Sherry Punch
intro
Warm, aromatic spiced sherry punch balanced with bright citrus, toasty spices, and a hint of honey, perfect for slow sipping at cozy winter holiday gatherings.
Ingredients
Steps
Slice Fresh Citrus
Place the whole navel orange, 4 clementines, and small lemon on the honey oak cutting board. Using the 4-inch paring knife, slice all citrus into 5mm-thick wheels, picking out and discarding any visible seeds as you cut. Set aside 6 of the most uniform, blemish-free clementine wheels for garnish, pressing 1 whole clove into the peel of each reserved wheel. Pile the remaining citrus slices loosely on the right side of the cutting board. This prep step takes approximately 5 minutes.
Simmer Spice Infusion
Pour the 120ml filtered water from the clear glass measuring cup into the brushed stainless steel saucepan. Add the 3 cinnamon sticks, 2 star anise, remaining 3 whole cloves, 2 tablespoons raw honey, and 3 tablespoons golden raisins to the pan. Place over low heat on the flush induction burner, bring to a gentle simmer (identified by tiny bubbles forming only around the pan edges, no rolling boil), then let the spices infuse for 8 minutes, stirring once with the beech wood muddler to fully dissolve the honey. The finished infusion will be pale golden, with a rich, warm spicy aroma.
Warm Sherry and Brandy
Once the spice base has infused for 8 minutes, turn the induction burner to the lowest setting. Pour the full 750ml of dry Amontillado sherry and 60ml of brandy into the saucepan, stirring gently with the beech wood muddler to fully combine with the spice base. Heat the mixture for 10 minutes, maintaining a steady temperature of 60C/140F — do not allow the liquid to boil, as high heat will destroy sherry's delicate nutty flavor and evaporate too much alcohol. The punch will deepen to a rich warm amber color as it heats.
Strain Punch Into Bowl
After 10 minutes of gentle heating, carefully lift the saucepan from the induction burner. Set the fine-mesh stainless steel strainer across the rim of the large clear glass punch bowl. Slowly pour the warm sherry mixture through the strainer to catch all whole spices and raisins, leaving a smooth, particle-free amber punch in the bowl. Set the strainer with caught spices aside on the counter; reserve 2 cinnamon sticks and a spoonful of plumped raisins for garnish if desired.
Add Citrus Slices
Add all the non-garnish sliced citrus (the navel orange, lemon, and un-studded clementine slices) to the punch bowl. Gently press the slices once or twice with the stainless steel ladle to release a small amount of fresh citrus juice into the punch, but do not muddle them to a pulp. Let the punch rest for 5 minutes to allow the bright citrus flavors to meld with the spiced sherry base. Citrus wheels will float across the punch surface, their bright peel contrasting with the deep amber liquid.
Garnish and Serve
Ladle the warm punch into the clear stemmed punch cups, filling each to 2/3 capacity. Garnish each cup with one of the reserved clove-studded clementine wheels, perched on the cup rim. For extra festive flair, add one plumped golden raisin and a tiny piece of reserved cinnamon stick to each cup. Serve immediately while the punch is warm but not scalding; the punch will hold its temperature for up to 1 hour in the glass bowl at room temperature.
Tips
2.Choose dry Amontillado sherry rather than sweet cream sherry for this recipe: Amontillado's nutty, slightly briny dry base balances the honey and natural citrus sweetness perfectly, while sweet cream sherry will result in a cloying, overly sugary punch that feels heavy after just a few sips.
3.For deeper, more melded flavor, make the spiced sherry base up to 24 hours in advance, storing it covered in the refrigerator. Reheat gently over low heat before adding fresh citrus slices and serving; adding citrus too early during storage will make the punch taste bitter from prolonged contact with citrus peel pith.

Made this for my pre-game before the college football watch party last weekend and everyone was begging for the recipe! So easy to throw together, the spice blend doesn’t overpower the sherry at all. 10/10 will make again for tailgates.
OMG this punch is SO good! I brought it to my office holiday potluck and even the people who swear they don’t like sherry went back for seconds. Perfect balance of warm spices and sweetness, not too heavy.
I’ve been making spiced punch for family dinners for 40 years and this recipe is my new go-to! Took me 20 minutes flat, just like the recipe said, and my grandkids raved about it. I added an extra cinnamon stick for garnish, chef’s kiss.
Pretty solid recipe for how easy it is. I used a dry sherry instead of sweet because that’s what I had on hand, and it still turned out great. Would pair perfect with Thanksgiving appetizers next month.
Total game changer for my girls’ night in! We made a big batch, added some frozen cranberries as ice cubes, and it looked so fancy for how little effort it took. Will absolutely be adding this to my regular party rotation.
Made this for my wife’s birthday dinner and she loved it! I’m definitely not a skilled bartender so the easy difficulty rating was a lifesaver. Didn’t burn the spices or anything, win in my book.
Has anyone tried making this ahead for a big crowd? I’m hosting 25 people for our neighborhood block party next weekend and want to prep as much as I can the night before so I’m not running around day of.
Wait, is this non-alcoholic friendly? My teen cousin is coming to our family Thanksgiving and I want to make something everyone can enjoy.
How much does this recipe serve? I’m making it for a small Friendsgiving of 6 people and don’t want to end up with way too much (or worse, too little!) punch.
My kids loved it! The spiced aroma while this was simmering had them hanging out in the kitchen the whole time I cooked. I made a little non-alcoholic batch for them with apple juice and they kept asking for refills, while the adult version with sherry was chef’s kiss for the grown ups too.
Tried this last night and thought the spice level was a little heavy on the clove for my taste, but that’s just personal preference! Next time I’ll cut the clove measurement in half and I bet it’ll be perfect.
OMG serving this with orange slices and whole star anise as garnish made it look like I spent hours on a fancy craft cocktail for my book club! No one needed to know it only took 20 minutes to make lol.
Can I use a cheaper cooking sherry for this or do I need to get the nicer drinking sherry? On a tight budget for my holiday party this year.
Made this for my fall potluck at work and it was the first empty bowl on the drink table! So many people asked where I found the recipe, I sent them all straight here.
Wait, do you serve this warm or cold? The recipe says simmer the spices but I can’t tell if you chill it after or serve it hot. I want to make it for our Halloween party this weekend!
I added a splash of spiced rum to this last time I made it and OH MY GOD it was so good. Took an already great punch to the next level, highly recommend if you like a little extra booze kick.
Is there a way to make this less sweet? I don’t love super sugary drinks and I’m worried the sherry plus the spice syrup will be too much for my taste.
Meal prepped a batch of this to have little servings after work all week and it’s the best cozy nightcap ever! I didn’t think punch would work as a weekly treat but it’s so easy to store in mason jars in the fridge.
Made this for our family Thanksgiving dinner last year and it was such a hit I’ve been tasked with bringing it again this year! Last time I forgot the nutmeg though, does it make a big difference?
Wait how did I not know about this recipe before? I hosted a fall dinner party last weekend and served boring old wine, this would have been such a better vibe. Saving this for my next get together for sure.