amish chicken
intro
Tender, juicy bone-in chicken baked to golden crispness in a creamy, lightly seasoned onion gravy—this classic Amish comfort food is simple, hearty, and made for gathering.
Ingredients
Steps
Preheat and Prep Chicken
Preheat your oven to 375°F (190°C). Pat all chicken pieces completely dry with paper towels, discarding any excess moisture. Use the chef knife to trim any large overhanging skin flaps, leaving a 1/2-inch skin overhang to crisp as it bakes. The chicken surface should feel dry to the touch, with no damp patches remaining.
Mix Seasoned Flour Coating
In the brushed stainless steel mixing bowl, combine the all-purpose flour, sweet paprika, garlic powder, 1 teaspoon of the kosher salt, and black pepper. Use the wire whisk to mix for 30 seconds until all spices are evenly distributed through the flour, with no concentrated clumps of paprika remaining. The mixture will be a pale tan color flecked with faint red.
Dredge Chicken Evenly
Working one piece at a time, press each chicken piece into the seasoned flour, turning to coat all sides including the skin and exposed bone ends. Shake off excess flour gently over the bowl, so only a thin, even coating remains on each piece. Set dredged pieces on the empty edge of the cutting board as you work. Reserve 1 tablespoon of the seasoned flour in the mixing bowl for making gravy.
Brown Chicken in Butter
Place the cut tablespoons of unsalted butter into the stoneware baking dish, then set the dish in the preheating oven for 3 minutes until the butter is fully melted, foamy, and fragrant. Carefully remove the hot dish from the oven to the cork trivet, then arrange the dredged chicken pieces skin-side down in the melted butter in a single layer, leaving 1/2-inch gaps between pieces for even cooking.
Bake First Side Until Golden
Return the baking dish to the preheated oven, and bake uncovered for 30 minutes. Do not flip or disturb the chicken during this time. When the 30 minutes elapse, the chicken skin touching the dish will be deep golden brown, and the flour coating will have set into a crisp, buttery crust.
Add Onions and Gravy
Use the tongs to flip all chicken pieces so they are skin-side up, taking care not to tear the crisp crust. Scatter the thinly sliced yellow onion evenly around the chicken pieces in the butter. Whisk the reserved 1 tablespoon of seasoned flour into the chicken broth until completely smooth, then pour the broth mixture and heavy cream over and around the chicken, keeping liquid below the top of the chicken skin to avoid soggy crust. Sprinkle the remaining 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt over the chicken tops.
Bake Until Tender
Return the baking dish to the oven, and bake uncovered for an additional 40-45 minutes, until the chicken reaches an internal temperature of 165°F (74°C) measured at the thickest part away from bone. The gravy will be bubbling and thickened, and the exposed chicken skin will be deep golden and crisp. Remove from the oven to the trivet and let rest for 5 minutes.
Plate and Garnish
Use the tongs to transfer chicken pieces to the matte off-white dinner plate, spoon a generous amount of thick gravy and cooked onions over the top of the chicken, and sprinkle with freshly chopped flat-leaf parsley for a bright, fresh garnish. Serve warm.
Tips
2.Keep liquid below the chicken skin line when adding gravy: pouring broth or cream directly over the crisped skin will make it turn soggy during the second bake, rather than staying crunchy and golden.
3.Don’t skip the 5-minute rest after baking: this short pause lets the chicken juices redistribute into the meat instead of running out onto the plate when cut, and allows the gravy to thicken to the perfect coating consistency.

OMG this baked chicken was an absolute game changer for our Sunday family dinner! The skin was so crispy, the meat was juicy all the way through, even the breast pieces which I always manage to dry out. My 3 kids went back for seconds, and my husband asked if we could add this to our weekly rotation. 10/10, so easy too!
I was skeptical a baked chicken could beat my grilled version, but wow, this seasoning blend is insane. I used bone-in thighs like the recipe said, tossed in that simple flour and spice mix, and it came out perfect. Took this to my buddy’s cookout last weekend and people were asking for the recipe left and right.
Super easy recipe that’s perfect for my weekly meal prep! I made a big batch on Sunday, portioned it out with roasted veggies and mashed potatoes, and it reheated like a dream all week. Didn’t even get soggy, which is my biggest pet peeve with baked chicken meal prep. Will make again for sure.
