Amish Oatmeal Pie
intro
A cozy, spiced vintage Amish pie with chewy caramelized oat filling, a budget-friendly nut-free alternative to pecan pie, perfect for homestyle gatherings.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep oven and crust
Preheat your oven to 350°F (175°C) with a rack positioned in the middle. Unroll the 9-inch unbaked pie crust and press it firmly into a standard 9-inch pie dish, crimping the edges decoratively if desired; set aside.
Melt and cool butter
Place 6 tablespoons (85 grams) of unsalted butter in a small microwave-safe bowl, heat in 30-second increments at 50% microwave power until fully melted (about 1 minute total), then set aside to cool for 5 minutes so it does not cook the eggs when mixed.
Combine wet ingredients
In a large 3-quart mixing bowl, whisk the 2 beaten room-temperature eggs, 3/4 cup (180ml) whole milk, cooled melted butter, and 1 teaspoon (5ml) vanilla extract together until fully smooth, with no streaks of egg remaining, about 1 minute of steady whisking.
Mix in dry ingredients
Add the 3/4 cup (150g) packed light brown sugar, 1 cup (90g) old-fashioned rolled oats, 1 teaspoon (2g) ground cinnamon, and 1/4 teaspoon (1.5g) fine salt to the wet mixture. Stir with a wooden spoon for 45 seconds until all ingredients are evenly coated and no dry pockets of sugar or oats remain.
Fill and bake the pie
Pour the entire oat filling mixture into the prepared pie crust, spreading it evenly with a silicone spatula. Place the pie dish on a rimmed metal baking sheet (to catch any bubbling drips) and bake for 45 minutes at 350°F (175°C), until the edges are fully set and the center jiggles only slightly when the dish is gently nudged.
Cool pie before serving
Remove the pie from the oven using oven mitts and transfer it to a wire cooling rack. Let it rest for 30 minutes at room temperature to allow the filling to set fully before slicing into 8 equal wedges to serve.
Tips
2.If your pie crust edges start to brown too quickly (before the 35-minute mark of baking), cover the edges loosely with a strip of aluminum foil to prevent burning.
3.For a classic Amish serving suggestion, top each slightly warm slice with a dollop of unsweetened freshly whipped cream or a small scoop of vanilla bean ice cream.

OMG y’all, this Amish Oatmeal Pie was the unexpected hit of our church potluck last Sunday! I was nervous because I’d never made it before, but it was SO easy to throw together even with my chaotic morning of getting the kids out the door for Sunday school. Tastes like a warm, cozy cross between pecan pie and a chewy oatmeal cookie—people were coming back for second slices before we even finished the main dishes! Will 100% be adding this to my regular fall baking rotation, total game changer for when I need a no-fuss dessert for a crowd.
Super easy recipe, the 55 minute cook time was totally spot on for my oven! I added a tiny dash of extra cinnamon and a handful of chopped walnuts on top because I love a little extra crunch in my pies. My picky 7 year old asked for seconds at dinner last night, which is basically a Michelin star rating in my book. Only tiny note: I wish the recipe mentioned letting it cool completely before slicing—my first piece was a little goopy when I cut it right out of the oven, but once it set up for an hour it was absolute perfection. SO good.
Made this last weekend for my weekly meal prep dessert portions and it held up perfectly all week in the fridge! It’s not overly sweet which I love, so good with a little dollop of whipped cream on top after a long work day. The easy difficulty rating is no joke—I even made it while my toddler was hanging on my leg begging for snacks the whole time and it still turned out flawless. Already sent the recipe to my mom and sister, they’re both planning to make it for their Thanksgiving tables this year!