Amish Sugar Cookies
intro
Soft, melt-in-your-mouth old-fashioned sugar cookies with a delicate, tender crumb, a beloved Amish community staple perfect for sharing.
Ingredients
Steps
Whisk Dry Ingredients Together
In a medium mixing bowl, whisk together 315g (2 ½ cups) all-purpose flour, 1 teaspoon baking soda, ½ teaspoon cream of tartar, and ¼ teaspoon fine table salt until fully combined, about 30 seconds. Set the dry ingredient mixture aside.
Cream Butter and Sugars
In a large mixing bowl (using a hand mixer or stand mixer on medium speed), cream 113g (½ cup) softened unsalted butter, 200g (1 cup) granulated sugar, and 60g (½ cup) powdered sugar together for 2 minutes until light, fluffy, and pale ivory in color. Scrape down the sides of the bowl with a silicone spatula halfway through mixing.
Mix In Wet Ingredients
Reduce mixer speed to low, then add 120ml (½ cup) neutral canola oil, 2 room-temperature large eggs, and 5ml (1 teaspoon) pure vanilla extract. Mix on low speed for 1 minute until the batter is fully smooth, taking care not to overmix to avoid tough cookies.
Combine and Chill Dough
Gradually add the reserved dry flour mixture to the wet batter, mixing on the lowest mixer speed only until no dry flour streaks remain, about 45 seconds. Cover the bowl tightly with plastic wrap and chill the dough in the refrigerator for 30 minutes to prevent excessive spreading during baking.
Preheat Oven, Prep Station
While the dough chills, preheat your oven to 190°C (375°F) and line 2 rimmed baking sheets with unbleached parchment paper. Place the reserved 65g (⅓ cup) granulated sugar in a small shallow dish. Once dough is chilled, scoop 2-tablespoon (30g) portions, roll each into a smooth ball, coat fully in the granulated sugar, and place 5cm (2 inches) apart on the prepared baking sheets.
Bake and Rest Cookies
Bake one sheet at a time on the middle oven rack for 8 to 9 minutes, until cookie edges are just set and pale golden (centers will look slightly puffy and underbaked). Let cookies rest on the hot baking sheet for 5 minutes to set, then transfer to a wire cooling rack to cool completely, as they will firm up as they cool.
Tips
2.Use room-temperature butter and eggs: Cold ingredients will not cream properly to create a light, fluffy batter, leading to dense, tough cookies instead of the signature tender crumb.
3.Never skip the 30-minute dough chill: Warm, unchilled dough spreads too quickly in the hot oven, resulting in thin, flat, crispy cookies instead of the classic thick, soft Amish sugar cookie texture.

OMG these are SO good! I brought a batch to my kid’s soccer potluck last weekend and every single cookie was gone in 10 minutes. People were asking me for the recipe before halftime even hit! I added a tiny extra dash of nutmeg because my grandma always did that with her sugar cookies, and it worked perfectly. So soft, not too sweet, exactly the old-school cookie I was craving. 10/10
I was so nervous to make these because I usually burn every cookie I bake, but this recipe was actually so easy! The instructions were super straightforward, I didn’t even have to Google any techniques. Mine came out pillowy soft just like the photos, I’m so proud of myself. Only thing is I rolled mine a little too thick so they needed an extra 2 minutes in the oven, no big deal!
Made these for my weekly book club meetup and everyone raved. The texture is unreal — they stay soft for DAYS if you keep them in an airtight container, which is a game changer for me because I hate when sugar cookies turn crunchy after a day. I dipped half of mine in white chocolate and sprinkled crushed peppermint on top for a little holiday flair, chef’s kiss.
Solid cookie recipe, not gonna lie. I’m usually a chocolate chip guy but my girlfriend begged me to make sugar cookies for her office party, so I gave these a shot. Didn’t have any cream of tartar so I used a little extra baking powder and a splash of lemon juice, turned out great. Only giving 4 stars because I wish the recipe noted substitutes for cream of tartar up front!
