Sourdough Toast
intro
Shatteringly crisp, golden sourdough toast with a soft chewy crumb, slathered in melted cultured butter and finished with flaky salt—simple, elevated comfort ready in minutes.
Ingredients
Steps
Slice Sourdough Evenly
Place the half sourdough loaf cut-side down on the central maple cutting board. Hold the serrated bread knife at a 45-degree angle, and cut four even 2.5cm (1 inch) thick slices using gentle sawing motions to avoid crushing the soft, holey crumb. Set cut slices in a small stack on the right edge of the cutting board, discarding any overly dry end pieces if desired. Visual cue: Each slice should have a 5mm thick dark, crusty edge surrounding pale, air-pocketed open crumb.
Preheat Dry Skillet
Retrieve the 10-inch matte black carbon steel skillet and place it on the counter immediately to the right of the maple cutting board, set to medium heat (175C / 350F). Preheat the completely dry skillet for 2 full minutes—do not add butter or oil at this stage. Test the temperature by flicking a single drop of water onto the pan surface; it should bead and dance across the skillet immediately when the correct temperature is reached.
Toast First Bread Side
Use the stainless steel tongs to lay two sourdough slices flat in the dry preheated skillet, leaving 1cm of space between them. Cook for 2 full minutes without moving or pressing down on the slices (pressing compresses the crumb and pushes out moisture needed for a soft center). The down-facing surface will turn deep golden brown with darker, crisped crust edges when ready. Visual cue: Look for faint, lacy dark brown toasting marks across the bread surface, with no pale uncooked spots remaining.
Flip Toast Evenly
Use the stainless steel tongs to flip each slice of bread carefully to avoid tearing the crisp crust. Toast the second side for 1.5 to 2 minutes, until it matches the deep golden brown color of the first side. Transfer the first two finished slices to a temporary spot on the edge of the cutting board, then repeat the toasting process with the remaining two sourdough slices. Visual cue: Both sides of every slice should sound crisp when tapped lightly with the tongs, with no soft pale patches remaining.
Butter Warm Slices
Once all four slices are fully toasted, turn off the heat under the skillet. Open the glass butter jar, retrieve the silicone basting brush, and use it to spread 0.5 tablespoon of softened cultured butter evenly across the top surface of each warm toast slice. Let the butter melt fully into the crumb crevices and run slightly down the crisp crust edges, taking care not to over-butter (excess butter will make the toast soggy). Visual cue: The butter will foam slightly as it hits the warm toast, leaving a glossy, even sheen across the surface without pooling.
Season and Plate Toast
Move the two matte cream ceramic side plates from their stacked back-right position to the front center of the counter. Stack two buttered toast slices on each plate, leaning them slightly against each other for gentle height. Sprinkle a tiny pinch of flaky sea salt evenly across the top of each stack, and tuck a small fresh thyme sprig against the toast for a bright, herby garnish if desired. Let the toast rest for 30 seconds before serving so the butter sets slightly into the crumb. Visual cue: The flaky salt crystals will glisten on the buttered surface, catching the soft natural light.
Tips
2.Cut sourdough slices to an exact 2.5cm (1 inch) thickness: thinner slices will turn hard and cracker-like when toasted, while this thickness creates the ideal textural contrast of shatteringly crisp outer crust and soft, chewy open crumb in the center.
3.Skip the pop-up toaster for artisan sourdough: skillet toasting delivers more even, controlled browning across the bread’s uneven crust and holey crumb, and prevents melted butter from dripping down into hard-to-clean toaster slots.

OMG this is SO good! I’ve been making sourdough toast in the toaster forever and never thought to use a skillet—total game changer. Got that perfect crispy edge but the middle is still soft and chewy, exactly how I like it. My kids devoured two slices each before school this morning, will be making this on repeat!
Super easy, 5 minutes exactly like the recipe says. I slathered mine with homemade peach jam and it was the perfect quick breakfast before my morning hike. Crispy enough that the jam didn’t make the bread soggy at all, 10/10.
Made this for our weekend potluck brunch last week and everyone asked for the recipe! I used a little garlic butter instead of plain butter on a couple slices and people went crazy for it. So easy to scale up for a crowd too.
Wait, do I need to use cast iron for this? I only have a regular nonstick skillet at my apartment and don’t want to mess it up. Has anyone tried it with nonstick?
Game changer for meal prep! I make a batch of these on Sunday, top them with avocado and a fried egg during the week, and they hold up way better than regular toaster toast. No more sad soggy work breakfasts for me.
Wait, is it normal for the butter to foam a lot when I put the bread in? I was worried I burned it at first but the toast came out great, just wanted to make sure I didn’t do something wrong lol.
SO good. I sprinkled a little parmesan on the bread while it was toasting in the skillet and got that perfect crispy cheese crust, paired great with tomato soup for dinner last night. Will absolutely be making this again.
I was skeptical because 5 minutes felt too fast, but wow, this really does come out perfect every time. I’ve made it four times this week already—once with cinnamon sugar for a sweet treat, once with avocado, once with egg salad, once just plain butter. All chef’s kiss.
My partner is obsessed with sourdough and I’ve been looking for easy ways to step up our weekend breakfasts, this did not disappoint. We served it alongside scrambled eggs and bacon and they said it was better than the toast we get at our favorite brunch spot downtown. Win for me!
Quick question—what thickness do you slice the sourdough for best results? I usually slice mine super thick but I’m worried it won’t crisp all the way through in the skillet.