Steak 'n Shake Original Double 'n Cheese
intro
The iconic Steak 'n Shake Original Double 'n Cheese: thin, crispy-edged seared beef patties, melted American cheese, soft toasted bun, and classic tangy toppings for nostalgic diner flavor at home.
Ingredients
Steps
Portion Beef Balls
Set the digital kitchen scale on the light maple cutting board. Divide the 500g 80/20 ground beef into eight equal 62g (2oz) portions, rolling each gently into a loose, round ball. Do not overwork or compact the meat, as this creates tough, dense patties. Set the beef balls along the back edge of the cutting board, loosely covered, until ready to cook.
Preheat Cast Iron Griddle
Place the 12-inch cast iron griddle over the two burners of the flush stovetop, preheating to medium-high heat (200C / 400F) for 5 minutes. Test readiness by sprinkling a drop of water on the surface: the griddle is ready when the water dances across the metal and evaporates in 1-2 seconds. While the griddle heats, use the small stainless steel butter spreader to brush the cut sides of all split hamburger buns with melted unsalted butter.
Toast Buttered Buns
Working in batches to fit the griddle, place buttered bun halves cut-side down on the preheated griddle surface. Toast for 30-45 seconds, until the cut surface is light golden brown with soft, not crispy, edges. Use the small stainless steel tongs to remove toasted buns, setting them cut-side up on the retro diner plates positioned at the front right of the counter.
Sear Thin Beef Patties
Working in batches of 2-3 patties at a time to avoid crowding the griddle, place loose beef balls on the hot griddle surface, leaving 5cm between each. Immediately press each ball firmly flat with the wide thin-bladed stainless steel spatula to form a 10cm wide, 3mm thin patty. Season the top of each patty with a pinch of kosher salt and black pepper. Cook for 90 seconds, until the edges are deep golden and crispy, and tiny beads of red beef juice bubble through the uncooked top surface of the patty.
Flip Patties, Add Cheese
Slide the thin metal spatula firmly under each patty (scraping to lift all crispy browned bits from the griddle to avoid tearing) and flip in one quick, smooth motion. Immediately place one slice of American cheese on top of each flipped patty. Cook for an additional 60 seconds, until the cheese is fully melted and the second patty side is crispy and browned. Stack two cooked, cheese-topped patties on top of each other while still on the griddle to let the cheese bind the layers together for each double burger.
Layer Base Condiments
On the cut side of each toasted bottom bun, use the butter spreader to spread 1 tsp yellow mustard evenly, followed by 1 tsp ketchup. Top the condiment layer with 1 tbsp finely diced white onion, spread evenly across the bun, and 4 crinkle-cut dill pickle slices per burger.
Stack and Serve Burgers
Use the wide metal spatula to lift one stacked double patty pair (two patties with melted cheese between layers) and place it directly on top of the pickle and onion layer on each prepared bottom bun. Place the toasted top bun on top of the patty stack, pressing down gently to set the layers so condiments and cheese hold the burger together. Serve immediately while hot and crispy.
Tips
2.Use only 80/20 lean-to-fat ground beef: the 20% fat content renders as the patties cook, creating the signature rich flavor and crispy seared edges, while also preventing patties from sticking to the dry griddle. Leaner beef blends will produce dry, bland burgers without the classic crust.
3.Only press patties once, immediately after placing them on the griddle: pressing patties after they have started searing squeezes out all the flavorful fat and juice, leading to dry, tough burgers. The single initial press creates the ultra-thin patty shape without losing moisture.

OMG this tastes EXACTLY like the Steak 'n Shake double I get on road trips! I was so skeptical a 10 minute at-home recipe could nail it but the thin patty trick? Game changer. My husband thought I ordered delivery until he saw me wiping grease off the stovetop lmao.
Super easy weeknight win! Only thing I changed was adding a little extra pickles because my household is obsessed with dill pickles. Kids devoured these in 5 minutes flat, no complaints at all.
Bro I have been craving Steak 'n Shake since I moved out here for school and the nearest location is 45 minutes away. This recipe saved my life. Took me 10 minutes total, used the cheap ground beef I had in the fridge, tasted identical. 10/10.
Made these for our weekly game night potluck last weekend and people were begging for the recipe! Everyone said they were better than the fast food version, I even had a couple people ask if I catered lmao. So good, zero fuss.
Taste was great, but these didn't hold up great for meal prep for me — the buns got soggy by day 2 even when I stored the patties separate. Any tips for making these work for weekly lunches?
I've tried so many copycat Steak 'n Shake recipes and this is the only one that gets the cheese melt right! The trick of putting a tiny splash of water on the griddle to steam the cheese? *Chef's kiss* Absolute perfection, no notes.
Worked at a Steak 'n Shake back in the 80s and let me tell you, this recipe is spot on. The thin patties, the American cheese, the soft bun — you folks nailed it. Brought back so many memories making these for my grandkids last weekend.
These were so good even with dairy-free American cheese! I was worried the swap would ruin it but the patty seasoning is so spot on I barely noticed a difference. My roommate who eats regular cheese even loved them.
Just whipped these up after a long 12 hour shift and I'm blown away. 10 minutes, minimal cleanup, tastes way better than any takeout I could've grabbed on my way home. Will be in my regular rotation for sure.
Taste was fine but my patties kept sticking to my pan no matter what I did. Ended up with a crumbly mess instead of nice thin patties. What am I doing wrong?
Made these for my son's 10th birthday because he's obsessed with Steak 'n Shake, and all his little friends went crazy for them! Even the parents were asking how I made them. So much cheaper than ordering a whole catering spread from the restaurant.
Made these at 1am after a night out with friends and let me tell you — better than any late night drive thru run. Crispy edges, melty cheese, perfect soft bun. I'm never waiting in a Steak 'n Shake drive thru line again.
First time ever making burgers from scratch and these turned out way better than I expected! I over-salted the patties a tiny bit but even then they were delicious. Super easy for a total beginner like me.
Paired these with homemade crispy onion rings and it felt like I was sitting in a Steak 'n Shake booth! The recipe is so straightforward, no fancy ingredients needed, which is my favorite kind of weeknight meal.
Cost me less than $10 to make 4 of these burgers at home, when a single double 'n cheese is almost $6 at my local Steak 'n Shake now. Absolute steal, tastes identical, will be making these every week to save money.
Added a little cajun seasoning to the patty mix and a dash of hot sauce on top for a little kick, and it was chef's kiss. The base recipe is perfect for tweaking to your own taste preferences!
Made these for my partner for our at home date night with milkshakes and fries, and they said it was better than our last date at an actual fancy burger restaurant. Win for cheap, cozy date nights!
I have a tiny apartment kitchen with almost no counter space and I still pulled these off with zero issues! No fancy equipment needed, just a frying pan and a spatula. 10/10 for small space cooking.