Amish Cookies
intro
Soft, pillowy, buttery Amish sugar cookies with a delicate tender crumb, lightly sweet and sugar-dusted— the timeless, comforting baked treat passed down through generations of Pennsylvania Dutch communities.
Ingredients
Steps
Whisk Dry Ingredients
In the medium brushed stainless steel mixing bowl, combine 360g (3 cups) all-purpose flour, 1 tsp baking powder, 1 tsp baking soda, 1/2 tsp fine sea salt, and 1/4 tsp ground nutmeg. Use the sage-handled silicone spatula to whisk the mixture for 30 seconds until fully uniform, with no streaks of spice or leavening visible. Set the bowl aside.
Cream Butter and Sugar
Place 226g (1 cup) softened unsalted butter and 200g (1 cup) granulated sugar in the large brushed stainless steel mixing bowl. Using the matte white electric hand mixer on medium speed, beat the mixture for 3 full minutes until it is pale, fluffy, and light lemon-yellow in color, scraping down the sides of the bowl with the silicone spatula halfway through to ensure no lumps of unblended butter remain.
Mix in Wet Ingredients
Add 1 large room-temperature egg, 60ml (1/4 cup) room-temperature whole milk, and 1 tsp pure vanilla extract to the creamed butter mixture. Beat on low speed for 30 seconds until fully combined, stopping to scrape down the bowl sides once. Do not overmix, as this will make cookies tough; the mixture should be smooth with no visible streaks of egg.
Fold in Dry Ingredients
Add the dry flour mixture from the medium bowl to the wet batter in 3 equal additions, folding gently with the silicone spatula after each addition. Mix only until no dry flour streaks remain; the dough will be soft, thick, and slightly sticky, similar in consistency to thick cake batter. Do not overwork the dough to keep cookies tender.
Prep Baking Sheet
Preheat oven to 190°C (375°F) with a rack positioned in the center. Line the heavy-gauge light gray aluminized steel baking sheet with the cut unbleached tan parchment paper, smoothing it flat to eliminate air bubbles. Set the prepared sheet near the mixing bowl.
Scoop and Coat Dough
Pour 3 tablespoons of granulated sugar into the small cream stoneware ramekin. Use the spring-loaded stainless steel cookie scoop to portion 2-tablespoon (30g) balls of dough, rolling each briefly between clean palms to form a smooth round. Roll each dough ball in the sugar to coat completely, then place them 8cm (3 inches) apart on the parchment-lined baking sheet, leaving room for spreading. You will fit 8 dough balls per batch.
Bake the Cookies
Place the first baking sheet on the center oven rack. Bake for 8-10 minutes at 190°C (375°F), until the edges are just light golden brown and the centers look slightly puffed and under-set; they will continue to set as they cool. Do not overbake, as this will turn the soft cookies hard and crunchy.
Cool Cookies Fully
Let the cookies rest on the hot baking sheet for 5 full minutes after removing from the oven, then use the spatula to transfer them to the chrome wire cooling rack to cool completely to room temperature. Repeat the scooping, baking, and cooling process with the remaining dough. Once fully cooled, stack cookies on the cream stoneware serving platter.
Tips
2.Resist the urge to overbake: cookies are done when edges are just pale golden and centers look slightly puffed and under-set. They will finish setting on the hot baking sheet over 5 minutes, ensuring a soft (not crunchy) texture that lasts 4-5 days stored in an airtight container at room temperature.
3.Leave at least 3 inches (8cm) of space between dough balls on the baking sheet: the dough spreads significantly as it bakes, and crowded cookies will merge into uneven, misshapen batches that don’t cook evenly.

OMG these are SO good! I baked these for my boys’ after-school snack yesterday and they demolished the entire batch in less than 24 hours. They’re so soft and buttery, not too sweet, perfect with a glass of cold milk. Total game changer for my go-to cookie rotation! Will absolutely be making these for our church potluck next Sunday.
I’m literally brand new to baking and I was so nervous these would flop, but they came out perfect! The instructions were so straightforward and easy to follow, no weird fancy ingredients required. Mine didn’t spread too much at all, they stayed nice and puffy just like the photos. My roommate said they’re better than the ones from the bakery down the street 😭
Made these with my 7 year old daughter over the weekend for her soccer team snack, and all the parents were asking for the recipe! We rolled half in cinnamon sugar and half in rainbow sprinkles, and both versions were a huge hit. The soft texture holds up so well even when you toss them in a snack bag for practice, no crumbles everywhere. 10/10, will be a weekend staple in our house.
These were really tasty! Super soft, just like the name says. My only tiny note is that I found them a touch too sweet for my taste, so next time I’ll cut the sugar by 2 tbsp and see how that goes. Brought them to my book club and everyone else raved, so it’s definitely just a personal preference thing!
Wait no way, these only take 30 minutes to make? I tried them at my friend’s place last night and they were insane, 10/10! Quick question though: I live in a dorm with just a tiny toaster oven and a cheap mixing bowl, no stand mixer or fancy bakeware. Do you think these would still turn out okay if I make them in my room?
I’ve been searching for a copycat of the Amish sugar cookies my grandma used to make when we visited her in Ohio as a kid, and THIS IS IT. They’re exactly the soft, melt-in-your-mouth, slightly tangy (thanks to the sour cream, I swear!) cookies I remember. I cried a little when I took the first bite, no joke. Thank you so much for sharing this recipe, it’s going in the family recipe book for sure.
I made a triple batch of these for our family reunion over the weekend and not a single cookie was left. People were packing them up to take home before we even finished serving lunch! I added a little lemon zest to half the dough for a bright twist and it was chef’s kiss. So easy to throw together even when you’re making a huge batch, no stress at all.
I bake for the local farmers market every Saturday, and I added these cookies to my lineup last week. Sold out in 45 minutes! I had multiple regulars come back specifically to ask if I’d have them again this week. The soft texture holds up even when it’s 85 degrees out, which is a miracle for baked goods around here. Absolute new best-seller.
Quick question! I want to make these for my holiday cookie exchange in a couple weeks, can you freeze the dough ahead of time? I like to prep all my cookie doughs the weekend before so I don’t go crazy baking 6 different kinds in one night. These are my top pick for the exchange already after testing a batch last night, they’re unreal.