Amish Sugar Cookies
intro
Soft, pillowy, melt-in-your-mouth Amish sugar cookies with crisp sugar-dusted edges—this timeless homestead treat requires no fancy equipment for cozy, old-fashioned sweetness.
Ingredients
Steps
Sift Dry Ingredients
Set the medium stainless steel mixing bowl on the counter. Place the fine-mesh sieve over the bowl, and add 2 ¾ cups all-purpose flour, 1 tsp baking soda, ½ tsp baking powder, ½ tsp fine sea salt, and ¼ tsp ground nutmeg to the sieve. Sift the mixture twice to fully combine and remove any lumps, then set aside. The finished dry blend will be uniformly pale cream, with no dark clumps of nutmeg visible.
Cream Butter and Sugar
Place the large stainless steel mixing bowl on the counter. Add 1 cup softened unsalted butter and 1 ½ cups granulated sugar to the bowl. Using the handheld electric mixer set to medium speed, cream the butter and sugar together for 3 full minutes, stopping once halfway to scrape down the bowl sides with the cream-colored silicone spatula. The finished mixture will be pale ivory, light and fluffy, with no visible lumps of butter.
Mix In Wet Ingredients
Reduce mixer speed to low. Add 1 room-temperature large egg to the creamed mixture, beating for 30 seconds until fully incorporated, then scrape down the bowl sides. Add ½ cup full-fat sour cream and 1 tsp pure vanilla extract, mixing on low for another 30 seconds until smooth, with no white streaks of sour cream remaining. Do not overmix at this stage to keep cookies tender.
Combine Dough Fully
Add the sifted dry ingredient mixture to the wet batter in 3 equal additions, folding gently with the silicone spatula after each addition, just until no dry flour streaks remain. The finished dough will be soft, thick, and slightly sticky, similar to thick cake batter. Overmixing will develop gluten and make tough cookies.
Chill Cookie Dough
Cover the top of the large mixing bowl tightly with clear plastic wrap, pressing the wrap directly against the dough surface to prevent a dry skin from forming. Refrigerate for 1 full hour, until the dough is firm enough to scoop without sticking to your hands. Chilling is critical to prevent excess spreading during baking.
Scoop and Sugar Dough
Once dough is chilled, preheat oven to 375°F (190°C) and line the large light gray baking sheet with unbleached parchment paper. Place ¼ cup granulated sugar in the small cream ramekin. Use the 3cm spring-loaded cookie scoop to portion 2-tbsp sized dough balls, rolling each gently between palms to form a smooth round, then rolling fully in granulated sugar to coat. Place dough balls 5cm apart on the parchment-lined sheet, 12 per batch.
Bake Until Golden Edged
Place the baking sheet on the middle oven rack. Bake for 8 to 10 minutes, until cookie edges are just pale golden brown, and centers are still slightly puffed and soft (centers will set as they cool). Do not overbake, as this will remove the signature soft texture. Remove from oven and let cookies rest on the sheet for 5 full minutes before moving.
Cool and Serve Cookies
After the 5-minute rest on the baking sheet, use the silicone spatula to transfer warm cookies to the chrome wire cooling rack to cool completely for 20 minutes. Once cooled, arrange cookies on the cream white ceramic serving platter. Cookies will stay soft for up to 5 days stored in an airtight container at room temperature.
Tips
2.Do not skip the 1-hour dough chill step: warm, soft dough spreads too quickly in the hot oven, resulting in thin, crisp cookies instead of thick, puffy ones; chilling also allows the flour to hydrate evenly for a more consistent crumb.
3.Err on the side of underbaking: pull cookies from the oven when edges are just barely pale gold, even if centers look slightly underdone. Residual heat from the baking sheet will set the centers as they rest, keeping cookies soft for up to 5 days in an airtight container.

OMG these Amish sugar cookies are INSANE. I brought a batch to my church potluck last Sunday and people were asking for the recipe before I even set the plate down! So soft, not too sweet, exactly the old-fashioned cookie I grew up eating at my grandma’s house in Ohio. 10 minute cook time is no joke, I knocked out 4 batches in under an hour for my kid’s soccer team snack too. Total game changer.
Super easy recipe, even for someone like me who burns 90% of the baked goods I attempt! These came out perfectly soft in the middle, slightly crispy around the edges just how I like. I rolled the dough balls in a little cinnamon sugar before baking and it was chef’s kiss. Only thing is I wish I’d doubled the batch because my roommates ate all of them in 10 minutes flat.