Wait a second, I grew up eating these at my neighbor’s house in Amish country and this recipe is dead on! I was worried online recipes would be too sweet or have a weird artificial vanilla aftertaste, but no — this tastes exactly like Mrs. Zook’s cookies I’d get after school as a kid. Absolute perfection.
I swapped the all purpose flour for a 1:1 gluten free baking blend and these still turned out incredible! I was worried they’d spread too much or get grainy, but they held their shape perfectly and were just as soft as the regular version. My gluten eating husband couldn’t even tell the difference. Will be making these for all our family gatherings from now on!
Made these with my 7 year old daughter last night for her class snack day. She had a blast rolling the dough in colored sugar, and the dough was so easy for little hands to work with — no sticky mess, which is a miracle for baking with kids. Her teacher sent me a message this morning saying all the kids asked for seconds!
Game changer. I’ve been using the same sugar cookie recipe for 15 years for our annual church potluck and I’m officially swapping it for this one. The texture is so soft it almost melts in your mouth, and you don’t even need to chill the dough for hours? Hello, that saves me so much time on busy bake sale weekends. 10/10, no notes.
I’ve been baking Amish sugar cookies for over 60 years and this recipe is as close to the original as I’ve found online. The secret is the sour cream, right? So many modern recipes skip it and wonder why their cookies are dry and crunchy. This one gets it right. I added a simple powdered sugar glaze on top like I always do, and my grandkids ate half the batch before dinner.
Wait these are perfect for meal prep snack stashes! I baked a big batch on Sunday, portioned them out into snack bags, and they stayed perfectly soft all week for my work lunches. I didn’t even add frosting, just a little cinnamon sugar on top before baking, and they hit that sweet spot without being overpowering. Great recipe for people who don’t have time to bake every night.
Help! I followed the recipe exactly but my cookies spread super thin in the oven and turned crispy around the edges, not soft at all. What did I do wrong? I used salted butter instead of unsalted, would that do it? I was really excited for these, so I want to try again!
These are the perfect base cookie for cutout shapes! I know it says drop cookie but I rolled the dough out a little and used my heart shaped cookie cutters for Valentine’s day, and they held their edges perfectly. I topped them with cream cheese frosting and sprinkles, and my partner said they were better than the bakery cookies downtown. Will absolutely be making these again for every holiday.
I don’t bake much, usually I’m manning the smoker, but my wife asked me to make a dessert for our family dinner last weekend so I picked this recipe because it said easy. Let me tell you, it was actually easy! Even I didn’t mess it up. My mother in law said it was the best sugar cookie she’s ever had, which is the highest possible praise coming from her. I might even start baking more often now.
I made these vegan by swapping the butter for vegan stick butter and the egg for a flax egg, and they turned out so good! I was worried the texture would be off, but they were just as soft and pillowy as the photos look. I brought them to my office and none of my non-vegan coworkers could tell they were plant based. Great, flexible recipe!
These are SO addictive. I made a batch last night and told myself I’d only eat one, then I had three with my morning coffee. Oops. They’re not cloyingly sweet like a lot of store bought sugar cookies, which I love — the buttery, vanilla flavor really comes through. Do yourself a favor and make these, you won’t regret it.
Made these in my tiny dorm kitchen with just a hand mixer and a toaster oven, and they still came out perfect! I didn’t even have a rolling pin, I just pressed the dough balls down with the bottom of a glass dipped in sugar, like my mom taught me. My dorm mates are already begging me to make another batch this weekend.
I make dozens of cookie tins every Christmas to give out to neighbors, and these are going to be the star of the tin this year. They hold up really well to being packed with other cookies, don’t get stale fast, and they look so pretty with a little colored sugar dusted on top. I tested three different sugar cookie recipes last month and this one is by far the best.
I cut the granulated sugar by 2 tablespoons because I prefer less sweet desserts, and these were absolutely perfect. The vanilla and butter flavors really shine when you dial the sugar back a little, and they still had that perfect soft, chewy center that everyone raves about. Super versatile recipe that’s easy to tweak to your own taste preferences. Only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is I wish the recipe had notes for adjusting sweetness for people who don’t like super sweet treats!