauce, and crisp toppings on a soft potato bun—the iconic NYC ShackBurger made easily at home.
Ingredients
Steps
Mix Shack Sauce
In a small mixing bowl, whisk together 120ml full-fat mayonnaise, 30ml ketchup, 15ml yellow mustard, 15ml dill pickle brine, 1g garlic powder, and 1g smoked paprika until completely smooth with no lumps. Cover the bowl and refrigerate for 10 minutes to allow flavors to meld while you prepare the remaining components.
Form beef patties
Divide the 680g 80/20 ground beef into 4 equal 170g portions. Gently shape each portion into a loose, 10cm (4-inch) wide patty that is slightly wider than your potato buns—do not compress or overwork the meat, as this creates tough cooked patties. Press a shallow 1cm dimple in the center of each patty to prevent bulging as it cooks.
Toast potato buns
Heat a cast iron skillet or flat griddle to medium heat (175°C / 350°F). Brush the cut inner sides of all 4 split potato buns evenly with the 28g melted unsalted butter. Place buns cut-side down on the preheated cooking surface for 45 to 60 seconds, until the cut surfaces are golden brown and slightly crisp at the edges. Transfer toasted buns to a clean plate and set aside.
Sear beef patties
Increase the griddle or skillet heat to medium-high (205°C / 400°F). Season the top surface of each raw patty evenly with three-quarters of the 5g kosher salt and all of the 2g freshly ground black pepper. Place patties seasoned-side down on the hot cooking surface, then season the exposed top side with the remaining kosher salt. Cook for 2.5 minutes without moving the patties, until a deep, crispy mahogany brown crust forms on the bottom.
Melt cheese on patties
Use a stiff metal spatula to flip each patty in one smooth motion, then immediately top each flipped patty with 1 slice of American cheese. Cook for an additional 1.5 minutes for medium doneness, until the cheese is fully melted and slightly oozing down the sides of each patty. Transfer cooked patties to a clean plate to rest for 1 minute before assembling.
Assemble the burgers
Spread 1 tablespoon (15ml) of the chilled Shack sauce on the cut inner side of both the top and bottom toasted bun for each burger. Layer the bottom bun with 1 trimmed green leaf lettuce leaf, 1 thin Roma tomato slice, 2 dill pickle slices, then the rested cheesy beef patty. Place the top bun on the patty, press gently to hold layers in place, and serve immediately.
Tips
2.Never press down on patties with a spatula while cooking, as this forces out all the rendered fat and flavorful juices, leading to dry, tough patties.
3.Do not overwork the beef when forming patties; gently shape loose pucks to keep the meat tender, as tightly compressed meat becomes dense when cooked.

OMG this is a total game changer! I’ve been missing Shake Shack ever since we moved an hour away from the nearest location, and these taste EXACTLY like the real thing. My kids devoured two each at our family cookout last weekend, even my picky 7 year old asked for seconds. The secret sauce is spot on, I could slather that on everything. SO good!
Made a test batch of these last night to prep for my neighborhood potluck this Saturday, and they were so good! Quick question though — can I make the sauce a day ahead? I don’t want to be rushing around right before guests show up! Also, do you recommend smashing the burgers super thin like they do at the restaurant? I felt like I didn’t smash mine quite enough last night.
Made these in my tiny dorm kitchen with a cheap electric griddle and they still slapped. Spent way less than I would on a ShackBurger delivery, and my roommate said he’d pay me to make these for him every week. Total win for easy weeknight meals when you’re on a budget.
These were so tasty! I swapped the regular potato bun for a gluten free brioche bun and it worked perfectly. Only thing is my first batch of patties stuck to the pan a little — did I not heat the pan enough? Flavor was 10/10 regardless, will absolutely make again.
As someone who ate ShackBurgers at least once a week when I lived in Manhattan, I can confirm this recipe is dead on. The cheese melt, the sauce, the soft bun — I felt like I was standing in the Madison Square Park line all over again. 10/10, no notes.
Added these to my weekly meal prep rotation! I make a batch of the patties on Sunday, keep the sauce in a mason jar, and I’ve got quick, delicious lunches all week. Way better than sad desk salads, let me tell you. Even my coworkers kept asking where I got the burger from when I heated one up at the office yesterday.
Made these on my outdoor flattop grill for game day last Sunday and they were the first thing gone off the snack table. People kept coming back asking for the recipe, I had to send the link to like 8 of my friends. The thin crispy patty edge is unmatched, I’ll never make thick pub-style burgers again.
Okay I know this is sacrilege but I added a couple pickled jalapeños to my burger and it CHEF’S KISS. The creamy sauce cuts the heat so perfectly, it’s my new go-to variation. Don’t @ me, it works.
I’m literally just learning to cook and this was so easy! I was nervous I’d mess up the patties but the instructions were super straightforward, no fancy ingredients needed. My girlfriend said it was the best burger I’ve ever made, which is saying something because I’ve burned a lot of burgers before lmao.
Pro tip: Don’t skip the American cheese! I tried it once with sharp cheddar because that’s all I had in the fridge, and it just wasn’t the same. The melty, gooey American is exactly what makes it taste like Shake Shack, trust me. Also, buttering the buns before toasting them is non-negotiable.
I’ve heard nothing but amazing things about this recipe and can’t wait to make it! Quick question for the group: Has anyone tried making this with a dairy free cheese alternative? My son is lactose intolerant but he’s been begging for Shake Shack ever since his friends talked about it, I want to make these for his birthday dinner next week.
20 minute cook time is no lie! I got home late from work, threw these together, and had dinner on the table before my partner even finished picking a show to watch. Way faster than waiting for delivery, and 10x tastier. Will be a regular on our weeknight menu for sure.
I could drink that Shack sauce straight, no cap. I put it on my fries, my chicken sandwiches, even dipped my tater tots in it last night. Why have I been buying store bought special sauce when this is so easy to make at home? Total game changer.
I was worried the thin patties wouldn’t be filling enough so I doubled up the patties per burger like they do at the actual Shack, and it was perfect. Paired it with crinkle cut fries and a chocolate shake and I swear I saved like $12 per person compared to ordering takeout for my family of four. Worth every minute of prep.
Full transparency: I forgot to add the pickles to mine and it was still insane. I ran to the fridge halfway through eating to grab a jar and add them on, and yeah, the pickles are a key touch, but even without it this burger slaps. 10/10, forgiving recipe for people who get distracted while cooking (aka me).
Made these for my at-home date night last night and my partner said it was better than our last date at Shake Shack in the city. We toasted the buns, made the sauce, added extra pickles, and ate them while we watched a baseball game. Such a fun, easy date night meal that feels special without all the fuss.