Made these for a family dinner last night and my 7 year old asked if we can have them every single night for dessert. They’re so simple to throw together after work, no fancy ingredients needed which is a huge win for busy weeknights. I didn’t even have to run to the grocery store, I had everything in my pantry already. SO good.
I’ve been making Amish sugar cookies for 40+ years and this recipe is dead on to the one my neighbor from Pennsylvania Dutch country gave me back in the 80s. No weird additives, just simple, honest, delicious cookie flavor. My only note is that if you like them a little firmer, you can bake them for 11 minutes instead of 10, works like a charm.
Took these to my office potluck on Friday and they were the first dessert gone, beat out three different batches of brownies even! The texture is unreal – so pillowy, not gritty like some sugar cookie recipes I’ve tried before. I did use salted butter instead of unsalted because that’s all I had, and it didn’t throw anything off at all.
These tasted really good, but my first batch spread way more than I expected and turned into super thin, almost lacy cookies. Did I do something wrong? I followed the recipe exactly, used room temp butter like it said, baked for 10 minutes at the right temp. Flavor is 10/10 but the shape was a little off for the cookie exchange I’m going to next week.
I made a big batch of these for meal prep snacks for my kids’ lunch boxes this week and they’re holding up so well! I stored them in an airtight container and they’re still just as soft on day 3 as they were right out of the oven. Way better than the store-bought sugar cookies I usually toss in their lunches, and way cheaper too. Will be making these on repeat.
Easy recipe, great flavor, but I feel like it’s missing a little something? I added a quarter teaspoon of almond extract to my second batch and that took it from good to amazing. If you’re a fan of that classic bakery sugar cookie taste, give the almond extract a shot, you won’t regret it.
Guys I made these in my tiny dorm oven last night and they actually turned out perfect??? I don’t even have a fancy mixer, I stirred everything by hand with a fork and they still came out soft and delicious. My whole floor came knocking when they smelled them baking, I ended up giving half the batch away. 10/10, no fancy equipment needed, perfect for broke college kids.
These are the PERFECT base cookie for decorating! They hold their shape just enough (if you chill the dough first, trust me) and don’t spread into blobs when you bake them, and the flavor is mild enough that it pairs amazing with royal icing or buttercream. I made these for my niece’s birthday party and decorated them like unicorns, all the kids went wild for them.
I was looking for a simple dessert to bring to our neighborhood BBQ last weekend and these did not disappoint. Not too heavy, not overly sweet, perfect after a big plate of brisket and sides. I sprinkled a little colored sugar on top to match our red white and blue theme and they looked so festive. Will be making these for every summer cookout from now on.
I tested these with dairy free butter this weekend for my son who has a dairy allergy, and they came out SO good! I was worried they’d taste weird or have an off texture, but you literally can’t tell the difference between these and the regular version. He brought them to his 3rd grade class party and none of the other kids even noticed they were dairy free. Total win for this mom!
These were fine, but way too sweet for my taste. I know they’re sugar cookies so that’s on me, but I cut the sugar by a third for my second batch and that was much more my speed. If you don’t have a massive sweet tooth, I’d recommend scaling the sugar back a little so the buttery flavor comes through more.
These taste exactly like the sugar cookies my Amish neighbor used to bring over when I was a kid growing up in Indiana. Soft, melt-in-your-mouth, just the right amount of sweetness, no weird fancy frills. I made a batch for my grandkids when they visited last weekend and they left with a whole tin of them to take home. Recipes like this are why I love simple, old-fashioned baking.
We made 12 dozen of these for our high school band bake sale last week and we sold out of them in 45 minutes! People were coming back to buy seconds, we even had a few people ask if we’d be selling them again at the next fundraiser. They’re so easy to make in big batches, which is perfect for bake sales when you need to make a ton of food fast. 10/10, will be our go-to sugar cookie from now on.
These are the perfect coffee dipper cookie. Not too crumbly, soft enough that they don’t break off in your coffee, just sweet enough to pair with a bitter black coffee in the morning. I keep a tin of them on my kitchen counter now for my morning coffee break, it’s the best little daily treat. Way better than the store-bought biscotti I used to buy.
Can you freeze the dough for these? I love keeping pre-portioned cookie dough in my freezer so I can bake a couple fresh cookies whenever I want without making a whole batch. The recipe sounds perfect, I just want to make sure it freezes well before I make a huge batch to portion out.
I made these for my husband for our first married Valentine’s Day and he said they’re better than the fancy bakery cookies we had at our wedding. I added a little pink sanding sugar on top to make them festive, and we ate half the batch while we watched our wedding video last night. Such a simple, sweet recipe that’s going to be a staple in our house for years to come.