Traditional Wisconsin Fish Boil
intro
A beloved Door County, Wisconsin communal meal of tender boiled whitefish, potatoes, and onions, finished with a dramatic boil-over to remove bitter fish oils.
Ingredients
Steps
Set Up Salted Boil Pot
Set up an outdoor 20-liter (5-gallon) stock pot on a propane burner or wood-fired rig over high heat. Fill the pot with 15 liters (4 gallons) of cold water, add 120g kosher salt, 1 tablespoon whole black peppercorns, and 3 dried bay leaves. Cover the pot and bring to a full rolling boil, which takes approximately 15 minutes.
Add Unpeeled Red Potatoes
Once the water reaches a constant rolling boil (100°C/212°F, with large bubbles breaking continuously on the surface), add all 680g whole unpeeled scrubbed small red potatoes. Maintain high heat to keep the boil steady, leave the pot uncovered, and set a timer for 12 minutes—potatoes will be partially tender, not fully cooked, when the timer goes off.
Add Peeled Onion Wedges
When the 12-minute potato timer elapses, add all 340g 5cm-thick peeled yellow onion wedges to the pot. Stir gently with a long-handled slotted spoon to fully submerge the onions, keep heat set to high to maintain a rolling boil, leave the pot uncovered, and reset the timer for 8 minutes.
Lower Fish Basket Into Boil
When the 8-minute onion timer goes off, lower 900g of 5cm-thick skin-on lake whitefish chunks (held in a wire mesh boil basket for easy removal) into the boiling water, ensuring all fish pieces are fully submerged. Maintain high heat to return the pot to a rolling boil as quickly as possible, leave uncovered, and set a timer for exactly 10 minutes.
Crank Heat for Boil Over
When 30 seconds remain on the 10-minute fish timer, turn heat to maximum (add one small split of dry hardwood to wood-fired rigs, or turn propane burners to full) to trigger a dramatic frothy boil-over that spills 2-3cm of water over the pot rim for 30 seconds—this washes bitter floating fish oil off the water’s surface. After 30 seconds, reduce heat to medium-low to stop the overflow.
Drain and Arrange Cooked Food
Carefully lift the wire fish basket out of the pot, shaking gently to drain excess water, then use the long slotted spoon to remove all potatoes and onions. Arrange drained fish, potatoes, and onions on a large serving platter, patting lightly with paper towels to remove surface moisture, and serve hot with 113g melted unsalted butter for dipping and lemon wedges on the side.
Tips
2.If cooking indoors on a stovetop without an outdoor rig, skip the intentional boil-over to avoid stovetop mess: instead, use a ladle to carefully skim all floating fish oil from the water surface during the final 2 minutes of fish cook time.
3.Stick to firm, mild whitefish like lake whitefish, cod, or haddock for this recipe: delicate fish like tilapia will fall apart during the vigorous boil, and oily fish like salmon will leave a strong, unpleasant residual flavor.

OMG, I grew up going to Door County fish boils every summer with my grandparents and I’ve been too scared to try making it at home! This recipe was so straightforward, even the dramatic boil over step worked perfectly first try. My whole family went back for seconds, the potatoes were perfectly tender and the whitefish didn’t get mushy at all. Total game changer for our weekend family dinners!
Tried this for our backyard cookout last weekend and I was shocked how much everyone loved it! I used cod instead of the traditional whitefish because that’s what my grocery store had, and it still turned out great. Only question: do you have to use the kerosene to get the boil over, or is there a safer alternative for when we have little kids running around?
Made this on our last camping trip up in the Rockies and it was *chef’s kiss*. We cooked it right over the campfire in a big stock pot, no fancy equipment needed. My buddies kept saying it tasted better than the restaurant version we had in Wisconsin last fall. 10/10 would make again for the next camp potluck.
My kids are so picky about fish, they usually turn their noses up at anything that isn’t fried fish sticks. I saw this recipe and figured I’d give it a shot since it’s such a fun, interactive meal. THEY BOTH ASKED FOR SECONDS. I served it with the melted butter and lemon wedges like the recipe said, and even the 7 year old ate all his veggies with it. SO good, adding this to our weekly rotation.
I wanted to love this, I really did. I followed the recipe exactly but my fish came out really overcooked and the potatoes were still rock hard in the middle. I think maybe my burner wasn’t hot enough? I’m gonna give it another shot next weekend because the flavor was there, just the timing was off for me.
Wait a second, I’ve lived in Georgia my whole life and I’d never even heard of a Wisconsin fish boil until I saw this recipe! I made it for our Sunday supper club and everyone was raving. I added a little Old Bay to the boil water because I can’t help myself, don’t @ me. Is this traditionally served with coleslaw on the side? I made a vinegar slaw to cut the butter and it paired perfectly.
I was worried this would be too heavy for 100 degree Arizona weather, but we made it on our back patio last night when it cooled down and it was perfect. I used local white bass from the lake near our house instead of lake whitefish, and it worked beautifully. The boil over was so fun to watch, my neighbor even came over to see what all the commotion was and left with a plate!
Quick question — can I prep the potatoes and onions ahead of time for this? I’m hosting a big group next Saturday and want to get as much done ahead as possible so I’m not stuck chopping while everyone is hanging out.
Worked as a cook at a Door County tourist spot back in the 70s making these fish boils every weekend, and I’ll say this recipe is spot on. Most home recipes skip the step of boiling the potatoes first before adding the fish, and that’s the secret to not having everything turn into a mushy mess. Great job nailing the classic ratios!
Made this with salmon instead of whitefish because that’s what we had in the freezer from our last fishing trip, and it was incredible! The simple salt and pepper boil let the salmon flavor really shine, and the melted butter dip was chef’s kiss. Will definitely be making this all summer long.
Wait, the recipe says to do the boil over when the fish is done, but when I did that all the hot water splattered everywhere and made a huge mess on my stove. I had to spend 20 minutes cleaning melted butter and fish scum off my stovetop. Did I do something wrong here? Because the food itself was good, but the mess was not worth it for a weeknight meal.
Took this to our Packers tailgate last weekend and it was the hit of the parking lot. We set up a little propane burner out the back of the truck, did the full boil over, and people were coming over from three rows over to get a bite. Served it with rye bread, coleslaw, and cold Spotted Cow, just like you’d get up north. 10/10, will be a staple for every home game from now on.
So happy this recipe is naturally gluten free! I have celiac and I’m always hunting for fun, crowd-pleasing meals I can bring to potlucks without having to make a separate dish for myself. I double checked all my ingredients and didn’t have any cross contact issues, and even my gluten-eating friends were raving about it.
Just caught my first batch of lake whitefish up in northern Wisconsin last weekend and had no clue how to cook it. A buddy sent me this recipe and I figured I’d give it a shot. Let me tell you, even as someone who burns toast half the time, this turned out incredible. My wife said it’s the best thing I’ve ever cooked. Wild!
I was shocked how affordable this meal is to make for a crowd! I fed 6 people for under $25 total, which is unheard of for seafood around here. The ingredients are super basic, no fancy spices or specialty items required. Even my teen son, who eats us out of house and home, was full after one plate. Perfect for large family gatherings on a budget.
Made this for my boyfriend’s birthday since he’s from Wisconsin and has been homesick lately. He said it tasted exactly like the fish boils his family used to go to when he was a kid. He almost cried, y’all. Best birthday dinner win I’ve ever pulled off. Thank you so much for sharing this authentic recipe!