banana pudding pops
intro
Creamy, nostalgic frozen pops loaded with ripe banana, smooth vanilla pudding, and crunchy vanilla wafer bits—just like classic Southern banana pudding, no oven required for hot summer days.
Ingredients
Steps
Crush Vanilla Wafers
Place 1 cup of vanilla wafer cookies into the small clear glass ramekin. Use the flat base of the stainless steel whisk to gently press and crush the cookies into coarse, pea-sized crumbs. Do not pulverize the cookies into fine powder, as small crunchy bits create classic banana pudding texture contrast. Set the remaining 1/2 cup of whole wafers aside for garnish.
Mash Ripe Bananas
Peel the 3 ripe spotty bananas, trim any bruised ends with the stainless steel paring knife, and place the fruit on the honey bamboo cutting board. Use the wire tines of the stainless steel whisk to mash the bananas into a mostly smooth puree with a few small, soft 1/4-inch lumps remaining. Avoid over-mashing into a completely liquid slurry, as small banana chunks add pleasant texture.
Whisk Pudding Base
Pour the cold whole milk, sweetened condensed milk, vanilla extract, and fine sea salt into the clear glass mixing bowl. Add the full packet of instant vanilla pudding mix, then whisk steadily at a moderate pace for 2 full minutes until the mixture is completely smooth with no dry lumps. Let the mixture rest for 5 minutes at room temperature to thicken slightly to a loose, pourable custard consistency.
Fold in Mix-Ins
Add the mashed banana puree and 3/4 of the crushed vanilla wafer crumbs to the thickened pudding base. Use the matte light grey silicone spatula to gently fold the ingredients together just until evenly distributed, about 8-10 slow turns. Do not over-stir, as this will make the base too runny and turn the cookie crumbs mushy.
Fill Pop Molds
Spoon the pudding mixture evenly into the 8 clear pop molds, filling each mold to 1/4 inch below the rim to leave room for expansion as the pops freeze. Tap the full mold tray firmly on the countertop 3-4 times to release any trapped air bubbles, then sprinkle the reserved crushed wafer crumbs evenly over the top of each mold.
Freeze Until Solid
Insert a wooden pop stick into the center of each filled mold, pushing it down 3/4 of the way into the mixture to ensure it stays anchored once frozen. Transfer the mold tray to a level middle shelf in the freezer, and freeze for a minimum of 6 hours (or up to overnight) until the pops are completely solid, with no soft give when you press the outside of the mold.
Unmold and Serve
When ready to serve, remove the mold tray from the freezer. Let the molds sit at room temperature for 2-3 minutes to loosen slightly, then gently pull the pop sticks to release the pops. If pops stick to the molds, run the outside of the mold under lukewarm (not hot) tap water for 5 seconds to release without melting the pop surface. Arrange the pops on the cream white ceramic serving platter to serve.
Tips
2.Keep crumb size coarse for texture: pea-sized wafer crumbs stay crunchy even after freezing, while finely ground crumbs will absorb moisture from the pudding and turn mushy, losing the classic textural contrast of banana pudding.
3.Avoid hot water when unmolding: hot water will melt the outer 1/8 inch of the pop instantly, leading to drips and a grainy, refrozen texture; lukewarm water for 5 seconds loosens the pop just enough to slide out cleanly with no melting.

OMG these are SO good! I made them for my kid’s end-of-summer pool party last weekend and every single pop was gone before the burgers even came off the grill. I added a tiny extra crumble of vanilla wafer on top before freezing and chef’s kiss. Game changer for hot Georgia days, no lie.
Super easy to throw together, no cook time is a win for my lazy summer meal prep. I was worried the banana would get weird and brown in the freezer? But mine turned out perfectly creamy, no weird texture at all. Only note is I wish I’d bought extra popsicle sticks because I ate three while I was unloading the dishwasher last night lmao.
I swapped the regular condensed milk for coconut condensed milk and used dairy-free vanilla wafers to make these vegan, and they turned out insane. Even my non-vegan roommate stole two out of my freezer! Will absolutely be making these again all August.
Brought these to our church potluck last Sunday and got so many recipe requests! People kept saying they tasted exactly like the classic banana pudding my grandma used to make, just frozen and way easier to eat while standing around chatting. 10/10, no notes.
Wait this is so easy even I can’t mess it up? I live in a dorm with just a mini fridge and a tiny freezer compartment, no fancy equipment needed. Spent like 10 minutes mixing everything up in a solo cup and poured it into the molds, woke up to perfect pops. Saved my summer from boring dining hall ice cream.
These are good but I found them a little too sweet for my taste? Next time I’ll cut the condensed milk by a quarter cup and maybe add a pinch of salt to balance it out. The banana flavor is perfect though, and the wafer bits get all soft and chewy in the freezer which is *chef’s kiss*.
My kids LOVED it. I let them help layer the banana slices and wafer crumbs in the molds and they were so proud to serve them to their dad after work. We didn’t have any popsicle molds so we used paper cups and they worked perfectly, no issues at all. Will be a staple in our house for the rest of summer.
I was skeptical these would feel too indulgent for my weekly meal prep, but they’re actually the perfect little sweet treat to have on hand when a sugar craving hits. I used Greek yogurt in place of half the pudding mix to add a little extra protein and it worked so well! Didn’t mess up the texture at all.
I’ve been making Southern banana pudding for 40+ years for family dinners, and I never thought to turn it into pops! My grandkids went crazy for these when they visited last weekend. They even asked if we could make a batch for their upcoming lemonade stand to sell. Makes this grandma’s heart so happy.
Tested these out as a limited special on my dessert menu last week and they blew up. Had customers coming back two days in a row asking when we’d have them back. Super low lift to make in big batches, zero cook time means I don’t have to tie up my oven during the lunch rush. Total win.
Y’all, I burn toast. I managed to make these without a single mishap? They taste exactly like the banana pudding I get at the local BBQ spot down the road. I did accidentally add extra vanilla extract and it still turned out amazing, this recipe is foolproof.