Awful Awful
intro
The iconic ultra-thick New England frozen milkshake, named for being 'awful big, awful good'—creamy, frosty, and perfectly sweet for hot summer days.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep measured ingredients
Remove full-fat vanilla ice cream from the freezer and let it soften at room temperature (20°C/68°F) for exactly 5 minutes—do not let it melt fully to a liquid. Measure out 240ml ice-cold whole milk, 120ml chocolate syrup, 80g sweetened whipped cream, and 4 maraschino cherries, and set all ingredients within arm’s reach of the blender to avoid ice cream melt during prep.
Layer blender contents
Layer ingredients in the blender canister to prevent sticking and ensure even mixing: add 60ml (half the total) chocolate syrup to the bottom first, then pack all 900 grams of slightly softened vanilla ice cream into the canister, then pour the remaining 60ml chocolate syrup and all 240ml ice-cold whole milk over the top of the ice cream.
Blend to thick texture
Secure the blender lid tightly, blend on the lowest speed setting for 15 seconds, then turn the blender off and scrape down the canister sides with a rubber spatula to incorporate any unblended syrup stuck to the edges. Blend on low for an additional 10–15 seconds only; over-blending will thin the shake and ruin its signature thick texture. The finished blend should be thick enough that a metal spoon stands upright when inserted into the center.
Chill serving glasses
Let the blended shake rest for 1 minute to firm up slightly, then place 4 tall 16oz (473ml) soda fountain glasses into the freezer for 1 minute to chill. Chilled glassware prevents the frozen shake from melting too quickly after pouring.
Portion shakes into glasses
Remove the frosted glasses from the freezer, then pour the thick shake evenly into each glass, leaving a 2cm (3/4 inch) gap at the top of each glass for garnish. If the shake is too thick to pour freely, use a rubber spatula to gently guide it into the glasses; do not add extra milk to thin the mixture, as this will ruin the classic texture.
Garnish and serve immediately
Top each shake with 20g (about 2 tablespoons) of sweetened whipped cream, centered on the surface of the shake, then place one maraschino cherry on top of each whipped cream dollop. Insert a thick paper straw and long sundae spoon into each glass, and serve within 2 minutes of preparation to enjoy the signature frosty, ultra-thick consistency.
Tips
2.To make the classic vanilla Awful Awful, replace the chocolate syrup with an extra 5ml (1 tsp) pure vanilla extract and 30g (2 tbsp) powdered sugar, following all other steps exactly for the same thick texture.
3.If you don’t have time to chill glasses in the freezer, fill each glass with ice water for 2 minutes while you prep the shake, then pour out the water right before adding the shake for the same frosty, melt-resistant effect.

OMG, I grew up getting Awful Awfuls on summer trips to Rhode Island and I was SO sure I’d never be able to replicate that perfect thick, creamy texture at home! This recipe is a total game changer. Blended it up for my kids after their soccer practice yesterday and they begged for seconds. Tastes exactly like the original from the old Newport Creamery, no joke. 10/10, will be making these all summer long.
Super easy to throw together! I only had chocolate ice cream on hand instead of vanilla so I swapped it, added a little extra syrup, and it was chef’s kiss. My whole family devoured these at our backyard cookout this weekend, even my picky 7 year old who normally turns down every sweet treat that isn’t a popsicle. Only thing I’ll do different next time is make a double batch because we ran out in 10 minutes flat!
Solid recipe! I was worried 10 minutes was too good to be true but it really is that fast. Threw in a handful of crushed malt balls for a little extra crunch and it slapped. Perfect for those brutal Florida afternoons when you don’t want to turn on the oven and just need something cold and sweet. Would definitely make again.
First time making an Awful Awful and I had no idea they were supposed to be this thick! I almost added more milk because I thought my blender was stuck, but I trusted the recipe and wow, it was perfect. Brought a batch to my neighborhood potluck and everyone was asking for the recipe. SO good, I can’t believe I’ve been making weak, runny milkshakes my whole life!