Banana Pudding Milkshake
intro
A thick, creamy frozen twist on classic Southern banana pudding, packed with vanilla wafer crunch and sweet ripe banana flavor for a nostalgic sippable treat.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep frozen ingredients
1 hour before making the shakes, peel 2 large ripe bananas, slice into 1-inch thick rounds, arrange in a single layer on a parchment-lined small plate, and freeze. Ten minutes before blending, remove 4 cups (600g) of vanilla ice cream from the freezer to soften at room temperature for 5 minutes for easier, smoother blending (no heat required for this recipe).
Load blender base
Add the softened vanilla ice cream, frozen banana slices, 1 cup (240ml) cold whole milk, 1/3 cup (40g) dry instant vanilla pudding mix, and 1 tsp (5ml) pure vanilla extract to a high-speed blender. Do not add vanilla wafers at this stage to preserve their signature crunchy texture.
Blend until smooth
Secure the blender lid tightly, blend on medium-high speed for 30–45 seconds, pausing once to scrape down the jar sides with a rubber spatula halfway through, until the mixture is completely lump-free, thick, and pale golden. Do not blend for longer than 1 minute total, as over-blending will melt the shake to a thin, watery consistency.
Fold in wafer crunch
Drop 1 cup (120g) of vanilla wafer cookies into the blended shake base. Pulse the blender on low speed 2–3 times, for 1 second per pulse, to break the cookies into small pea-sized crumbs evenly distributed throughout the shake. Do not fully puree the wafers, as the crunchy bits replicate classic banana pudding texture.
Portion into glasses
Evenly divide the thick milkshake between 4 chilled 12-oz (350ml) tall glasses, leaving 1/2 inch of headspace at the top of each glass for toppings. If the shake is too thick to pour, stir in 1 tbsp (15ml) of extra cold milk at a time until it reaches a slow, sippable consistency.
Top and serve immediately
Top each milkshake with a 2-tbsp (30ml) dollop of sweetened whipped cream, 1 whole vanilla wafer tucked into the cream, and 1 thin fresh banana slice for garnish. Serve immediately with a wide metal or thick paper straw, as the shake will soften and melt within 10 minutes at room temperature.
Tips
2.Use ripe bananas spotted with small brown flecks for the sweetest, most aromatic flavor; unripe green bananas will add a starchy, bitter taste to the finished shake.
3.For an adult-only twist, stir 1 oz (30ml) of spiced rum or banana liqueur into the blender base before mixing, adding an extra 2 tablespoons of ice cream to offset the added liquid.

OMG this is such a game changer! I had a bunch of spotty overripe bananas sitting on my counter that I was gonna toss for compost, and this recipe popped up on my feed right as I was staring at them. Blended everything up, crumbled a handful of vanilla wafers right into the mix and sprinkled extra on top, just like classic banana pudding, and my whole family went crazy for it. My 7 year old asked for seconds before she even finished her first glass! It was the perfect sweet treat for our weekend backyard cookout, and I will 100% be making this on repeat all summer. So easy too, I didn’t even have to pull out a bunch of fancy equipment to pull it off.
Tried this last night for my partner who’s low key obsessed with all things banana flavored, and it did NOT disappoint. Only misstep on my end was I totally forgot to freeze the bananas ahead of time, so mine came out a little runny even when I piled in extra ice. The flavor was still chef’s kiss, just had that regular milk consistency instead of the thick, creamy milkshake texture I was going for. Will definitely plan ahead next time so I get that perfect thick shake vibe.
I brought a big batch of this to our neighborhood block party potluck this past weekend and people were hounding me for the recipe before I even set the pitcher down on the dessert table! I topped each serving with a little dollop of whipped cream and a mini vanilla wafer, and the whole batch was gone in 15 minutes flat. It’s so quick to throw together even for a crowd, no fussy steps, and everyone from wiggly toddlers to my 82 year old neighbor was raving about it. 10/10, this is going straight into my permanent summer recipe rotation.
Wait this is SO good and so cheap to make? I’m a college student on a super tight meal plan budget, and I already had spotty bananas, milk, and vanilla ice cream in my dorm mini fridge. Grabbed a tiny box of instant vanilla pudding mix from the campus market for like 99 cents, and this tasted better than the $8 milkshake I get from the fancy ice cream shop by the library. Total win for late night study sessions, literally no notes.
My kids are the pickiest eaters on the planet, I swear. They turn their nose up at 90% of the new recipes I try, but they begged me to make this milkshake three nights in a row after the first time I made it! I love that I can sneak a little extra plain Greek yogurt in there for protein and they don’t even notice. It’s sweet enough that they think it’s a special weekend treat, but not so loaded with added sugar that they’re bouncing off the walls an hour before bedtime. Absolute game changer for busy weeknights when we need a quick, no-fuss dessert.