Has anyone tried making this with a gluten free flour blend? I have celiac and would love to make this for my grandma’s birthday dinner next week, it looks so cozy and nostalgic!
Uh oh, I think I messed up? I followed the recipe exactly but my chicken skin came out really soggy, not crispy at all. Did I crowd the pan too much? I used a 9x13 dish and stuffed 8 pieces in there because I was cooking for my roommates.
This tastes exactly like the Amish baked chicken my grandma used to make when we’d visit her farm in Pennsylvania as kids! The simple seasoning, no fancy ingredients, just pure comfort food. I served it with buttered noodles and green beans and it felt like a hug on a plate. SO good.
Made this for our office potluck yesterday and the whole pan was gone in 10 minutes. People were literally scraping the crumbs off the baking sheet! So easy to throw together the night before too, I just prepped the seasoned chicken in the fridge and popped it in the oven when I got to work. 10/10.
Wait how do you get the seasoning to stick to the chicken? I tried making this last night and half the flour spice mix slid off the skin while it was baking, so it was pretty bland. Did I forget to pat the chicken dry first? I was in a rush getting the kids to soccer practice so I might have skipped that step.
I’ve been cooking for 40+ years and I still come back to simple, no-fuss recipes like this. People overcomplicate chicken with 20 different spices and fancy glazes, but this classic blend of paprika, garlic, salt, and pepper is all you need. Cooked low and slow so it’s fall-off-the-bone tender, absolutely perfect.
Made this after a long day of hiking last weekend, threw it in the oven when we got home and took a quick shower while it cooked. Came out to the whole cabin smelling amazing, served it with some coleslaw and cornbread we picked up on the drive up. Zero effort, maximum coziness. Will be a regular on our cabin trip menu from now on.
I have the pickiest 7 year old on the planet who refuses to eat any chicken that isn’t dinosaur-shaped nuggets, and he ate TWO whole drumsticks of this last night!!! I almost fell out of my chair. The flavor is mild but so tasty, not spicy at all, perfect for little kid palates.
I run a little diner in rural Ohio and I tested this recipe for our weekly comfort food special last week. We sold out by 6pm both days we ran it! Customers were saying it was the best baked chicken they’d had in years. I’m adding it to our permanent menu, no joke.
This is my new go-to weeknight dinner! It’s so easy to throw together, no weird specialty ingredients I have to run to three different grocery stores to find, and the cook time is totally hands off so I can help my kid with homework while it bakes. Served it with roasted broccoli and mac and cheese last night, zero complaints.
Has anyone tried adapting this for the air fryer? I don’t love heating up my whole oven in the summer when it’s 90 degrees out, but this chicken looks too good to wait until fall to make.
I’ve been making Amish baked chicken for our church suppers for 30 years, and I have to say this recipe is even better than my old one! The little touch of paprika in the seasoning gives it such a nice warm flavor without being overpowering. I brought 12 pieces last Sunday and came home with an empty dish.
I made this for a neighbor who just had a new baby last week, and she texted me two days later saying it was the best meal train meal they’d gotten the whole time. It travels really well, reheats perfectly, and is just plain comforting, which is exactly what people need when they’re adjusting to a new baby.
This recipe is so budget friendly! I grabbed a whole family pack of chicken pieces for under $8, already had all the spices and flour in my pantry, and it fed me and my two roommates for two nights. No fancy expensive ingredients, just good hearty food that doesn’t break the bank. Obsessed.
I tried making this for a date night last week and accidentally used smoked paprika instead of regular, and I thought I ruined it! Turns out it was amazing, the smoky flavor paired so well with the garlic and the juicy chicken. My date thought I was a total cooking genius, little does he know I messed up the ingredient measurement. 😂
Made this for our multigenerational Sunday supper last weekend, and my 92 year old grandpa said it tasted just like the chicken his mom used to make when he was growing up on an Amish farm in Indiana. I almost cried, that’s the best review I could ever get for a recipe. Thank you so much for sharing this!
The leftovers from this make the BEST chicken salad the next day! I chopped up the leftover chicken, mixed it with a little mayo, celery, onion, and a pinch of dill, and had amazing chicken salad sandwiches for lunch all week. Don’t sleep on the leftovers, they’re just as good as the fresh baked version!